原文标题:《 DAO 金库 Token 发行 》
Jordan Stastny, Sam Bronstein
Block unicorn
Now let's talk about the DAO Vault.
A brief layman's description of the vault: The DAO's vault is its capital, in other words, it is all the DAO's resources (in the form of replaceable and non-replaceable tokens) that can be used to pay for and do things. When DAOs want to pay contributors, issue grants to consultants, or solidify partnerships through token exchanges, they use that money to do so. Since Treasury balances are often used as currency for transactions, they are discussed as simple cash-like assets. Usually not, and the purpose of this article is to discuss why that is and, more importantly, why it matters.
一方面,你可以在某种程度上原谅人们前面提到的误解。这一看,DAO 金库真的很像一张类似现金的资产负债表。金库中有一堆 Token ,您可以很容易地前往任何加密交易所来确定这些 Token 的价值。另一方面,几乎所有 DAO 金库中的很大一部分 (通常是大多数) 都由特定 DAO 的治理 Token 组成。这造成了一些悖论,从而造成了混乱。我们究竟应该如何看待 DAO 金库的规模?金库如何影响 DAO 股权的总价值?更具体地说:一个 DAO 的金库的构成和使用如何影响其治理 Token 最终交易价值?
To have this conversation properly, we first need to talk about values. In traditional markets, there are two basic ways to think about the value of a company's equity (or ownership).
One is the book value of the equity.Quite simply, it's the assets a company controls minus the liabilities it holds. If Evan Spiegel decided today to tear up Snap, pay off all of its debt and other liabilities, and then sell all of its remaining assets (inventory of Snap glasses, computers, desks, coffee makers, etc.) and distribute the proceeds to all of its shareholders it would be great for the company, The book value of the equity -- at least in theory -- is the total value they would get as a result of doing so.
Second, equity market value.This is literally how the market values a company's total share capital: the company's outstanding shares multiplied by its stock price [1] footnote is at the bottom of the article.
These two equity values are rarely equal to each other, but since they are different calculations of the same thing, they are clearly very related. The market value of equity is the belief that a company is greater than the sum of its assets -- more simply, that market value is a reflection of expected future corporate performance, rather than simply showing the value of assets net of liabilities. To put it more simply: if a company is generally believed to be good and will use the assets it currently has to generate more future assets (especially cash or something like cash), its market value will be greater than its book value. If the company is widely believed to be bad and more likely to waste the assets it now has rather than generate cash, the market value will be lower than book value [2]. The simplest way to think about the market value of a stock is: today's net asset value (also known as book value) + the probability of future asset generation [3].
The purpose of this financial lecture is to highlight a few very important points to consider when trying to understand the value of the DAO and the role that the DAO Vault plays in that value:
1. The basic level of equity value of any organization is the value of its assets today, and the value of any liabilities, also known as book value.
2. The total market value of the equity depends on how the asset base today is expected to generate cash in the future (i.e., a larger asset base than today).
3. Operating a company to generate cash is expensive. Above book value comes with an implicit assumption that shareholders must assume that companies will choose to use their assets efficiently today and will earn more assets tomorrow.
让我们依次的将这些要点应用于 DAO,请注意,以下假设 DAO 的治理 Token 对其金库和任何未来资产流(扣除费用、奖励和其他费用)拥有所有权。(如果你不能对你的 DAO 的治理令牌这么说,我会……重新考虑你的立场,就个人而言。)
任何协议的权益价值首先由 DAO 的资产净值决定,它 Token 的实际价格就是这个数字加上假设未来资产生成量除以市场上的 Token 供应量。这两个项目都很重要,但计算总是从今天的账面价值开始 [4]。
DAO 金库的问题是,DAO 的账面价值不能包括它自己的治理令牌,因为这些令牌的价格至少在一定程度上是由其流动资产决定的。显而易见的陈述: Token 本身不能用在等式中来确定它自己的值。不仅如此,如果一个 DAO 清算,那么这些 Token 将崩溃,DAO 资产将在未偿还的 Token 持有者之间分配,因为他们每个人都有平等的金库权利。你不会考虑金库 Token ,即使你想也怎么能?金库资产本身不能有债权,这些 Token 持有的债权和权利实际上是按比例重新分配给非国库 Token 持有人的。
除了价值之外,还需要考虑高流动性资产的实用性--如果一笔巨额债务到期,或者一家 DAO 只是想将一大笔资本投资于一项新的增长计划,那么 DAO 的治理标志有多大的流动性来支付这一切?以太和稳定币可以随时被用来支付费用,比如说,被黑客攻击造成损失的补偿。从理论上讲,DAO 的治理 Token 可以被大规模清算以支付这笔费用,但它显然不像法定加密那样具有流动性,更不用说稀释 Token 持有者的成本了,特别是当你总是不能够选择你正在交易的 Token 价格时 (稍后将详细介绍这一点)。最后,任何象征性的大规模清算显然都是以象征性抛售压力为代价的,除了上述稀释外,还会压低股权的总市值。
这并不是说金库持有的治理 Token 没有价值,显然不是这样。它只是重新定义了 DAO 社区和领导层应该如何看待它们,无论是从 DAO 持有的资本来看,还是从该资本与已经分发的 Token 的价值如何相互作用的角度来看。类现金资产构成了 Token 持有人今天声称的价值基线,当它们被花费时具有固定和已知的成本,并在需要交易时提供有保证的流动性——金库中持有的 DAO 治理 Token 不做这些事情。
要点 1:DAO 金库中持有的治理 Token 不会对所述治理 Token 的潜在价值做出贡献。
要点 2:DAO 国库中持有的治理 Token 不应被视为流动资金,并且无法立即知道花费它们的实际成本。
DAO 的治理 Token 价格 (例如,其股权市值除以未偿还 Token 数量) 从当前资产净值开始,但最终取决于未来的资产流动 [5]。你可能希望这不会是一个有争议的说法,但坦率地说,我有时会怀疑,即使是传统的科技投资者是否也完全理解这一点 (特别是那些只在一生中最长的牛市期间才是投资者的人)。任何分配股权的组织的目的都是为了生产更多的资本,以便对股权进行治理和索取权。不断增长的用户群和不断增长的 TVL(锁仓总价值),但如果你不能从中获利,或者利润与用于驱动用户/TVL 的奖励稀释不匹配,那么随着时间的推移,你的金库的总价值将会缩水,你的 Token 价格将会下降,你的 DAO 将会消亡。
这并不意味着你今天需要创造一大堆资产--许多成功的传统公司最终不会在很长一段时间内实现现金流为正,我想许多 DAO 也不会。然而,这应该是因为正在做出一个有意识的决定,要么用于扩大协议用户基础 (即,额外的 S&M 或研发),要么通过金库分配将金库收入分配给 Token 持有人 (即,股息),或者进行治理 Token 购买 (即,回购)。如果你的金库没有增长,你也不会做这些事情?也可能是一个很好的解释,为什么你的交易价格可能会低于你的 PCV(即,你的 DAO 被认为是「糟糕的」,你没有赚到任何钱,NGMI 我们都不会成功。)。
要点 3: Token 持有者创造价值的关键是积极的资产流动,或者至少是被证明的正资产流动与营收增长相结合的能力。
要点 4:相关地,任何协议的基本健康状况都应该在您剔除与增长相关的费用、 Token 持有者分红和 Token 回购时确定其资产流动是否为正。
Cost is necessary to create value, but how much do your expenses really cost?
If I paid cash for a computer, how much did I pay for it? What is the value of cash? I mean, I now have a computer that's worth more or less the cash I spent on the transaction. It actually cost me the return I could have gotten on that cash (in the traditional financial world, people often boil this down to Treasury rates, because that's the best guaranteed return you can get). This is my cash cost. People rarely talk about it that way, but at its core, the cost of capital is purely an opportunity cost. Instead of putting my cash in U.S. Treasury bonds, earning a guaranteed 2-3% annual yield, I put it in a computer and I didn't get any guaranteed yield. If you don't think about cost that way, then how can you possibly think about the ROI of any business decision?
What if, instead of cash, I finance my computer purchase with debt? The answer to the cost question is even simpler: what annual interest rate can I earn on this debt? 5%, 10%? Whatever it is, that number is the cost of my debt. That's almost certainly higher than my cash cost, because if it wasn't, why the hell would anyone lend me money instead of lending it to the U.S. government through the aforementioned Treasury bonds? Especially considering I'm taking out a loan to buy a computer.
My final choice: What if I traded some of my company's stock for the computer? Best Buy may not accept my stock, so I may need to sell it to someone else before I Buy the computer with the money. But from a "cost" point of view, the two actions are synonymous. However, calculating how much this actually costs me can be difficult, especially in Defi. One way to think about this is the expected (or required) annual return on the stake. The cost of equity of a traditional public company typically hovers between 8% and 12%, depending on the maturity of the company and the assumptions you use [6]. Given the immaturity, volatility, relative illiquidity, and expected/demanded returns of institutional investors, this figure should be a high return for any DAO.
所有这些都是说,你如何支付东西对你的费用的 ROI(投资回报率)以及最终你的 DAO 价值有巨大的影响。如果你对你的协议的方向和你的 Token 的价值 (即未来的价值和你的股权的成本) 有任何信念,你不应该将它用作是日常货币或是廉价的出售它,破坏 Token 结构。老实说,任何拥有你的 Token 的人都有这种信念,仅仅是因为他们完全持有这个 Token 。粗心大意的出售/发放治理 Token 会稀释你的 Token 持有者,让您失去对支出真实成本的控制,并发出您不重视自己 Token 所有权的信号 (有意或无意)。
Point 5: In general -- the cost of using equity for A DAO is much higher than the cost of funding incentives/expenditures with staboin or debt, and will significantly reduce the ROI of those incentives/expenditures.
要点 6:粗心空投 Token 的成本对 Token 持有者的价值产生多重复合负面影响——所有权稀释、市场抛售压力、缺乏成本控制和负面的市场信号。
Whether you want to talk about DAO money management in terms of risk diversification or capitalization, it ultimately makes no difference -- how you approach it strategically matters. In my banking career, we used to spend hours with cfos of public companies talking briefly about the capitalization/cost of capital of the company and what they could do to optimize it. I know this sounds bad and boring (it usually is), but it's important, and in general, most DAOs don't seem to give much thought to it at all.
花一点时间在 DeepDao 或 OpenOrgs 上,你就会明白我的意思。这些问题存在于光谱的两侧。一些 DAO 资本严重不足,根本没有能力支付日常开支(更不用说处理黑天鹅事件了),其最终成本和 Token 持有者稀释完全取决于市场的一时兴起(即,你最好向上帝祈祷,当您的负债和费用到期时,您的 Token 交易良好)。其他人则大量「 资本过剩 」 [7] 并拥有数百万(在某些情况下为数亿)稳定币和其他 Token ,而不是用于增长或通过股息或 Token 回购将这些价值分配给 Token 持有者*[8]*。无论哪种情况,我都可以向您保证,由于不必要的稀释、不当的资本化做法和财务管理不善,数百万美元的价值被搁置在桌面上,将无法得到妥善处理。
Bottom line: DaOs should start thinking and managing their cost runway today and optimize their capex and financial diversity. When it comes to spending (or, better yet, hiring someone's spending) it pays to thoughtfully analyze and anticipate the direction of the agreement and pay special attention to:
1. Token 经济学和 Token 持有者稀释
2. Capitalization planning and requirements
3. Capital strategy and optimization
All of these things will have a huge impact on value today and in the future, and that's how.
[1] 请注意,如果您想考虑,公司的已发行股票必须包括已发行但未归属的股票,例如员工 RSU(受限制的股票,满足限制条件即可自由流通)、员工期权和可转换债券(DeFi 模拟是投资者/核心团队未归属的 Token )股权的市场价值适当。市场(阅读:股价)肯定会影响这种预期的稀释,我们在考虑股权的真实总价值时也应该如此。可以说,市场也会从实体持有的授权但尚未发行的股票中获得一些预期的稀释,这在考虑 DeFi 估值时会产生一个有趣的细微差别,因为它们倾向于通过奖励排放来稀释自己和/ 或国库管理不善(国库和未发出的 Token 都可以简单地被认为是授权的,大多数用途的未发行股票)。这个脚注已经太长了——让我们把它放在一边,改天我会写另一篇关于 Token 结构和财务管理稀释对股权估值的影响的文章。
[2] You don't see this very often, for the same reason you never see a two-star restaurant on Yelp. Things like this don't have a long shelf life. Nature tends to take care of these things.
[3] There are subtle differences between working and non-working assets in determining market equity values, but for the sake of simplicity we can ignore this for now... Not to complicate things further, but any future asset value obviously needs to be discounted to its present value.
[4] One way to illustrate this relationship is to consider the market's reaction to TradFi (traditional finance) dividends: stocks fall because of the cash paid out. This is because the prior stock price in a. future cash payments and b. dividend cash have left the entity, so the net asset value (i.e., book value of equity) reduces that amount (i.e., shareholders are no longer entitled to it).
[5] In this case, "asset flow" and "cash flow" are basically interchangeable -- and since "cash" means legal tender, asset flow may make more sense in DeFi. Maybe we'll eventually come up with a more encrypted name for this, IDK.
[6] This range is based on what I have typically seen in my time at investment banking and what we often calculate as "cost of equity" when discounting cash flows, but is supported by the fact that S&P has returned about 10.5% a year since its founding in 1957.
[7] I cite this because I'm still not sure why "excess capital" in the real financial world means something different from what it sounds like, and is not the exact opposite of insufficient capital.
[8] Hopefully they will be able to make these balances work at least to some extent and optimise risk and reward appropriately, but my guess is that this is rare.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia