VC or Token Fund?
Source: Just Blockchain News
This series of articles, mainly from the dual perspective of practitioners and scholars, will talk about my review, exposition and reflection on the past, current situation and future of equity investment and financing, currency investment and financing. This is the second part of the seriesThe first step of "Crypto Capital" : Token HK $20BN.
What should we do about emerging currency projects? How can retail investors judge the rationality of currency financing projects as quickly as possible? And how should regulators reconcile technology and industry self-discipline? How does the traditional VC participate in the interests of currency rights as far as possible under its own equity legal framework? And, as an entrepreneur, how to choose equity and currency financing to help the development of my project?
When I was starting a business, I often encountered two soul questions that all entrepreneurs face:
(1) What would you do if a senior person from Alibaba or Tencent came out with a project similar to yours?
(2) What should you do if Sequoia, IDG or Hillhouse invest in your competitors?
After entering web3, basically no one dared to ask me that.
The answer is simple.
Against (1) : It doesn't matter, just beat them. Web3 has no Alibaba, No Tencent, no Facebook.
(2) : It doesn't matter. Users on the other side of the ocean will not start FOMO just because there is a well-known Chinese capital standing behind the project.
I don't mean any disrespect to the names I mentioned above. However, Compared with Web2, Web3 further erases the commercial moat brought by geographical framework, and directly throws all projects into the undifferentiated international competitive market. After all, on web3, there is no narrative logic to describe a project as "binance in the UK", "uniswap in China" or "opensea in Korea".
So -- when we talk about VC and Token When it comes to competition between funds, think about who will get the better deal. Sourcing and good post-sourcing for web3 projects around the world? There is no one right answer, but I believe, at least at this point in time, VC friends reading this article, and Token When fund competes for projects, it doesn't seem to be doing so well at some point.
The currency circle is an influence-driven and dissemination industry. Almost all good token Fund always has a "shiller", which may seem a bit shabby before Web2 era, but in Web3, it is really needed for every project.
Of course, traditional VCS are under more pressure, or, more enviously, Token. The funds have amazing annualized returns (IRR), and the portion of those paper gains that can be liquidated and paid out (DPI).
In a sense, 2022 is the first year when Chinese VC officially enters Web3. I am fortunate to be responsible for the Partner/VP of Web3 project and Token&NBSP with more than 90% of Chinese VC. The Partenrs of the Fund have spoken (and so have I, of course). VCS, at the beginning of the least understand, more Token Fund looks at investing in a completely different way. This perspective mainly focuses on three specific issues.
First, Ticket Size (investment amount).
Token Fund and traditional VC for the calculation of the rate of return and expected logic, can be said to be completely different. For traditional VC, entrepreneurial enterprises are thousands of armies and horses crossing A single-plank bridge. The mortality rate of angel round enterprises is too high, so they tend to invest in a-round enterprises which have passed the "fragile period" with A large probability. And token For fund, 90% of the coin circle projects invested are "angel period", and the investment is currency rights, the time window from the primary market to the upper secondary market is very short. It does not matter whether they can stand out from tough competition. They just need to exchange liquidity on "angel days", whereas most of the lesser known Token&Nbsp; The fund, which is more or less related to the major exchanges, has realized a return if it uses the power of "post-investment services" to push the exchange.
In a bull market, Token Funds even make the assumption that we're investing in a project, we want long-term and short-term returns, you want a low valuation, and then we're all going to get you on the exchange quickly, and you're going to get there. For example, for some applications, especially common in Defi projects, the investor unlock method is TGE 20%, 20% every three months, released in a year. So when TGE listed on the stock exchange, the price was inflated to five times what the private investors paid, and they made a return.) Of course, it is conceivable that such programs would fall into a long downward spiral after the first wave of FOMO.
The more important assumption is implicit here -- in the coin world, token Fund is extremely aggressive, especially in the bull market, the expected annual return rate of bitcoin such a basic asset may be at least 300-500%, so for them, investment in the "angel period" of the coin circle project, must be at least eight out of ten to make money, but also at least one can turn dozens of times. Otherwise, in their expectation, why not buy bitcoin and keep it?
Correspondingly, VC but as long as the long-term 20% annual rate of return, it is good enough. I have tracked the world's famous institutions, at least 15 years of existence of VC, only a few can achieve a long-term average return rate of 20% per term fund -- this is enough to make LP people satisfied with the answer.
But on the contrary, the liquidity of most coin circle projects cannot reach the level of the real stock secondary market. Frankly speaking, with the exception of a few exchanges such as Binance, Coinbase and Upbit, the depth of most exchanges is not deep enough for a fund-level Token Allocation investment to be cashed out. So instead of investing hundreds of thousands of dollars or even millions of dollars with a huge paper return that you can't cash out at all, you can invest tens of thousands of dollars per project, and cash out is extremely flexible through volume.

Binance's daily volume change after cleansing over the past year (source: CoinGecko)
Daily Trading volume changes after Coinbase's purge over the past year (source: CoinGecko)
KuCoin Daily trading volume changes after cleaning over the past year (source: CoinGecko)
Daily Trading volume changes after Coinone purge over the past year (source: CoinGecko)

From here, all along, I think token. The funds have a common structural flaw -- too many tokenes. Fund only focuses on pre-investment judgment, but there is no good selling strategy and management method, resulting in "waste" a lot of income. Contrary to VC, most of the projects VC participates in will die, and only a very small part will involve listing, so the secondary market strategy can be said to be better than nothing, and the importance of post-investment management and timing exit is relatively less than the judgment before investment. On the contrary, a good token Fund, how to realize income at the most appropriate time point, may be the fundamental to improve performance. How do you frame a broader selling strategy so you don't get caught up in the hundreds of tokens in your portfolio that are listed on multiple exchanges? How to better communicate the latest dynamic information of the project obtained by the primary team to the secondary team for decision making? How to give the right incentives to the secondary selling team? How to ensure that the best risk control strategy is found in a 24*7 trading market?
In fact, Token The funds' gains were not nearly as spectacular as they looked on their earnings reports -- AND I believe that by the end of March, every tokenstock in the world would have been. The one-year performance that the fund reports to LPS may differ by an order of magnitude from what was left in mid-May.
If I have time, I will expand on the discussion below.
Second, project valuation.
Just entered the circle VC often feel confused, a crypto new project, why can be worth 20 million, 40 million, or 80 million DOLLARS?
More directly, they will compare the equity valuation of similar projects with currency rights -- then, is the valuation of currency rights high or low relative to equity?
The answer is, no.
To simplify the discussion, we divide blockchain projects into three categories and separately discuss the valuation interval:
The male chain:
Seed rounds: 30 million to 100 million
Strategy round: 60-300 million
Private round: 150 million to 600 million
Public offering round: 500 million to 1 billion
Application:
Seed rounds: 10-40 million
Strategy round: 15-60 million
Private placement round: 20-80 million
Public offering round: 10-150 million
Equity:
Seed rounds: 5 million to 15 million
Round A: 20-100 million
Round B: 80 million to 500 million
Round C: 200 million to 2 billion

Valuation comparison of different rounds of financing for blockchain projects (unit: USD)

As can be seen from the figure above, there are three characteristics:
1. There is little difference in valuation between different rounds of application coin rights projects, and the basic range shows a trend of equal proportion growth. This is because the multi-round financing of coin rights is often completed within a few months or even weeks. During this period, the fundamental changes of the project itself are very small, and there are only "influence premium", "resource premium", and even differences generated to distinguish investors with different priorities.
2. The valuation of public chain coin rights project is significantly higher than the application. Of course, from my personal point of view, there is no chance to belong to the public chain now, so I will not elaborate more here. (See "Rediscussion on Blockchain and Industrial Investment -- Thirty Years of Gold" for details.)
3. The valuation range of the currency rights project during the entire financing cycle is much smaller than that of the equity. In other words, the valuation of the coin rights project at the beginning is significantly higher than that of the equity project, while the valuation of the financing in the last round (before the exchange) is significantly lower than that of the equity project at the later stage. Therefore, in popular terms, currency rights projects are "expensive before cheap".
As for the third point, the currency option project actually transfers the future continuous financing ability of the equity project so as to realize the liquidity premium in advance. Low financing ratio, in exchange for a better rise in the secondary market. We will expand on this in more detail below.
This is also why, as an equity financing company, NFTGo is a domestic token  Fund is less than impressed.
Because -- look at the chart above, from a valuation range, Token&Nbsp; A $100 million project is almost impossible for the fund to understand, and it doesn't look like a good fit and has no intention of issuing money.
But is this really the case? In the next article, you may discover some hidden thoughts.
However, currency circle projects sometimes deliberately lower their primary market valuation, in order to obtain more flow and speculation space, because only in this way, can create enough potential energy to ensure that the exchange recognized its "heat", more directly, equivalent to using the valuation in exchange for liquidity.
This is the ultimate strategy of some heavily marketed coin projects to capture the market -- early rounds at significantly below-average valuations to attract more support. Such projects often have dozens or even hundreds of "investors." For example, a project with an estimated value of $20 million can only borrow 15%, but the amount is scattered to 100, so as to make the global token&NbSP in the shortest time. Funds and "community investors" quickly understand that there is money to be made from this, and that there is a market for it, so get involved. After all, the key for those kols and communities to be deeply attached to you and continue to help you spread the word is not how much money you pay them to do marketing costs, but to let them skin in The game, and an easy game.
In addition, the price of some projects in the public offering round may even be inverted with the price of the previous rounds of private placement, which is the same as the above mentioned. This fundraising behavior is actually more like a marketing plan, of course, the amount released will not be too much.
Even for exchanges, they almost always have an eco-fund, so that they can participate in the investment, which is more closely tied to the exchange, not more happy to see its success.
Of course, this kind of project, certainly no VC share. Funds often fight over tens of thousands of dollars in "quotas" for such projects, making it impossible for them to make financial investments.
Naturally, in token financing, we often see that the project side takes the initiative and has the negotiating advantage. The project side is always in the same position. If you want to invest or not, there is no way for you to invest as much as you want.
Third, the number of participating institutions.
On the other hand, what is often frowned upon by traditional entrepreneurs and VCS is, why do web3 projects need a list of investor names?
In fact, this is a necessary product of localization. When a project needs to expand the market at the fastest speed, increase the base of community fans, and find the fund with sufficient localization ability in each region. Often, the funds' strongest attributes are local connections, resources and advocacy.
For example, some names are very important in the core circle of the coin circle, such as Vietnam's Coin98 and South America's 4SV. However, even most people engaged in web3 projects only focus on the well-known names A16Z and Paradigm, and turn a blind eye to the development of other non-English speaking countries.
Similarly, in contrast to the stock market, the most core exit path is IPO -- the most important indicator of domestic A-share listing is profit, the most important indicator of NASDAQ listing is technology, and the most important indicator of coin circle exchange is flow.
So, of course, some of these funds are stacked in a pile, and the message to the outside world is very clear - this is a project that is very popular with the global community.
Keep in mind that the core of a Web3 project isn't size, monetization, or even technology, it's community.
So, all is well - you need at least 15-20 names to really build resources, social networks around the world, plus some financial and strategic investors, and it's not surprising that Web3 projects have dozens, if not hundreds, of investors.
In fact, for old leek, from the financing valuation and techniques disclosed by a project, you can basically guess whether it is money or equity, without looking at its financing institutions.
It's a hunch.
So, reverse thinking, when we do our own blockchain projects, which one do we choose to do?
Or, more complicated -- coins after stocks, or stocks after coins?
Next, let's continue this discussion.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia