header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

In the wave of Web3.0, scientific DAO cannot be absent

Read this article in 12 Minutes
How can Web3 technologies help the Decentralized Science (DeSci) movement?
Original Title: "How Web3 Technologies Can Help Improve the Scientific Record"
Original Source: DeSci Foundation
Original Compilation: Old Yuppie

< br>

Science is the foundation of knowledge and progress, and as an essential public good, science requires reliable, transparent and open access. This article discusses how the state of science can improve on all these fronts. Web3 technologies offer exciting possibilities to change the status quo, and a new Decentralized Science (DeSci) movement is beginning to leverage these new technologies to improve science.


Technological innovations have historically resulted in vast improvements in our ability to produce, verify, preserve and disseminate knowledge. From the invention of printing in the 15th century, which first enabled the mass dissemination of knowledge, to the invention of the Internet in the 20th century, it dramatically lowered the transaction costs of sharing information.


What problems does scientific publishing face?


The market for scientific publications is dominated by five large for-profit companies (Elsevier, Black & Wiley, Taylor & Francis, Springer Nature, and SAGE), which Together they control more than 50% of the market. Worldwide sales of rights to scientific papers exceed $19 billion, and the scientific publishing industry falls between the music and film industries in terms of revenue.


The two main business models for publishing companies are pay-to-access and pay-to-publish. Both models rely on the unpaid labor of scientists for peer review. This amounts to billions of dollars involuntarily donated by scientists to the publishing industry, using mostly public funds or researchers’ private time to boost publishers’ profits and depriving scientists of a fair return for high-quality refereeing work. Here's a great quiz from the University of Virginia that gives a sense of the importance of money.


Pay for access


In the pay-to-access model, journals make payments to individuals and institutions such as universities Libraries) charge subscription or access fees. Annual subscriptions typically run in the hundreds of dollars per journal, and access to individual articles usually ranges from $20 to $100.


Institutional subscribers such as universities, libraries, and governments receive bundled "deals" that often include not only the publisher's highest-ranked journals, but also A large number of niche or low-impact journals for which subscribers may not be willing to pay if these journals are not part of a bundled deal. This practice of exploiting market dominance by bundling goods is a powerful anti-competitive strategy for consolidating market position. By taking the majority of a library's budget in one transaction, incumbents can protect their market from competition from newcomers.


Journal subscriptions under this model are a huge burden on public funds. For example, the United Kingdom spent $52.3 million on annual journal subscriptions in 2014, while the Netherlands paid more than $14 million in 2018 for its public universities to subscribe to journals from just one large publisher (Elsevier). While public money spends heavily on journal subscriptions, taxpayers — who fund much of the research and journal subscriptions — don’t get access to the science their taxes pay for.


Pay to Publish


In the "Pay to Publish" model, authors pay Payments for each article (i.e. Author Publication Charges - APCs). These articles are often published under open access agreements, which allow the public to access the content online, in contrast to the "pay for access" model. Publication fees vary by journal and article type, with typical publication fees ranging from $2,000 to $11,800. Scientists either pay for these costs from their research budgets, out of pocket, or rely on their employers, such as universities, to cover the costs. The total number and market share of pay-to-access journals is growing every year.


At the heart of the "pay to publish" model is a perverse incentive: authors of articles pay only when their manuscript is accepted. This means that for every manuscript rejected, journals lose potential revenue. Therefore, open access journals are usually less restrictive in their choice in order to maintain their business model. While open access journals have lowered the barriers to access to knowledge and many journals are of high quality, this model, taken as a whole, has led to a worldwide prevalence of predatory journals, lowering standards and providing little value for research opened the floodgates.


Our scientific curation system is thus caught in a dilemma: on the one hand subscription-based publishers control distribution channels and have proven to be tenacious , unshakable, powerful force for extracting capital from taxpayer dollars. Their highly selective flagship journals allow for lucrative bundle deals. Meanwhile, on the other side, the open access model thrives on volume and has enabled the global rise of predatory publishers, flooding the scientific literature with a flood of false, unreliable, and even plagiarized reports masquerading as science.


Finally, both pay-to-access and pay-to-publish models exclude the vast majority of scientists from lower-end institutions and people in developing countries participation in science, thereby exaggerating inequalities and limiting opportunities for progress and development.


A new paradigm is needed to break out of exploitation


The latest innovation involves human coordination and The purpose of value redistribution using Web3 technology is to realize a decentralized version of the Internet. Web3 is based on peer-to-peer networks with increasingly self-certified, massive multi-client databases called blockchains.


Just like the early web in the 1990s, Web3 is now experimental. Skeptics rightly point out that the space is currently rife with scams and excessive marketing hype. However, there are also some major technological breakthroughs that can be used to create a better, more open, verifiable and secure scientific record.


We have identified at least six ways that Web3 breakthroughs could benefit science and scientists:


1. New ways of cooperation


2. More transparent and changeable incentive structure


3. Decentralized data and metadata storage


4. Proven research object


< /p>

5. New Forms of Identity Management


6. New Ways to Fund Research


A New Way to Collaborate


The core promise of Web3 is to execute code in a trustless, censorship-resistant way through stakeholder incentivized coordination, And coordinate through a peer-to-peer network to broadly redistribute value to users. Built on top of these networks are decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs), communities of contributors and active users who collaborate by co-owning and co-managing these networks.


A more transparent and changeable incentive structure


Smart contract programmability, Composition and trustless execution create a rich experimentation space for mechanism design. Transparent incentive systems can be coordinated programmatically without relying on trust in intermediaries. All events are recorded on an open, immutable ledger. These self-certified, large-scale multi-client databases can be used to greatly improve scientific accessibility, transparency and credibility.


Decentralized data and metadata storage


Interoperable data model native to Web3 , such as IPLD, combined with a storage incentive layer such as Filecoin, can make science permanently accessible to everyone. Persistent Identifiers (PIDs) on Web3 are replaced by Content Identifiers (CIDs). Unlike PIDs, CIDs are encrypted to provide a tamper-proof mapping to their underlying content.


Unlike DOIs (PIDs and primary keys for publishing), Web3's CIDs can be published at will, are immune to link rot, and are immune to content corruption , traditionally expensive to maintain and dependent on centralized institutions controlled by the publishing industry. The shift from Web2 PIDs to Web3 CIDs will be a paradigm shift in our ability to generate rich interconnected, immutable knowledge graphs (CID-graphs) and automatically generate rich scientific metadata from these relationships. Such a Web3 knowledge graph will reveal new information about connections within the research domain.


Verified research objects


The move to Web3 will also be a step to overcome the Outdated legacy of static print and PDF technology for sharing scientific knowledge, moving to rich, dynamic research objects Combining text, code, data, video, peer review, annotations, and comments, allowing tracking of research object development, including versioning, citations, replication status, and on-chain verification of open science practices, badges, and replication status.


Research objects will be tied to reproducible code docks and allow for systematic reconstruction of research output through reproducibility runs. Decentralized computing solutions combined with fully homomorphic encryption will allow users to share sensitive data in a privacy-preserving manner, opening the door to widespread reusability and protection of commercially viable scientific intellectual property.


New Forms of Identity Management


Web3 also empowers anonymous identities, which can be A tamper-proof and auditable way to link individual contributions to science with cross-platform contributions (e.g. authorship, peer review, scientific review). By combining "proof of skill" with anonymity, it is possible to create a scientific ecosystem that simultaneously fosters public debate and reduces bias.


The scientific expertise of anonymous contributors can be proven through zk-SNARKs connected to a decentralized identity management system. Such a system would allow credit to flow back to scientists.


A New Way to Fund Research


The DAO has revolutionized the way crowdfunding is organized. For example, VitaDAO collects funds from its members for longevity-related research that could lead to startups or patents. In return for research funding, DAO members become (co-)owners of the intellectual property generated by the research. Unlike the traditional financial industry, Web3 provides programmable funding channels that can be combined with research results and held securely in escrow accounts until certain conditions are met.


For example, a funder can declare a research problem or initiative in a node and contribute money to its wallet. Other parties can easily add funds, effectively pooling donations from different sponsors. Research teams apply, their proposals are evaluated, and funding is matched. Such a system would be faster, more efficient, and more flexible than ordinary funding schemes, allowing rapid responses to new challenges such as outbreaks. This model has been successfully tested in the context of Gitcoin grants.


Therefore, the DeSci movement can support the efforts of the scientific community to transform the way research is funded, the way knowledge is validated and, ultimately, shared, helping to transfer scientific knowledge to Ownership of and its value is transferred from the intermediary to the scientist who created that value.


By indexing research objects on-chain and linking them to financial channels, we create a new primitive that will incentivize Programmability is combined with the production of scientific knowledge as a dynamic research object.


For example, we can automate the creation of escrow accounts, securely between sponsors, authors, research institutes, foundations, DAOs, and for-profit R&D at scale Send funds. These accounts are open to anyone to create validation grants: peer review grants, artefact evaluation grants, replication grants, and direct funding for post-review analysis plans. Unlike traditional banking systems, all financial transactions are recorded on-chain, providing full transparency and auditability.


Combining on-chain research objects, tamper-proof data stored on IPFS, and custody-based trustless accounts, we can create a A one-click funding solution with efficiency, traceability and accessibility addressing the entire space of scientific validation with surgical precision.


We call this concept "DeSci Nodes" - because they are inherent in the Web3 stack. This has the potential to greatly increase the speed of scientific validation and expedite research funding, which is particularly useful for finding fast, reliable solutions to new challenges.


Scientific selection and validation


A central feature of the scientific enterprise is the Research articles are selected for inclusion in journals and conferences on a basis. Despite the shortcomings of the current system discussed in our previous three blog posts, it is still critical for scientists to obtain funding from institutional sources. The traditional system is here to stay because of the prestige it carries and the sticky incentive systems that universities, research institutes, and funding agencies have built around them.


DeSci can complement and provide on-demand validation services for research objects and artifacts (e.g., peer-reviewed ACM badges, OSF badges, FAIR data) Improve the situation. Additionally, there can be explicit incentives to replicate research, and the replicability of results can be independently verified and indexed on-chain. This holistic curatorial service is conducted in the open domain and requires no copyright or other intellectual property rights over the research objects. This will allow scientists to continue publishing their manuscripts in the existing journals that are most relevant to them, while making validated research subjects open and free to all.


Securely stored and authenticated research objects can also help editors of scientific journals to evaluate the submissions they receive faster and better. On-chain proofs of reproducibility, validation badges for FAIR data, and open science practices will signal to editors which submissions are most likely to report authentic, reproducible findings. This can help ambitious submissions succeed, reduce fraud, and speed turnaround times for journals.


Scientific Association as DAO


Coordinates the verification of research objects indexed on-chain (peer review, artefact evaluation, replication evaluation) is for scientific societies to run a DAO stack (essentially an OSS preprint validation overlay for coordinating micro-tasks, interfacing with links to store research objects and assigning credits to scientists).


Such a DAO should be run by renowned scientists in each field and enable them to monetize and share the value created by their services, e.g. by collecting Grants are validated and automatically redistributed in the form of fellowships with stipends to early career researchers participating in the DAO.


DAO that returns value to scientists


Design sustainable mechanisms to create value redistribution , making it away from the big publishers and towards the decentralized scientific community is now urgent. Talented scientists around the world need new ways to improve their economics. Structural factors such as rising inflation and stagnant wages, combined with the increasing allocation of funding to younger generations of chief scientists, create an unsustainable economic situation for early-career scientists. The situation is so dramatic that even a few hundred dollars per month can make a huge difference in the life of a talented early-stage researcher.


DeSci Laboratories is establishing an ARC for this purpose


Table 2 below summarizes the Key differences in how studies are assessed and selected in the traditional system and in DeSci.



Relink influence and replicability


In many academic fields, the current scientific record favors novelty over reproducibility ("Why Science Is Facing a Credibility Crisis"). This bias undermines the credibility and legitimacy of science and imposes enormous social costs. One of the core causes of the replication crisis is the lack of clear incentives for scientists to share research beyond their manuscripts, conduct replication studies, and consider the replicability of their new discoveries from the outset. DeSci can change that by creating clear incentives for replication.


Towards a world where knowledge is publicly reproducible, verifiable, accessible – and of value to scientists


In summary, the vision we outline here will increase the reliability, transparency and accessibility of research. It also allows scientists to capture some of the value they create with their work. In addition, it allows institutional and private funders of science, as well as the private sector, to direct funding to topics, teams and methods they deem most valuable and promising in a rapid, capital-efficient and flexible manner, with full transparency.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit