Original title: "a16z: The next generation business model of search engine is "boutique search""
Original author: Sari Azout
Original compilation: Old Yuppie
Google search is pretty frustrating for most searchers these days. Google is great at answering questions that have objective answers, like "how many billionaires are there in the world" or "what's the population of Iceland"? It's pretty bad at answering questions that require context, like "What do NFT collectors think about NFTs?"
The evidence is everywhere. These days, I squash the junk of the internet by googling "Substack + future of learning" to find the best perspectives on education. I retrieve Twitter posts over and over with the "what's the best" question. When I'm researching a new product, I type "X project reddit" into Google. I've found tremendous value in small, niche, oft-forgotten sites like Spaghetti Directory.
With tools like Notion, Airtable, and Readwise, people are aggregating content and resources to reinvigorate the curated web. But most of these sites currently stand alone -- tucked away in private or semi-private corners of the internet, fragmented, poorly indexed, and unavailable to the public. We haven't figured out how to make them "multiplayer". Where we've made them public and collaborative - and here's a good example - these projects tend to be short-lived and poorly maintained.
A nearly $2 trillion company with the stated mission of "organizing the world's information" remains poorly organized. Or, to put it another way, in an information-infinite world, simply organizing the information in the world is no longer enough. It becomes important to organize trustworthy information in the world.
It's hard to believe, but once Google got going, one of its main problems was that there wasn't much to see online. It's no use having a great search engine if someone types in "how to grow herbs in the garden?" and the answer doesn't exist on the web. With the advent of Google AdWords, it became profitable to push out low-quality content to serve as informative and populate Google's search engine results. The end result is that the sites that rank high in Google are not necessarily the highest quality, but rather those that have put the most effort into SEO. What started as a well-meaning way of organizing the world's information has turned into a business that focuses most of its resources on monetizing clicks to support advertisers, rather than focusing on providing people with trustworthy search results.
The problem now is very different from ten years ago. It is not what to read/buy/eat/watch, but to use my limited time and attention to find Bring out the best things to read/buy/eat/watch/etc.
Bold groups like DuckDuckGo and Neeva are trying to compete head-on with Google by building massive horizontal search engines. Rather than crawling and indexing things their own way, they sit on top of existing data sources and position themselves as a privacy-focused alternative to Google. But protecting privacy isn't a compelling reason to leave Google. Allowing them to "control their data" isn't a selling point for the vast majority of people, especially if it involves paying for something they're used to getting for free.
I believe the opportunity in the search field is not with a massive , a one-size-fits-all horizontal aggregator to attack Google head-on, and instead build a boutique search engine that indexes, curates, and organizes things in new ways.

Google is how the Internet is A great example of scale and speed: every page on the web returns in an instant. But, as we increasingly see, this scale conflicts with a fundamental human need: relevance. Someone trying to find the best freelance designer, or the best sushi restaurant, or the best NFT to buy, won't find the answer on Google.
No search framework works universally across all categories. It's hard to imagine wanting to use the same user experience to search for recipes and search for freelancers. Google's products start and end with a search bar, trading functionality for simplicity, while vertical search players like Yelp, Expedia, Zillow, and Behance emerged to fill functionality and functionality with their industry-specific structured data. Relevance gap. Users have strong opinions on how to organize information, so they favor filter functions, and vertical search aggregators have a clear advantage that horizontal software cannot achieve.
But here too, relevance depends on the sociology of the moment. For example, on Behance, the online creative community, school and location are featured prominently as filters—meaning where you live and where you went to school is an important indicator of the quality of your design portfolio. In a world where talent is decoupled from credentialism and geography, these filters are losing relevance.
With the development of this demand trend, new indexing methods and superficial innovations have emerged. If Behance were designed today, I don't think "place" nor "school" would be filters.

On Yelp, search for "electricians in Miami" to start with A page titled "10 Best Electricians in Miami, FL" and the text below it shows that most of these results are paid promotions.

When you make money through advertising , curation would give way to advertisers, as there would be less digital space available to curate your own recommendations. So these platforms end up making ethically questionable design choices that create a huge trust gap in the user psyche.
Additionally, in vertical search aggregators like Yelp, Zillow, LinkedIn, and Behance, anyone can have a profile. The combination of irrelevant filters, ad-based business models, and unfettered supply has overwhelmed consumers and made it difficult for users to find the information they want on these platforms.
Vertical search aggregators come into play when you know exactly what you want. But knowing what you want is often not the starting point, creating an opportunity to help overwhelmed consumers discover and curate better down the funnel.
We Living in the information age, it has become a popular saying that we need "curation" to help us organize the messy information. But so far, the conversation around curation has focused too much on content and not enough on structure. We seem to have accepted the curator's job of offering product reviews, link lists, or song recommendations -- all linearly structured and chronologically available online, designed to surface thoughts from the past 24 hours rather than to accumulate and Demonstrate knowledge as required.
As a sideline, it feels fun and gimmicky to send out an email every day with the top five Alibaba products, but when you're trying to find It doesn't help when it's the best crib. Inevitably, you'll want a way to search the planner's profile.
When it comes to sharing bit-by-bit, isolated pieces in a feed-like structure, curation is more about entertainment than utility. It is not wrong to say that this kind of planning has a market. However, what people overlook is that this market is already occupied by Twitter, Facebook and TikTok.
These entertainment giants offer curations that demand our attention, but they don't offer on-demand curations. The opportunity lies in moving the curated content feed away from its never-ending present direction to a more purposeful interface. People should be able to find whatever content they want on their own terms, not at the mercy of curators deciding when to post it.
Applying Ben Evans' framework, it is clear that while vertical search players have grown too large to require curation , but the curated feed has become too long to browse, requiring search and structured data. The solution is better search and better curation, all wrapped up in a better business model -- a combination of what I call a boutique search engine.
Searchable, curated interfaces will help us move from ephemeral, time-limited feeds into contextual, highly informative, trustworthy knowledge spaces . Because the searchable interface is densely linked, explorers can follow multiple threads through content rather than being dumped into a "recent" feed.
With curation and search so closely linked, the real question is not if you need to curate or search, but when and how :
· Spotify does not curate which songs make it to their platform. Instead, it finds endless ways to discover and search its music library from across the music universe, including a mix of human curation (via playlists curated by its in-house curation team and users) and algorithms (like Discover Weekly).
· Wirecutter does not review every product. It manually curates top products, then uses search and other discovery tools to help you find what you need.
· Thingtesting does not automatically search all consumer packaged goods brands on the Internet. Someone on its team or community is desperate to add a brand to the database.
· If you're searching On Deck's member database, you know everyone has applied, been vetted, and paid paid to participate in this project.
· If you're reading the transcripts on Tegus, you know they're from its team of hand-picked experts.
In all of these examples, the value lies in what they exclude and what they include. Supply-side friction is what creates the value of information.
On top of the value of information, these companies have established powerful search engines. For example, OnDeck has built an opinion graph that lets you discover talent in a unique way. For example, you could filter by people with "software engineering" skills and a current status of "open to new ideas." As a founder looking for engineering talent, I would choose this curated dataset over LinkedIn's dataset anytime.

Unlike vertical search aggregators, boutique search engines don't feel like Yellow Pages , but more like texting a friend asking for a recommendation. They limit supply, which is the foundation of their greatest moat: trust. Importantly, boutique search engines also introduce new business models that do not rely on advertising.

Building a boutique search engine requires countless nuanced product choices. Getting the right mix of curation, search, algorithms and business models will likely prove to be very difficult, but also very valuable. The following is a non-exhaustive list of questions we thought about as we built Startupy, our attempt to build a boutique search engine for qualitative insights.
Time and time again, curation sites fall into an existential trap. They start with high-quality, curated recommendations. As they grow, they crowdsource to scale, often scraping to fill in the gaps. Content goes from good to good over time. At this point, vertical search aggregators like Yelp offer more utility. For example, Yahoo became too big to browse, lost its signal power, and reached the point where Google was better off. The lines between planners, compilers, and catalogers are thin, with a natural invisible asymptote—more data with diminishing returns over time.
On the surface, vertical search engines are simple -- content is supply, and eyeballs are demand. But the last wave of vertical search engines was built on an ad-based business model, which made things trickier. In an advertising-driven market, eyeballs are on the supply side. Their attention is what the demand side -- advertisers -- want. The downside of this ad-driven model is that advertisers and content producers are competing for the same attention, which is why these sites end up feeling like marketing blogs.
That's why subscriptions present an opportunity. Subscriptions simplify network effects into two: content as supply and paying audience as demand. But a subscription by itself isn't a panacea, especially if usage isn't frequent enough. How often do you need to find a freelancer? an investor? If usage isn't frequent enough, the utility of search engines won't translate into a sustainable business model, and you'll have to come up with your own "come for search, stay for something else" flavor.
Also, as my friend Joey points out in this post, any product you spend a lot of time using in incognito mode has a fairly Big UX problem. How many New York Times accounts did you create before finally succumbing to the paywall? With today's subscription model, customers have no real incentive to help the platform grow. Emerging token-based business models show early promise. By handing ownership over to stakeholders and allowing users to benefit from future growth, startups can overcome the cold start problem.
As fascinating as it is, the playbook for tokenized business models is not there yet. I suspect this will change over the next few years, and I'm excited to improve my understanding of the issue.
Platforms like Twitter delegate this responsibility to their users, who must go through a long and arduous process of following a large number of people to eventually arrive at a A self-curated timeline that mimics their interests. Some centralize their curation - at OnDeck, you trust them to be doing the work of choosing who gets to join their network. Others, however, stay away from curation in favor of more traditional crowdsourcing. This range is very wide.
I started this article arguing that Google needs to be untied. It's a catchy headline, but in truth, I believe that Google will be a big part of your engine being discovered first before you can build habit recall into your product. Zillow and Airbnb are examples of search companies that enjoy a lot of direct traffic, but SEO was a big part of their early strategy. By being the first companies to create a home authority page, they reap the benefits of an SEO land grab that is hard to replace thereafter.
We are far from realizing the grand vision of the Internet. Today's project of human knowledge is a vast ocean of ephemeral and fragmented information and ideas, the best sources of which are nearly impossible to find. We need more interfaces, and the point of view of these interfaces is what information is missing, how it needs to be organized, and at what point in the value chain must it be curated. It is also worth thinking about.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia