header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Art or science? Discussion on Token pricing in Web3 economy

Read this article in 6 Minutes
DAOrayaki community member Shaun compiled Living Opera's "Token Pricing in the Web3 Economy" to explore token pricing in the Web3 economy.
Pricing Tokens in a Web3 Economy
By Living Opera
Shaun@DAOrayaki.org


There are over 10,000 tokens in circulation right now, according to Statista, but most of them probably aren't worth much. Some of these tokens are outright scams, but many others are more nebulous, and they could be interesting or have a lot going for them, but it's a confusing sight to have to say.


How do you decide which choices are right and whether all the actions you are taking are wise decisions? While many people are aware of the red flags behind the scam, few articles have been written about the actual pricing of tokens. So Shaun, a member of the DAOrayaki community, compiled Living Opera's "Token Pricing in the Web3 Economy" to explore token pricing in the Web3 economy. Like most other activities, pricing tokens is more of an art than a science.


  Explain the reason for the increase in Token price


Let's start with the basics: risk and reward.


Cryptocurrencies are much more volatile than standard securities in the stock market. For example, Yukun Liu and Aleh Tsyvinski wrote a groundbreaking research paper in 2020 that found cryptocurrency had a daily return of 0.46%, while stocks had a daily return of 0.05%. Similarly, cryptocurrencies have returned 20.44% a month, while stocks have returned 0.94% a month. These are obvious differences, not to mention differences in skewness and kurtosis.



Even a simple report listing the distribution of different dimensions, like this shocking table, conveys a great deal about token volatility. The question is, what is driving all these changes?


There are two most frequently cited factors:


Network utilization (that is, how many users are on the network)

The cost of executing transactions (i.e., how expensive is the consensus mechanism)


Which of these factors is more important? Interestingly, Liu and Tsyvinsky (2020) found that measures of production costs, such as electricity prices or computing power, did not correlate with rates of return.


Overall, there is limited evidence that computational factors are important drivers of token returns ". They also found that macroeconomic and other currency fluctuations were not a material factor in the currency's rise.


They found, however, that network effects matter. The more users there are on a platform, the better the price is likely to perform. In Web2, it's easy to draw similar conclusions, like if you're the only user on Facebook, it's worthless to you because you can't communicate with other people. With Web3, however, this is less clear and not necessarily true.


After Yukun and Tsyvinski analyzed the network effects by quantifying the number of users, the number of active wallets, etc., they found that these variables were highly predictive of token price growth. Of course, this conclusion is not surprising, and tokens with more users may indeed perform better.


In fact, one of the great advantages of the Web3 era is that cross-chain operability is much easier. Because implicit data, whether explicit or based on consensus mechanisms, is often owned by individuals, this creates an incentive for cross-chain Bridges to form.


Yukun and Tsyvinski (2020) also explore the role played by investor attention to market events and find that it is also important. For example, they found that when investors increased their attention to a "bitcoin hacker" search by one standard deviation, it resulted in a 2% drop in overall cryptocurrency market returns over the next week. (Investor sentiment matters. They used the ratio of positive stories to negative stories to represent the positive and negative relationship between token price growth).


However, it is really difficult when you try to delve into the actual fundamentals behind tokens. Tokens have no "book value", updating a standard physical asset. Here are five examples from Yukun and Tsyvinski.


Cumulative token market return over the past 100 weeks

User market ratio & NBSP;

Address market ratio

Mark-to-market ratio

Pay market ratio


Everyone is trying to capture the "book value" of cryptocurrency assets over a long period of time, measured against the current market capitalization.


Interestingly, however, they found that these measures did not predict token growth either. Overall, the relationship between future token returns and the current ratio of token fundamentals to value is very weak." This is prime evidence that token fundamentals don't matter. Fundamentals, however, is always important, at least in the end is important, because is impossible to avoid the laws of physics, more fully shows that the results we are how to think token fundamental issues need to do more work, we are now on the analysis of the token in the communities are still largely in the "art form", not "scientific practice".


How is Token different from equity


While tokens and equity share many similarities, they also have some important differences, such as the utility value they offer on the blockchain being completely different. This consensus mechanism based on the use of blockchain adds an additional layer of security.


In traditional startups, founders and venture capitalists own equity. This means that decision-making is fairly centralized. It also means that very few employees and participants feel like real shareholders.


In the Web3 economy, the concept of shareholder becomes much broader. Suddenly, anyone with a token could be a shareholder in the underlying platform. That is, when there is a transaction, the token holder can get a slice of the whole transaction. Furthermore, if tokens are given governance capabilities, then token holders can vote on the development of the agreement, which means they can even influence the fee structure.


In addition to the larger spread of governance capabilities, Tokens provide an infinite number of ways to create utility for users. In Living Opera, for example, NFTs are being built around artwork to allow holders to access live concerts using NFT. Equity by itself provides only a cash entry point, but practical tokens provide experience and cash.


Just like equity can be diluted, so can tokens. It is important to see how a platform decides whether a different economic policy for its token offering is more inflation or more deflation, and this decision should be influenced by the following factors.


        What is the market of potential users?

        How does the composition of new users change?

        What are the existing users like?


Heuristic algorithm for Token pricing


It may be hard for anyone to think there is an exact price for tokens, but to make that idea a reality, we can create a provisional valuation by asking questions that serve as a guiding indicator.


What is the price of each token purchased on the platform today?

How much is the community expected to grow, and what is the fee structure at these different stages of growth?

What is the discount rate and what are the comparable investments?


These are obviously not an exhaustive set of questions, but they are probing questions that you can tie into the broader context of the entire article. Since there is currently no comprehensive evidence to explain the dispersion of token price growth, the best we can do now is to ask smart questions and create an AD hoc valuation as a guiding indicator.


The original link




Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit