Author: 0x2333
The NFT field can be said to be the most lively place in the Crypto circle today, bringing goods from various stars When major brands listed NFT as a new battlefield for brand announcements, more and more people began to understand the vigorous vitality of NFT and began to collect their first NFT. According to statistics, the current number of OpenSea users is as high as 1.24 million, which has soared 40 times in one year. In January 2022, OpenSea's single-month transaction volume will reach 4.9 billion US dollars.
This is a fertile soil, countless Builders hope to make some achievements here; and the frequent wealth effect has become the biggest billboard of NFT, Attracted countless profit seekers.
The pursuit of profit is a very normal thing. Everyone likes the accumulation and growth of personal wealth, but excessive pursuit of profit will endanger healthy development of the industry. Rhythm BlockBeats wrote this article to summarize the four major chaos in the NFT field recently, and deeply analyze the harm these behaviors will bring to the development of the industry. I hope investors and project parties can take warning.
February 10th Twitter user @NFTethics posted a Rug Pull warning about the popular project "Squiggles" and uploaded a 57-page PDF document to explain the risks in the Squiggles NFT project. It is mentioned in the document that the project team has previously operated more than 5 NFT fraud projects, all of which created false prosperity by purchasing fans, sweepstakes, purchasing advertising spaces, etc., and are strictly controlled At the same time as the release of the whitelist, the team members internally hyped the whitelist price, and immediately transferred all the income to run away after the public sale of the project.
Similarly, @NFTethics also exposed the recent high-profile NFT project "Cereal Club NFT (Oatmeal)". It is understood that the project was discovered because careful users found that it used the same code contract as another Rug Pull project HolyCowsNFT, and at the same time found co-founders of two NFT projects that should have nothing to do, and passed The outlier in the data intersection found that this team had launched multiple Rug Pull projects named MonaLisa, Baby Ape Club, Crypto Wolf Club, etc. Because of the exposure of @NFTethic, the Squiggles project side operated without authorization in order to cheat more income It was removed from OpenSea due to suspicion of fraud.
There are not a few NFT projects that "mass-produce" in the same way as Squiggles and Cereal to defraud funds, but in this era that values data, most of them can be fooled NFT players only have data. With hundreds of thousands of Twitter fans, each tweet is reposted tens of thousands of times, it is difficult not to attract the attention of NFT players and other project parties, and the project party continues to reassure community members by "showing off their wealth". The community is in the dark about the white list.
The traffic attracted by this pipelined publicity model can also reach the level of top projects, or even exceed them, but the current NFT market has many projects, and many projects The sale attracted funds that should have been circulated in the secondary market, and many project parties invested a lot of energy in the secondary market, and the income generated by the sale in the primary market was far less than the income generated by the sale in the primary market. This also made these project parties choose Rug Pull.
There are currently three income channels for most NFT projects, namely primary market income, secondary market royalty income, and NFT derivative income.
The primary market income refers to the income obtained through pre-sale and public sale. If the public sale is carried out, the total income of the project party will be around 500ETH. This part of the income is also the largest proportion of income.
The royalty income in the secondary market is much less. When NFT projects are circulated in the secondary market, royalties will be generated, and the royalties generally range from 5% to 10%. Taking 5% as an example, if you want to achieve the income of 500ETH from the public sale, at least the total transaction volume needs to reach more than 10,000 ETH, which is difficult for most projects today.
The last is the income of NFT derivatives, which requires NFT projects to launch derivative NFT products and obtain income based on the already high popularity, such as BAYC airdrop potions (Equivalent to airdropping a mutant monkey to the holder), the remaining 10,000 mutant monkeys will be sold in the form of a Dutch auction.
Compared with the income of the primary market, the secondary market and derivatives are full of uncertainties. The project party must not only maintain the popularity of the community, but also maintain the floor price Steadily rising, and at the same time, the roadmap has to be delivered, but with the popularity of Cereal Club NFT, even if they are all sold out at the lowest price through the Dutch auction, the project party can get at least 11 million US dollars. Compared with the income from the secondary market through community building, it is only a drop in the bucket.
As @NFTethics took the lead in speaking out, more and more NFT players have also joined the queue to crack down on "assembly line" NFT projects. The well-known encryption community Youtuber The Bitcoin Express also summarized in the video "4 Major NFT Red Flags To Avoid" how to use the information released by the NFT project party to help investors effectively avoid being cheated in the NFT market.
It’s cold in domestic emoticons After Rabbit released its own NFT avatar, Ali, another domestic emoji package IP, also announced its entry into the NFT field and released its own NFT avatar series. However, compared with Lengtu, Ali's operations fully prove that it is not yet ready to enter the Web3 era.
Ari’s community is very lively, but lively does not mean prosperity. Because the original IP has a high public awareness, so the Ali NFT The white list was also very popular at the beginning, and the off-exchange price was once as high as $1,000. However, due to the whitelist mechanism design and team decision-making issues, a large number of chatbots and studios tirelessly brushed the levels in the chat area. The names of community members were changed to ALI, and their profile pictures were changed to Ali. It was uniform, but there was nothing wrong with it. Cohesion can be said.
During the pre-sale, the community reported that there were various loopholes in Ahri, even the most basic word spelling mistakes, and some people even said that they would sell goods on Web3 Ahri uses "Web1.5" technology.

Let's talk about the copyright issue, Ah raccoon NFT is an NFT authorized by Ahri’s original IP party, which means that this NFT is not actually an official product sold by Ahri, but is only authorized to a certain publisher to make and sell NFT, just like Marvel can authorize many trendy games Just like the company produces and sells figurines, perhaps in the future the original IP side of Ahri will authorize a new issuer to re-release a set of NFTs, but in the era of Web3, will there still be fans who will pay for this Web2 behavior?
As of the time of writing, the Ali official has deleted the Weibo that has been published to promote this version of Ali NFT. Ali NFT also canceled the public sale and temporarily added 1,000 whitelists.
The most scarce resource in the Web3 era is attention, so IPs with their own traffic in the Web2 era will have a natural advantage in selling NFT in the Web3 era. This is why many outside stars, trendy brands and even emoji production teams choose to sell their own NFTs.
Compared with the original IP, the only advantage of the out-of-circle IP is its own traffic. As for how to convert traffic into the community, how to develop together with the community, and many other issues, the IP outside the circle and the original IP are actually on the same starting line. After entering the Web3 world, many IPs outside the circle are still looking at the big environment with a traditional perspective, trying to apply the Web2 methodology to Web3, which is obviously not feasible.
In the era of Web3, the brand is no longer just IP, but also includes the community behind the brand. The community and the brand are no longer a vassal relationship, but truly integrated One. It is extremely easy for IPs that already have a certain fan base to make a quick buck by selling NFTs, and whether they care about the community and their own community determines whether the quick money they earn is using their own traffic to cash it out or whether it is in the Lose your reputation.
One of the charms of Web3 is that the original brand and the community accompany each other. This accompanying growth may not allow the brand to grow rapidly in a short period of time. At present, there is no Web3 brand that can be compared with the giant brands of Web2. However, "Skin In The Game" will make the bond between the brand and the community more indestructible.
Whichever field you come to, you must abide by the rules of that field. In the circle of Web2, selling goods to fans may be regarded as "giving benefits", "selling Small souvenirs”, but in the Web3 world, this represents a responsibility. If the community is willing to spend money to support the brand, the brand must do things seriously to create value for the entire community. From accumulating value first and then consuming it slowly, to continuously creating value together with the community, Web3 has brought about unprecedented changes in the life cycle of brands. Every big brand trying to enter Web3 should face up to this and put away the arrogance from Web2 .
" Tasty Bones (Bones)" is undoubtedly the NFT project that has received the most attention in the past two months. Both the overall style of painting and promotional materials can be called exquisite. The white list of Tasty Bones is "hard to get a ticket."
The white list of the project adopts the mechanism of Mint Pass, and the players who get the white list can trade freely in the secondary market. Enthusiasm continued to rise, and the price of Mint Pass also rose, reaching 4ETH at one point. Just when everyone was expecting Tasty Bones to become the next "blue chip" project in one fell swoop, the price of blind box opening was surprising. As of press time, the floor price was only less than 1ETH, although it was dozens of times higher than the launch price. However, for most people who bought Mint Pass in the secondary market, it has already "broken".
In the face of high whitelist prices, it is difficult for ordinary community members to withstand the temptation, and players who were originally the main purchasing power in the secondary market, for the sake of safety Choosing to purchase MintPass in advance, this kind of excessive overdraft makes the existence of the whitelist completely become a bargaining chip for the project party to hype, and the mechanism of the whitelist has become worthless.
The white list mechanism was originally established to screen out "family members" who are willing to contribute to the community and grow up with the community, but now it has become With a stable low-cost arbitrage tool, people don’t have time to participate in the construction of each community when a large number of NFT projects are on sale today, and the whitelist acquisition method of most projects is almost zero cost, just need “hard work” You can win a white list, you can choose to sell off-market, or you can choose to buy NFT in the primary market at a very low cost and arbitrage in the secondary market.
For the project party and the community, this is a severe test they are facing.
Rhythm BlockBeats previously published "In order to buy an NFT, I learned English and drawing" describes the current status of the whitelist acquisition mechanism that has long deviated from the original intention. In fact, whether it is chat level, number of invitees, secondary creation, etc., various forms can instinctively screen out the members who love the community the most, but where there is a wealth effect, there will be speculators, not to mention that participation is zero cost.
Although there are currently some project parties who choose to build the community and select actively participating members through decryption, singing, etc., but there are people who can find countermeasures in every form , Some people sell answers for decryption, some people find substitute singers for singing, and obtain a white list that may bring great profits at a lower cost, but the community can only continue to face difficult problems.
The conscientious project party will try to send the white list to the members who are really willing to participate in community construction, while some project parties completely use the incentive mechanism such as the white list As a tool for hype, many project parties have set up whitelists for off-market transactions or official sales whitelists internally, in order to increase the cost of the floor price before the release, and may create anxiety about the whitelist before the project is released, causing focus on. As everyone knows, this is the project party overdrafting its own "value" in advance.
As mentioned above, through various marketing methods such as hunger marketing and the whitelist acquisition mechanism, you can make your Twitter data look good and your Discord It seems extremely lively, and this false prosperity will make many people mistakenly believe that the project has great potential, but in fact it may be just a feather in the ground.
Perhaps we should all reflect on it. Although the starting point of the whitelist model is good, judging from the current situation, the whitelist is not very good How to motivate their loyal community members is a topic that all practitioners need to rethink.
Last week, the biggest hot spot in the NFT circle was the dispute of Club721.
On February 12th, the largest Chinese NFT community, Club721, caused disputes among various communities due to internal administrator corruption of the whitelist and loose management of team leaders. That night, the two parties held their own opinions and broke the news on Twitter Space, which lasted for 7 hours. At the same time, the number of online listeners exceeded 1,000, which once caused the Twitter Space server to crash. One accused the other of embezzling the whitelist, and the other accused the other Not given the incentives they deserved. After that night, more inside stories about the founders of Club721 and Open Dao continued to ferment.
This is another dispute caused by the whitelist, and it just reflects the problem that the distributed company structure and the DAO organization are facing: the governance model with incentive mode.
Since the spread of the new crown epidemic around the world, more and more enterprises and companies have begun to adopt a more loosely distributed office in terms of governance; and DAO has always been used by Web3 residents It is believed to be a new organizational structure that can replace the traditional corporate system, and it has also attracted the attention of top investment institutions such as a16z. But both of them also face problems.
The first problem is management and governance.
At present, the most commonly used governance method of DAO organizations is voting, and most voting weights are given according to the holdings of tokens or NFTs. Such a simple and crude method does not Considering the experience and expertise of each DAO member, and the result of such voting is likely to be in the wrong direction or the direction with extremely low efficiency. Cases that result in a loss of stake are decided by community members voting.
The reason why DAO organizations like FWB can succeed is because they do not have a clear and concrete purpose, they are more like a society, organized Most of the activities have nothing to do with efficiency, so we can lay a solid foundation and gradually grow bigger. It is not for nothing that people have adopted a centralized corporate system for many years, but it is due to the consideration of improving efficiency. In the Web2 world, many companies also adopt a management method that is as flat as possible to achieve "semi-decentralization"; in the Web3 era, DAO also needs to find a more suitable governance model to achieve better decentralization and efficiency. balance.
Although distributed companies can formulate a set of strict rules and regulations, the relatively loose management model still has room to exploit, and the vacancy of internal control links will lead to Embezzlement, corruption and other problems occur frequently, and no one can find out.
Another focus of this turmoil is the issue of incentives.
The company system should be handled in a company way, and the salary should be fixed and paid as agreed; if it is a DAO, it is necessary to formulate an incentive that everyone can be satisfied with plan. The formulation of the incentive mechanism will first encounter the obstacles of the above-mentioned governance mechanism. It is difficult to efficiently formulate a plan that satisfies all parties, and it will also encounter efficiency problems during implementation.
Whether it is a company or a DAO, incentives are the fuel and the guarantee for employees and DAO members to continue to contribute. Distributed and DAO management structures are inherently loose. If you don’t get the incentives you deserve for long-term contributions, you may be reluctant to continue to contribute at least, or you will dig more and more loopholes in internal control. It is not difficult to know what money can be earned, but what is difficult is to know what money cannot be earned. In the face of huge profit temptation and loose internal review mechanism, who can guarantee to stick to the original intention?
NFT is a brand new fertile soil. As practitioners, we all have the obligation to maintain its environment and make it sustainable. We should face up to the development path The problems encountered will solve all kinds of chaos one by one, and the joint protection industry will stride forward in the right direction.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia