How to Value an NFT Project?
Othmane Senhaji Rhazi is a Web 3 entrepreneur.
Hei Mi, Bai Ze Research Institute
I am an entrepreneur who is a big advocate for Web3 and NFT because I believe we are witnessing social, economic and innovative breakthroughs. NFT is an innovation that tokenizes things that have intrinsic value or appreciation value on a large scale through unique assets on the blockchain, and has the potential to be shared.
Who is this frame for?
- Enthusiasts of NFT projects,
- Web3/NFTs Advocate,
- Anyone interested in learning more about Web3 /NFT.
After one month of being active in over 60 NFT communities and investing over $100,000, I developed a score metric to better evaluate NFT projects.
Grade = 20% (A) + 10% (T)+ 30% (C)+ 30% (U)+ 10% (S)
These are in part as follows:
A = art
T = team
C = community
U = utility
S = cultural significance
Each section (art, team, community, etc.) can have a score from 0 to 5.
Zero is extremely poor appreciability.
5 is a strong appreciation.
We can divide the score within each section. The sum of these scores is the score for that part.
Each section score has a weight applied to its score based on its relevance and importance.
The total score is determined by multiplying the score of each section by its weight.
Quality: How do you feel about art? (Score between 0 and 4)
High level of effort: Requires strong expertise such as 2D, 3D or animation (0 to 1 point)
Aesthetics: Is it attractive? Do you like it? Harmony? (0 to 0.5 points)
Rarity: What character is the series built on? How many different features are there? (0 to 0.5 points)
Distinguishable: How distinguishable are these features? (0 to 0.5 points)
Brand capability:   Do the characters have a potential collaborative impact, i.e. fashion, retail, music, community? (0 to 2 points)
Copyrights: Who do they belong to? (Score 0 or 1)
Creator, (0 points)
Holder, (1 point)
CC0 (in the public domain, i.e. no one owns it). (0.5)
Public image :(score from 0 to 0.5)
Is the founder/core team public or anonymous? (0.5)
Pattern: & have spent (Score from 0 to 1)
What is the track record, relevance, and vision of the core team? (0.5)
Are there any upcoming partnerships or collaborations that could add impact to the series? (0.5)
Fan size :(score from 0 to 0.5)
Do they have a large following of fans (0.5 points)
Activities :(score from 0 to 3)
How often do they interact with the community? (0.5)
Is their participation relevant? (0.5)
Was it carefully reviewed (module teams, time zone stops, channel segmentation, etc.)? (1)
Are they starting their community with updates to their roadmap/questions/polls? (1)
Human or robot (0 to 1) :
Check social engagement: Discord's likes, views, retweets, activities and reactions. (0 to 1 points)
The Discord community for most NFT projects has more than 100,000 members, but little participation, with = >; 95% bots and fake accounts to hype the project.
What real users think (0 to 2) :
Bulk holders: Listed and collectible items (e.g. 1000/10000). (1)
Do not cling to FP (floor price). (0 to 0.5 points)
Participate in the future of the project and its roadmap. (0 to 0.5 points)
Bonus points (0 to 0.5 points) :
Rich and famous people (0 to 0.5 points)
Social media fan activity (0 to 1.5) :
Discord Member (0.25 points),
Percentage of holders (0.25 points),
Social followers (Twitter, Instagram), (0.25 points),
Dissonance: Announcements and Member participation (0.5 points)
Social media: Retweets, likes and comments (0.25 points).
Practicality is the fuel of the community and the foundation upon which the potential strengths of the project are built.
Roadmap (0 to 2 points) :
Synthesis (Display, Art, Play2earn (P2E), Future Airdrop, Benefits, timeline)
Metauniverse Footprint: Is there a headquarters in the metauniverse on Decentraland or Sandbox that community members can share and meet with? Is there a platform for holders?
Community-driven (DAO based, whitelist of holders, interests)
DeFi: Are there tokens built for the project to allow for different rewards and multiple perspectives?
Privileges (0 to 1) :
Parties and events (parties, conferences, focus groups, holiday events, etc.)
Partnerships (brands, artists, collections and privileged access)
Exclusive goods (privileged access to specific goods)
Make friends (visit high-end profiles of entrepreneurs, athletes, coaches and others in the community)
Defi mechanism (0 to 0.5) :
Airdrop (derivative of NFT, e.g. Cyborg airdrop free Cydog for the holder)
Pledge (can you pledge NFT in the game? For example: Mobox or Zookeeper)
borrowing
Exchanges (Views and trading volume of different exchanges: Opensea, Rarible, NiftyGateaway, etc.)
Bonus (0 to 0.5 points) :
Commodity (airdrop to NFT holder)
Community rewards (access to upcoming new NFT and free casting, etc.)
Benefits (0 to 0.5 points) :
In-game power boost (NFT holder specific feature in P2E games)
Game strengths (speed, power)
Price (0 to 0.5 points) :
Is the entry fee appropriate? (Casting price +Gas charge)
What is the precedent for floor prices? (Stability or collapse?)
What is your target and expected holding time?
- Age group: is the project limited to specific age group culture? Or does it remind users of the past (cartoons, games, habits, interests, etc.)? (0 to 3 points)
- Is it easy for celebrities and influencers (actors, artists, athletes, vloggers, etc.) to accept? (0 to 0.25 points)
- Social trends: volume of searches, articles and videos? (0 to 0.25 points)
- die for? (0 to 0.25 points)
- Fan trends? (0 to 0.25 points)
- Is it innovative enough to inspire other NFTS: art, utility, mechanics, roadmaps? (0 to 1 points)
After evaluating the scores for these different sections, I will set weights for each section (which can be adjusted to your liking) :
Art (20%)
Founders and teams account for 10%.
The composition of the community accounts for 30%
Practicality is 30%
Culture (10%)
Assume the following scores for each section:
A (art) = 4
T team is equal to 3
C (community) = 5
U (practicality) = 4
S (culture) = 3
This will result in:
Total score = 20% x 4 + 10% x 3+ 30% x 5+ 30% x 4 + 10% x 4 = 0.8 + 0.3 + 1.5 + 1.2 + 0.4 = 4.2
I usually choose when the total score is 4-5.
Last but not least, we can also adjust the score model differently by tracking project performance based on evaluation scores and collection floor price growth/decline.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia