The Economist
原文编译: Unitime 南风
For believers, open public blockchains offer a second chance to build a digital economy. The fact that applications built on top of these blockchains collaborate and the information they store is visible to everyone harks back to the idealism of the early architects of the Internet, before most users embraced the walled gardens offered by the tech giants. Over the past year, a new "decentralized" digital economy has become possible as applications built on various blockchains have boomed in size and functionality.
Perhaps the most important part of this digital economy is decentralized finance (DeFi) apps, which enable users to trade assets, obtain loans and store deposits. Now, the battle for market share in this area is intensifying. Most importantly, Ethereum, the leading DeFi platform, seems to be losing its near-monopoly. The race shows how DeFi has been influenced by the standards Wars that have broken out among other emerging technologies -- think SONY's Betamax vs VHS video battles in the 1970s -- and how DeFi technology has advanced at lightning speed.
The idea behind DeFi is that blockchains -- or databases spread across many computers and kept secure by encryption -- can help replace centralised institutions like multinational banks and technology platforms. The value of assets stored in the nascent financial system (DeFi) has climbed from less than $1 billion in early 2020 to more than $1 billion today. $200 billion, see chart below.
Above: Growth of assets stored in DeFi applications since 2020. Source: DeFi Llama
Until recently, the Ethereum blockchain was the undisputed dominant player in all of this DeFi activity. Ethereum was created in 2015 as a more generic version of Bitcoin. Bitcoin's database stores transaction information about the underlying cryptocurrency, known as BTC, providing proof of who owns what at any given time. Ethereum, by contrast, stores more information, such as lines of computer code. Coded Ethereum applications are guaranteed to behave as written code, eliminating the need for mediations. But just as Ethereum continues to improve on Bitcoin, it is now being usurped by newer and better technologies. Jeremy Allaire, the boss of Circle, which publishes the popular STABlecoin USDC, says the competition is like that between computer operating systems.
Current blockchain technology is clunky and slow. Both Bitcoin and Ethereum use a mechanism called "PoW" (proof of work), in which computers compete to solve mathematical problems to verify transactions in exchange for rewards. This slows down the network and limits capacity. Bitcoin can only process seven transactions per second; Ethereum can only handle 15 transactions. When the network is busy, transactions are either slow or expensive (and sometimes both). When the demand to complete transactions on the Ethereum network is high, transaction fees paid to the computers (nodes) that validate those transactions go up, and settlement times increase. You can spend $70 to exchange $500 for ETH and then wait several minutes to transfer from one encrypted wallet to another.
Developers have long tried to increase ethereum's capacity. In fact, one direction is to transform the consensus mechanism of blockchain. Later this year, developers plan to turn Ethereum into a more scalable mechanism called "PoS" (proof of stake). Another idea is to break up the blockchain. (This is done through a process called sharding). These shards will share the load, increasing capacity. In addition, some developers are working on ways to bundle deals. (e.g., & have spent Rollups) to reduce the number of transactions that must be verified directly (on the L1 main network).
The problem is that every advance comes with a cost. DeFi's supporters tout its ability to conduct transactions safely and without the involvement of centralised intermediaries. But scalability gains must be weighed against the loss of security or decentralization. Centralize transactions before they reach the blockchain, which is typically done by centralized entities. It may be easier for hackers to attack one shard of a blockchain than the entire blockchain. As a result, Ethereum developers have been slowly making changes.
The slowness has hurt the network in another way -- by boosting the rise of rivals. In early 2021, almost all of the assets locked up in DeFi apps were on Ethereum's network. But a recent research note from JPMorgan Chase estimated that the share of assets locked up in DeFi apps on Ethereum had fallen to 70% by the end of 2021. A growing number of other networks, like Avalanche, Binance Smart Chain, Terra, and Solana, now use PoS to run blockchains that do the same basic job as Ethereum, but at a faster and lower cost. Avalanche and Solana, for example, each process thousands of transactions per second.
The experience of the DOLLAR stablecoin USDC illustrates these shifts. USDC launched on the Ethereum network three years ago, but has since been rolled out on a number of rival networks, including Algorand, Hedera and Solana. Jeremy Allaire, the boss of Circle, the publishing company behind USDC, says that whereas transactions on Ethereum are subject to cost and speed limits, those on Solana can handle "visa-size transactions", "settling in about 400 milliseconds and costing about one-twentieth of a penny". Other DeFi apps, such as SushiSwap, an exchange founded on Ethereum, have also been launched on several other blockchain networks.
Jpmorgan's Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou wrote that with some changes in Ethereum's plans likely to take at least a year, if not longer, "the risk is... that the Ethereum network will lose market share further". For Jeremy Allaire, the current landscape is full of competition. "Just like in the web space, there is competition between Windows, iOS and Android, and there is competition between blockchain platforms." The ultimate winners, he argues, will be networks that attract the best developers to build apps and thus reap network effects.
But that operating system analogy may only go so far, in part because of the nature of open public blockchains. Anyone can access the data they generate and see their operating codes, making it possible to build "Bridges" or applications that span multiple blockchain networks, as well as applications that aggregate information between different blockchains. Some applications, such as decentralized exchange aggregators & NBSP; 1Inch, has been "scanning" exchanges across the blockchain to find the best strike price for cryptocurrency trades; And like & have spent Polkadot And & have spent Cosmos Such "multi-chain" blockchains operate like "Bridges" between different networks, making it possible to operate across networks.
As long as DeFi has the potential to succeed, the competition to become the DeFi network of choice will naturally intensify. But the idea of "winner takes all and gains total control over the digital economy and how it develops" may one day be as obsolete as videotape.
*** This article represents the views of the original author only and does not constitute any investment opinion or recommendation.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia