header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

The NFT works deleted by OpenSea triggered a big discussion on Web3: Is it really better than Web2?

Read this article in 15 Minutes
web3 is at least nerdy-level new - creating a space for creativity/exploration reminiscent of the early internet days.
Original title: ""Who Moved My JPEG?" - Triggering the Web 3 Opinion Controversy"
Original source: Tao of the Metaverse


Last weekend, Moxie Marlinspike, the founder of the well-known encrypted communication application Signal, published an article entitled "My First Impressions on web3" (Chinese version ‌by Chain Catcher), which aroused heated discussions in the encryption circle. It is reported that Moxie conducted in-depth research after developing two decentralized applications and creating NFT works but was deleted by Opensea. He found that Metamask didn't actually show the contents of his account on the Ethereum blockchain. Instead, the wallet app relies on the Opensea API to check which NFTs are associated with which blockchain account.


This result reminded Moxie of "Web 2", he said that Web3 cannot move us from Centralized platforms, and web3 will not fundamentally change our relationship with technology. As for why so many people are excited about it, Moxie said that web3 is at least nerdy-level new - creating a space for creativity/exploration reminiscent of the early internet era. But ironically, part of this creativity may stem from the constraints that make web3 so unwieldy.


In this regard, Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin‌, Facebook engineer and Dropbox CTO Aditya Agarwal‌ and Dror Poleg, a columnist in "The Wall Street Journal", "New York Times" and other publications, expressed his own views. The following is a compilation of relevant content.


V God: The most cutting-edge encryption technology is being researched, Moxie has no Get to


image


The word "server" is not very useful in the context of blockchain; it combines concepts that are best treated separately . In particular, consider that users can connect to the blockchain in the following ways:


1. Use a Binance account.


2. Run a piece of code that asks an Infura API endpoint what the blockchain state is, and trust the answer. However, the keys are still kept locally; the code signs the transaction locally and sends it to the Infura API endpoint for rebroadcasting.


3. Same as 2, but the code also runs a light client to verify the signature of the block header, and uses Merkle proofs to verify personal accounts and store data.


4. Same as 3, but the code talks to N different API endpoints run by N different companies, so only one of them needs to provide an honest answer, Connections are reliable.


5. Same as 4, but instead of pre-specifying N API endpoints, the code directly connects to a P2P network.


6. Same as 5, but the code also does data availability sampling and accepts fraud proofs, so it can detect and reject invalid blocks.


7. Run a fully validating node.


8. Run a fully verified node and participate in mining/staking at the same time.


Currently, only 1, 2, 7 and 8 are feasible, and 7 and 8 are Too expensive for most users. In fact, the whole reason blockchain is the future of decentralization and self-hosting isn't is that running a 24/7 online server is even harder than 8 [if your staked nodes are only online 95% of the time, fine; if Your website is only online 95% of the time, then this is causing serious annoyance to your users! ]


Moxie's criticism in the second half of the post makes me think that the criticism of the current state of the ecosystem is Correct (of which 1, 2, 7, and 8 are the only things we have working code for), but they miss where the blockchain ecosystem is headed. There are already teams working on implementing 3, 4, 5, and actively working on how to implement 6. These efforts, contrary to Moxie's claims that cryptography is rarely involved (which is true for most of what's happening today!), are largely based on some cutting-edge and advanced cryptography. Verkle trees, ZK-SNARKs for the EVM, BLS signature aggregation, and more.


As for my theory about why this hasn't been posted yet, I would say, Much of this is down to limited technical resources and funding. It's easier to build things in a lazy, centralized way, whereas getting it "right" requires serious effort. The Ethereum ecosystem didn't have that many resources until ~4 years ago.


Of course, ~4 years ago, the ecosystem did start to have a lot of resources, but new projects were slow to start and the centralized way of working had Years of head start. One thing that makes the climb slower is the dependency chain: in order to have light clients, we need to have a light client friendly chain, which is a deep change to the protocol, so the only realistic chance is to switch to PoS, while We are only now at the point where we have PoS, full integration of the merger is coming.


Fortunately, these dependencies are being tackled and resolved one by one, and great progress has been made! Once the common hard work is done by a few dedicated teams, building trustless applications becomes much more feasible for all development teams to just plug in these libraries.


So I think a properly authenticated decentralized blockchain world is coming, and more than Many imagined it was closer to that. Of course, there's always the possibility that all of this technology will be built and many people won't care. But I am more optimistic. Users generally accept the defaults given by developers, and many developers do genuinely care about decentralization and trustless issues (and the growing legal issues of running centralized trustpoints will drive them to care even more).


Decentralized options that users reject today (e.g. running a full node) are indeed quite difficult today, so users stick with more centralized Options are understandable, at least they are easily accessible. None of the suggestions listed here are that difficult, and even running a full node itself will become easier and cheaper over time as ideas like statelessness and history expiration come into play. So I see no technical reason why the future needs to look like the status quo today.


Facebook Engineer: Don't Focus It's much more interesting to build than to try to predict


image


Moxie had a great blog post about his observations on Web3 that got me thinking a bit about centralization, protocols, platforms and finally what we predict in this space Basic questions of competence.


An interesting framework in the post is the relationship of "protocol" to "platform". In short, protocols are difficult and slow to develop. That's not in dispute, but I also think that everyone's mental model of a "protocol" is the current protocols like HTTP, SMTP, etc. All of these protocols are *stateless*. This has long been an accepted (and generally correct) protocol design pattern.


For web3, the big difference is that they are stateful protocols. In that sense, I don't think the speed at which protocols evolve is really the right mental model. If state is universally accessible, it is easier to remix and orchestrate.


There aren't many examples of such "protocols" yet, which is why we all Not sure how it compares to traditional models, which isn't surprising.


More broadly, I think there is a lot of "technological determinism" oriented commentary on web3 . For example, web3 leads to some points of centralization (examples: Alchemy, OpenSea), so it doesn't satisfy utopian goals of complete decentralization, etc.


I find this comment somewhat naive as it ignores how technology is ultimately woven in. Most things don't appear cleanly in one world or the other. It will be confusing. Things will feel like they cross ideological boundaries.


The future is here, but it's not evenly distributed, only a part of it is captured. More likely, the future will be intertwined with the past for a long time to come. It's basically the same conversation we're seeing around autonomy, artificial intelligence, SaaS, etc.


The world is too complex to attempt to predict in any form. Instead, I tend to think about whether the underlying idea is useful and can be used. In this sense, blockchains, NFTs, DAOs, Defi, etc. are super interesting constructs that will be used to create interesting things.


Don't focus on trying to predict. Building is much more fun.


Wall Street Journal Column Author Dror Poleg: I don't believe that web3 will be more fair and free


< /p>

image


Crypto is interesting because Because of the freedom it brings, not the freedom users currently care about. (Response to Moxie)


A Hungarian Sausage Story


"Jews, Germans and oil are our best exports," dictator Nicolae Ceaușescu boasted in the 1970s. He was talking about my grandmother, my father and my uncle.


Some people like living in the Socialist Republic of Romania, but my grandmother didn't. After surviving Auschwitz, she wanted to give her children something better than anti-Semitism. But she couldn't just pack up and leave. Someone has to buy her.


Since 1945, Romania has collected over $100 million in cash and other goods in exchange for Jewish. As Zahra Tara recounts in The Great Departure:


"Using Romanian Jewish The exchange of money and agricultural products began insidiously after World War II. A Jewish businessman in London named Henry Jacober acted as an intermediary between Western privates and the Romanian Secret Service. With a briefcase full of cash, Jacober Typically $4,000 to $6,000 per immigrant (depending on the individual's age and education) in exchange for an exit permit to the West.


< p>When Israeli intelligence officials learned of these deals, they decided to join the scheme, with Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion's approval. At Khrushchev's insistence, Romanians began demanding agricultural products instead of cash. Soon, Romania of Jews were traded for everything from cows and pigs to chicken farms and cornflake factories... Depending on the immigrant's age, education, occupation, family status and political importance, the price of exit can reach 50,000 Dollar".


In 1962, my grandmother, father and uncle managed to get exit visas and board the Flight to Rome. They are only allowed to bring clothes, sheets and food for the trip. Everything else -- property, electrical appliances, jewelry, books, even photos -- had to stay in Romania.


To start the family fortune in the New World, my father and uncle brought some Hungarian sausage . They heard a rumor that Italians were generous with this rare delicacy. But this rumor is wrong. After days of running the streets of Naples without finding generous customers, my father and uncle threw the sausages away and boarded a boat to Israel.


Most of the time, being able to pack up and leave is not important to most people. But when it happens, it matters.


Recent discussions about the promises and limitations of cryptocurrencies/Web3 got me thinking about those Hungarian sausages . Our current predicament seems comical in light of the tragedies of history. But they could end up having a big impact.


In 2022, the smartest minds in the world are debating digital tokens, monkey JPEGs and super The problem with bowl ads. Last week, the Financial Times quoted my review of a shoddy ad starring Matt Damon, while The Guardian ran an article on why the Boring Ape NFT is actually worthless.


A more substantive contribution to the debate about the future of the Internet comes from Moxie Marlinspike, who He is the founder of the private messaging app Signal. Moxie shared his "first impressions of web3" in a blog post.


The bottleneck of decentralization


The vision of web3 is admirable. But Moxie set out to understand how decentralized "sausage" is made in practice. However, this did not impress him.


Moxie's first concern is that Web3 is not as decentralized as it claims change. In this case, access to the basic infrastructure of web3 (the Ethereum blockchain) ends up going through several popular API providers. So even though the blockchain itself is decentralized, most applications that rely on it are still bottlenecked by centralization and run by private, for-profit entities.


For example, if a person buys a piece of gold and stores it in In a keyed vault down the mountain maintained by the Swiss Bank. When the person logs into the bank's app to check his gold balance, the app doesn't send someone into the vault to check how much gold is there or if someone has tampered with the key to the vault. Instead, it simply displays data from a third-party database that records bullion inflows and outflows across the mountain. So the client gets the latest information, but it doesn't get the straight, indisputable truth.


The bank does this because it maintains a central database that records all deposits and Sending money is much easier than sending someone in person every time a customer logs into the app. Ethereum-based applications use API providers for the same reason: it's easier and simpler for them to do so than to verify each query itself on the blockchain.


This choice of expediency over decentralization is a good idea in some use cases Bad, and harmless in other use cases. The problems Moxie raises are well known, ethereum developers have spoken and written about them publicly, and are working on ways to mitigate them. And I've also written about how each wave of decentralization simultaneously spawned a wave of centralization.


However, Moxie ignores (or does not mention) these issues and the current Web 2.0 One essential difference between what happens in . We'll discuss that in a minute. But first, let's look at Moxie's second concern.


No benefit


After trying to build a decentralized application and encountering a centralized API, Moxie created an NFT and listed it on OpenSea, the most popular NFT marketplace online.


NFTs are a prime example of web3's promise to free users from powerful platforms. Even though NFTs can be created and listed on platforms like OpenSea, they are not stored on those platforms. When you create or buy an NFT, that action is recorded on the blockchain itself.


This means you can buy an NFT on one platform and "carry it" to a different platform, or without anyone else's permission sell it to other people. You can use a cryptocurrency wallet like Metamask or Rainbow to access all your funds and assets on the blockchain without having to log into any specific platform.


This may sound like nonsense. Why would anyone want to buy or sell tokens that give ownership of digital goods? But when you consider that in 2021 humans will spend over $60 billion on games, or $13 billion on digital music streaming, or $22 billion on digital artwork -- you start to see a The value of digitally native ownership systems.


In Web 2.0, you can buy a movie on Amazon Prime, or on Apple You can buy a song on Music, but if you decide to leave the platform (or get kicked), you lose access to those assets. The goal of NFTs is to enable users to directly own their stuff, take it with them, and move the power away from platforms and companies.


But this was not the Moxie experience.


Who moved my JPEG?


Moxie created an NFT on OpenSea and intentionally programmed the manifest to be It looks different on different platforms (by loading different images, depending on the IP of the requesting website). Initially, he can see the NFT in his cryptocurrency wallet, meaning his ownership of it is recorded on the Ethereum blockchain. However, a few days later, OpenSea decided to remove his NFT from their marketplace, claiming that Moxie violated their terms of service (due to the code changing what users see).


Technically, the fact that OpenSea has decided to remove NFTs from their marketplace should not have question. Moxie still owns it, and this ownership is independent of OpenSea, recorded on the blockchain itself. But when Moxie checked his cryptocurrency wallet app, he found that the NFT had disappeared. How is this possible?


Moxie dug deeper and found that the wallet app he was using (Metamask) didn't really show The contents of his account on the Ethereum blockchain. Instead, his wallet app relies on an API to check which NFTs are associated with which blockchain account, and that API is none other than the OpenSea API! Since Moxie’s NFT has been removed from OpenSea, the API says it no longer exists.


This feels like Web 2.0 all over again. A powerful platform successfully confiscated/deleted data and assets from a user's account without his consent.


However, what happened to Moxie is not the same as when a Web 2.0 platform decides to delete a user file or list There is an essential difference between what happens.


If Moxie uses a different app, check his NFT directly on the blockchain , then he can see that the NFT still exists. In fact, you can also see that NFT on OpenSea competitor Rarible. Going back to our earlier analogy, the bullion is still inside the vault, inside the mountain, even though the bank's app doesn't show it.


Of course, popular wallet apps don't show what's in people's accounts (although the stuff still there) is a problem. But the good news is that while OpenSea deleted Moxie's NFT, that NFT "survived" and is still in its place. I'm pretty sure Moxie ended up making a lot of money when someone bought it as a memento of the whole event. And I've already bid.


Afterword


< /p>

Unlike my father, if I need to move, I can take most of my assets and cash-generating businesses with me. If the US decides to kick me out (or sell me back to Romania!), as long as I can use my Twitter, Gmail, Maven, and Stripe accounts, I can keep making money. The biggest threat to my livelihood is not losing my citizenship; it's losing access to my accounts on multiple platforms.


Crypto and web3 promise to increase my freedom to switch between the platforms I rely on, and My chances of surviving hostilities on one of the platforms. This promise is only partially fulfilled so far, and may never be fully realized.


Unlike some, I don't believe web3 will be more just or fair, or even default to more freedom. But I do believe it offers the possibility of increasing our freedom and agency. And, on the basis of general and personal history, this possibility was enough to pique my curiosity and gain my support.


For most users, the freedom to pack and move your digital assets and identity is not unimportant. But one day it might matter, and when it does, it will matter a lot.

There is still a lot of work to do along the way. Glad to have you on board, Moxie.


------------------- ---------------------

So, for Web3, your evaluation what is it Is it "the road is obstructed and long", or "this web3 will be fine".


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit