header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

What is the best valuation method of public chain Token?

Read this article in 7 Minutes
Don't price Ethereum, Solana, etc., like a "company." Price them like a "nation."
Opinion: The best way to value public chain tokens is not by "company", but by "country" pricing
原文来源: Tascha Che,mysoundwise.com 创始人,宏观经济学博士
Smell the chain


1. Many people try to value the underlying public chain (L1) token like a stock.


This is ridiculous.


Don't price Ethereum, Solana, etc., like a "company." Price them like a "nation."


That's it.


2. The first wrong way to evaluate L1 tokens: earnings multiples.


Some people apply the value investment framework of stocks to blockchain, and put forward concepts such as price-to-earnings ratio and price-to-sales ratio around ETH, SOL and AVAX.


3. Unsurprisingly, these rates look alarmingly high. High enough to give any value enthusiast a heart attack.


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


That's the problem. Revenue is the ultimate goal of corporate value. But they don't apply to calculating value for the common chain.


5. If Ethereum were to halve its average Gas fee tomorrow, a similar p/E factor would double. Does that mean ethereum was twice as overvalued? Not at all. Instead, it will be a boon for platform growth.


6. Since the value of blockchain comes from how much economic activity the token holder supports, no matter what percentage of that activity is pocketed as "profit" by the platform.


7. The absurdity of valuation ratios becomes obvious if you view the public chain as a sovereign economic ecosystem akin to a state.


If the US doubled all tax rates, the US government's "price-earnings ratio" would fall by half. But is it good for the U.S. economy? Hardly any.


8. Structurally, government activity accounts for a larger share of the economy in some countries than in others. All else being equal, China (with a relatively high share of state assets) will trade at a lower p/E than the US (with a low share of state assets). Does this really say anything about the economic value of these two economies? It doesn't make any sense.


9. The second wrong way to value L1 tokens: discounted cash flow (DCF). DCF, another common framework for borrowing stock valuations, is actually more ridiculous.


10. The DCF model of the stock looks like this:


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


11. This is a good approach because the company's future cash flows are denominated in the same currency, such as the US dollar.


12. But Solana and Ethereum's future cash flows are measured in SOL and ETH, not dollars. So you need to make assumptions about the exchange rate for each period in the future to come up with DCF in DOLLARS.


Solana's DCF model looks like this:


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


13. This is completely useless as USD/SOL exchange rate has to be calculated first.


Instead of using a company valuation model, L1 tokens should be valued as the currencies of "cryptocurrency countries".


L1 token is a new type of asset. They are some kind of stock, some kind of bond, some kind of currency. But the bigger the blockchain platform, the more it looks like a sovereign economy, and its native token is a real currency.


15. Currency exchange rate models are therefore more useful than stock dividend models in valuing L1 tokens.


16. Unfortunately, when you try to estimate exchange rates, it's like stirring up a hornet's nest. There are a million factors influencing the relative prices of different currencies, and hundreds of frameworks and assumptions that could fill a library of books on the exact estimation process.


17. But there is a simple and elegant framework -- arguably the closest thing to fundamental analysis -- which is a quantitative model of money.


The specific formula is:


Money supply (M) · velocity of money circulation (V) = Price (P) · Real GDP (Y)

Rearranging the equation, you can express the price level as:


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


What does this have to do with the exchange rate?


19. Assuming that the output of any two economies is replaceable, and therefore price differences can be arbitraged (which is obviously not the case in many cases, but does not affect our purpose as long as the direction is correct), by the way, the relationship between the price levels of the currencies of country A and country B is as follows:


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


20. A simple example: a hamburger costs 1 euro in Germany and $1.50 in the United States, so dollar/euro exchange rate = 1.5.


Substituting this equation back into the previous domestic price level equation, you get:


If it is not clear, assume


Country A = United States


Country B = Ethereum,


What you get:


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


22. This means that the exchange rate of ETH against the US dollar will appreciate under the following circumstances:


Ethereum GDP (Y_ETH) grows faster than US GDP (Y_US)


Us money supply (M_US) is growing faster than Ethereum money supply (M_ETH)


The velocity of dollar currency (V_US) grows faster than that of ETH currency (V_ETH).


23. If you take the equation at face value, there should be a one-to-one relationship between the growth rate of ETH prices in dollar terms and the growth rate of the US money supply. The Fed's balance sheet has expanded massively since last year, as evidenced by what has happened to ETH prices.


24. But that's not the most interesting part.


Interestingly, the ETH price growth rate and the ETHEREum GDP growth rate (i.e., the total output of the Ethereum economy) should also have a 1:1 relationship.


25. Apparently, there is no statistics bureau compiling "GDP" for "Ethereum countries". However, GDP growth can be indirectly inferred from the growth rates of transactions, wallets, and total lock-up value (TVL).


Almost every transaction involves some additional economic output. The increase in wallets can be thought of as an increase in the country's "working population". The growth of TVL reflects the growth of the financial sector of the economy.


Of course, these are not perfect measures. But the point is that they are positively correlated with the additional economic output generated on the platform.


The actual data confirm the relationship between these variables and the token/DOLLAR exchange rate.


28. Incidentally, the growth in trading volume shows a near-linear correlation with the price growth of Ethereum and ETH: a 10% increase in trading volume means an average 13% increase in price.


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


29. Similarly, a 10% increase in the number of wallets means an average 7% increase in prices.


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


30. The next one is even more striking. The acceleration of wallet growth (i.e., the growth rate of new wallets) has an almost 1:1 relationship with ETH price growth.


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


31. And that's not all.


Software development in the virtual world is like construction in the real economy -- a leading indicator of GDP growth. Arguably, developer activity on L1 says more about the coming economic expansion than trading or wallets.


32. Back in May, if you searched for "Ethereum" and "Solana" on Github, the former returned 65 times more repo results than the latter. By October, the multiple had shrunk to 17 -- a positive correlation with the rapid growth of the "Solana country".


观点:公链代币的最佳估值方式不应参照「公司」,而是参照「国家」定价


33. All this is not to say that the platform's own cash flow is unimportant.


This is important for the stability of L1 tokens.


It is no accident that the government becomes the monopoly issuer of currency. There were many folk currencies in history. But they never lasted long and were always rendered obsolete by government money.


Among many problems of folk money, the lack of "financial foundation" is one of the most serious.


36. The government can protect the value of its currency through taxation, which is the most stable and almost guaranteed income. Even if the fiat currency is "unbacked", the government can raise resources through taxation and use those resources to buy/sell its currency to defend its value.


This is a big deal, can bring confidence to the holder of the currency.


You can't say the same about non-government money, well... Until now.


With transaction fees programmed into each economic activity on the platform and used for token destruction or collateral rewards, currencies of "blockchain nations" are receiving financial support similar to government currencies.


39. As we've already discussed, while these cash flows do not determine the price of a token, they help keep the exchange rate stable in the long run.


40. But the most important thing for token prices is still the GDP growth of cryptocurrency "countries". Since the meta-universe is only in its primordial stage, the story has only just begun.


The original link



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit