Is it an obstacle or an opportunity for THE Development of NFT in the Context of Global Carbon Neutrality?
原文作者:梁文辉,白话区块链
Some time ago, an article titled "The End of NFT Art" attracted a lot of attention. It explained why NFT art is short, and also mentioned the dilemma of NFT artists: they are finding it increasingly difficult to make money from it.
Separately, French artist Joanie Mercier attacked the NFT auction process for producing very high carbon emissions (POW mechanism)...The market is full of bearish voices of NFT, in the context of global carbon neutrality, where will it go in the future?This article has done some carding to the relevant content.
There is no shortage of voices questioning whether NFT is "green". "Any SINGLE NFT is much more expensive than a normal Ethereum exchange because NFT is minted and exchanged many times on the blockchain." Memo Atken, a digital artist and engineer.
The New York Times criticized: "Creating an ordinary NFT would create a huge amount of carbon emissions, more than 200 kilograms of carbon, equivalent to the carbon footprint of an average American gasoline-powered car traveling 500 miles, and those emissions would cause global warming."

Carbon-fyi specifically calculates the Carbon footprint of blockchain: "The cumulative total power consumption of the Bitcoin network is more than 45.8TWh (terawatt hours), which is the annual output of 125 Daya Bay nuclear power plants and emits about 45.8 million tons of co2 per year, while ethereum is 9.62TWh, creating the annual output of about 26 Daya Bay nuclear power plants."
Basically, POW-based applications are big carbon emitters, and NFT is one of them. As of April 29, OpenSea had emitted 82.83 million kg of Carbon dioxide, equivalent to 20% of the total emissions of the Cayman Islands in 2016, according to carbon.fyi.
NFT is a huge resource drain. According to Ultrasound. Money, OpenSea burned 369 ETH in 24 hours. The main culprit is the POW consensus algorithm used by Ethereum networks because it consumes a lot of energy.
In fact, most NFT mining and exchange takes place on poW-based blockchains, which require a lot of energy and are not sustainable. In the long run, NFT, which has a lower fuel cost and a smaller carbon footprint, will surely prevail.
Optimisation on consensus is not the best approach, and uncertainty is a big reason: Ethereum has proposed switching to POS since 2018, and it is optimistically expected to switch this year or next.
Because the ecosystem is so large, ethereum's multi-phase games don't make it easy to switch consensus mechanisms. In fact, the most direct way to achieve green NFT is to use green electricity instead of high emission traditional electricity such as coal and thermal power.
In the European Union, for example, where nearly half of the electricity supply is from clean energy, nodes across the EU can undertake the main validation work of NFT in all aspects of the foundry and exchange process and have been able to significantly reduce emissions. Of course, this is difficult to implement due to the dispersal of nodes, which requires them to be organized in an orderly manner.
Green capital will help drive NFT projects to operate in a "low carbon" or even "zero carbon" manner.
Investment institutions or creditors have specific requirements for carbon emissions in all links, and carbon emissions should be limited in casting, issuance and auction. In addition, projects also need to fulfill disclosure obligations, provide traceable carbon footprint and regularly release carbon emission data.
In other words, in addition to financial performance, THE NFT project needs to meet green indicators, or it needs to accept capital withdrawal from investors or be regarded as default of debt.It will not be difficult to drive this process, as blockchain technology already has a broad impact in driving green investment.
Internationally, many organizations have been actively promoting the application of blockchain technology in the field of sustainable Finance. The Green Digital Finance Alliance predicts that 10% of global GDP will be stored in blockchain by 2025.

Source: Green Digital Finance Alliance
Ulrich, professor of Economics at University College London's Department of Sustainable Finance, has written the Scaling up Sustainable Investment through Blockchain-based Project Bonds, The paper discusses in detail the specific steps and ways to use blockchain technology to help sustainable investment to be implemented at large scale.
There is no doubt that zero-carbon NFT will be an irreversible trend.
Solution architect Cosimo Bassi has calculated that for each NFT cast on Algorand, only 0.0000004kg of co2 is produced. Algorand's carbon footprint is negligible compared to the 200kg produced by most blockchains.
The consensus algorithm used by Algorand is pure proof of equity (PPoS). Users become block verifiers by pledging ALGO. The system randomly and secretly selects the verifier for each phase, which achieves the same degree of decentralization as POW and ensures extremely high security.
"WAX chain has accumulated 211 tons of co2 offsets and plans to create a global market offering new carbon impact NFT digital collectibles." WAX reports.

The WAX protocol eliminates POW and uses WAX GUILDS, which verify exchanges and generate new blocks. Because of consensus mechanisms based entirely on pledging and voting, WAX chains consume 220,000 times less power than bitcoin and Ethereum.
On July 16 this year, China's carbon market officially launched online exchange. Before China, the United States was the first country to implement emission rights exchange. Although it did not form a system and scale like the European Union EST, some enterprises have already produced "amazing" benefits.
Tesla turned a profit for the first time in 2020, largely because it sold $1.58 billion in carbon credits to other car companies.
In this era of capital and digital convergence, we can boldly predict that the era of "carbon yuan" may be coming, and carbon emission index is expected to become the next generation of hard currency with global payment function. In this huge market, there are hidden opportunities for NFT.
First, the circulation of carbon credit NFT is limited, and carbon credit NFT is scarce and accelerates deflation year by year.
Under the broad framework of the Paris agreement, countries would have to set an annual cap on carbon emissions that would be allocated as credits to designated industries, and the credits would decrease each year. In the European Union, for example, emissions caps will be reduced by 2.2 percent a year from 2021, equivalent to 43 million tons of co2 a year.
In other words, there will be 43 million tonnes of carbon credits available on the open market, which will be a necessity for countries or companies that cannot fail to reduce emissions in the short term. The latest carbon index spot purchase price is about 54.11 euros (CFD), which means that the annual primary market turnover is about 2.3 billion euros. In addition, carbon quotas cannot be rolled over to the next year, creating a limited-supply market.
Secondly, carbon credit NFT is hard currency.There is ongoing demand because for a long time, specific industries and countries that have not yet industrialised can't reduce their emissions and therefore need to buy quotas, which is why Tesla is able to make such a huge profit by selling carbon credits.
In the future, carbon credits are likely to become an important asset class in corporate financial statements and be stored as NFT because blockchain-based NFT is immutable and traceable, making it ideal for managing and tracking carbon credit footprints.
It may only be a matter of time before carbon credits become globally convertible across borders,But there needs to be a better crypto asset infrastructure and more service providers that can connect demand and supply to demand.
The purchase and consumption of carbon emission credits need to be tracked. The blockchain-based NFT has the characteristics of traceability, which can effectively identify the identity of carbon indicators and record the flow direction of carbon indicators.
In fact, the application of block chain to label key information and realize dynamic tracking has been quite mature in China, such as The State Grid Qinghai Electric Power Company (Referred to as "State Grid Qinghai").
State Grid Qinghai cooperated with the Energy Storage Power Station project to deploy the integrated project of distributed power supply and energy storage transmission in Qinghai.
Taking advantage of the traceable and untampered characteristics of blockchain, State Grid Qinghai labels and records the quantity and price of each link in the distributed system, such as distribution, storage, distribution and use.
Each entity and electricity circulation is clear: users (residents or enterprises) choose electricity suppliers based on their budget and demand for electricity time through bidding. Each wind or photovoltaic company sells electricity through bidding auction.
The NFT market is widely regarded as promising, and its only pain point is high emissions. That is to say, NFT has to solve the emission problem in every link. As long as it reaches zero carbon, it has the condition of good investment target. There are two potential business opportunities:
Pure green electricity is used in each link of NFT circulation. Green electricity means that its carbon dioxide emissions are zero or close to zero in the process of generating electricity, and it has a lower impact on the environment than electricity produced by other means (such as thermal power generation).
The main sources of green electricity are solar energy, wind energy, water power, biomass energy, geothermal energy, nuclear power and so on.At present, NFT mainly uses local electricity, and the degree of carbon emissions depends on the local generation mix. For example, in European Union countries, nuclear and renewable energy are both 20%, and in China, about 60% are coal.
Because each platform and exchange of nodes is distributed, it is difficult to control electricity type, need professional services according to their electricity type on the market, on the one hand, artists can choose a more "green" way of casting and bidders, and on the other hand is advantageous to the statistics of NFT industry overall carbon emissions.
The purpose of this approach isThrough technical means, active absorption of carbon emission services, the carbon emission of NFT is absorbed and captured with compensationThat is, carbon sequestration is achieved by artificial means. Artists and platforms maintain the existing business model, but need to purchase third-party carbon absorption services.
If a piece of NFT art is cast and auctioned, the cumulative emission of 400kg carbon dioxide needs to purchase equivalent carbon absorption, to achieve the purpose of zero total carbon.
But it's a bit controversial, as freelance illustrator Bleached Rainbows pointed out on Twitter: it's the equivalent of setting fire to a house (releasing huge amounts of carbon) and then 'compensating' it by placing a potted plant next to the ruins.
However, this may not be feasible, as it would increase the exchange cost and circulation difficulty of NFT.
Transformation is the only way for the blockchain and crypto industry to mature.
In the context of global carbon neutrality, environmental protection has become a necessary issue for the development of various industries, but this just provides a good opportunity: on the one hand, it gives birth to new industry opportunities, and on the other hand, it allows the crypto industry to increase its influence by proving its value.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia