Finding undervalued assets through asset pricing models is perhaps a favourite activity of traditional financiers. When they see bitcoin, that non-cashflow junk, soaring in price and surpassing Berkshire Hathaway in market value, they say sourly: "This Ponzi scheme will soon be over."
Memes, narratives, speculation -- things that once didn't count as intrinsic value -- are slowly starting to feel like they might be. We can't put a price on emotions, feelings, and all those intangibles yet, so the imagination is infinite. Moon? That's all too close. In an era of increasingly pervasive investment, intangible factors will contribute more and more intrinsic value, which will be difficult to measure.
This paper is from EgirlCapital. The author analyzes the value deviation caused by memes from the constitutive dimension of intrinsic value. Translated by BlockBeats:
This article is inspired by CL'sThe latest article on memes.
In particular, the first part reveals that many models are memes in nature, even "revenue".
Wait, why are revenue and valuation memes? Are they all fundamental analysis?
So, what is the price/earnings ratio of something that is cheap? How much is too much? In every case? So who determines the different special cases? And who categorizes the different situations?
P/E is a meme. But why? Because when the p/E ratio is too high, there is no natural law forcing its price to fall, and when the p/E ratio is too low, there is no natural law forcing its price to rise.
Overvaluation or undervaluation is a classic example of a traditional financial meme that is shared by many investors and thus allows them to turn their belief in valuation into a self-fulfilling belief.
This is not to say that the meme has no logical support at all, but its outcome depends on participants' beliefs about the meme, not according to any laws of nature.
What other traditional financial memes can you think of? A lot, actually!
Here's a great example, which I'm sure you've heard before: Bitcoin doesn't generate cash flow, so it's worth nothing.
Have you fallen in love with traditional financial memes? Congratulations, you've been awarded the NGMI (Not Going to Make It) and HFSP(Have Fun Staying Poor) Honorary certification airdrop to add to your Linkedin name suffix!
-
In the post-Benjamin Graham era, the art of investing can be understood simply as finding assets whose intrinsic value is lower than the current market price, thereby achieving a "margin of safety." (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/intrinsicvalue.asp)
So when people look at the price of an asset, they wonder what makes it go up or down, and what makes it deviate from its intrinsic value.
If the price is above intrinsic value - avoid the asset.
If the price is below intrinsic value - explore this asset.
-
I think we can derive the following formula:

(Price = intrinsic value * deviation factor)
Intrinsic value in the formula refers to "a measure of the value of an asset", which is usually obtained by calculating the net realizable value of the asset, using cash flow discounting or other models.
And the deviation factors (including liquidity, market volatility, speculation factors, etc.) will have a positive or negative impact on intrinsic value. Finally, multiply the two together to get the market value of the asset.
-
The failure of this model, however, is that we can clearly see that there are many assets in the world with an intrinsic value of "0", so their price is still zero regardless of their deviation factor.
However, these asset prices are not actually zero.
Why is that?
A scam? Ponzi? Or do they actually have high intrinsic value to begin with?
I think the reason why traditional finance was so enthusiastic and quickly abandoned crypto is that they simply couldn't accept that the price of something with no intrinsic value never went to zero.
Why didn't dogecoin go to zero? Why are some NFTS worth so much?
To the brothers of traditional finance, this does not make any sense, it is completely absurd!
After analyzing the information through their existing cognitive models, they concluded that it must be a hoax.
Their brains say, "This thing has an intrinsic value of zero," and they find that this thing has a non-zero price?
Their brain: "ERROR 404." ", "This logic could not be found. Their brains explode.
-
This is the world of traditional finance.
But it's not the same.

Welcome to the world of clowns.
Governance tokens that have no value in this world are actually valuable, even if no one uses them to govern.
Jpegs are prized in this world because we love art (or maybe because we hate it).
Don't you love that Pollock's work looks like colorful Bukakke?
To you! Who cares what you think? Other people who have more money than you don't agree. The price is set by the buyer, not by outsiders with no stake in it.
The 69th knockoff of Crypto Punks, they wear various fast-food restaurant hats in a boring yacht club and are deployed on a chain of junk that you'd think would be worthless.
But you're wrong. Who cares what you think? Other people who have more money than you don't agree. The price is set by the buyer, not by outsiders with no stake in it.
The owners may not even "like" these NFTS, and they don't care about their scarcity, features, history, community, etc. In fact, the more ridiculous it is, the more valuable it may be. There's nothing like owning a JPEG stone to say, "Look at me, I'm not rich, I'm fucking rich!" At least for now, unless there's something more ridiculous than that.
The problem with all the traditional financial models in the "old world" is that they can't accept our pure guesswork, and they can't understand that we buy these "worthless" memes and sell them into billions (dogecoin, billions).
As long as the leeks can be washed and the leeks are still there, there will always be speculative opportunities.
We need a new model, one that can embrace this whole new clown world. We need something to explain why memes are valuable.
-
Therefore, I propose a simple modified version of the model that revises this old arcane traditional financial view of memes, hence what we call the price proposition of G:

(Price = intrinsic value * deviation factor + speculative premium or discount)
To put it more simply, we just added an "incomprehensible" component.

(Prices in the clown world = prices in the traditional financial world + speculative premium or discount)
Intrinsic value in the formula refers to "a measure of the value of an asset", which is usually obtained by calculating the net realizable value of the asset, using cash flow discounting or other models. This part may also be 0.
A speculative premium or discount is the positive or negative value that hype, attention, and other intangible factors bring to a clown, which may not be based on any source, but may represent all of its value in the clown world.
At this point, I'm sure many people would say that the price of the unique junk asset they own is not primarily due to a speculative premium, but to its own value.
If it can't be measured, is it still real?
Aesthetics, "community," "good leadership and a good track record," Haskell, rarity, etc.
So, what do we do? Make a list and add $100 million to the market value of each attribute?
It sounds ridiculous, right?
However, I am not here to tell you how to price non-intrinsic value, but to show that speculation does have some value and should not be ignored.
However, I do think that in the future, features that we currently classify as "speculative" will have a proprietary model for pricing them and factoring them into the intrinsic value of an asset.
This may explain the "post-mainnet sell off" phenomenon that plagues many projects delivered according to the roadmap. The imaginary space of the infinite future has now been compressed into a real, practical path. From now on, the valuation of a project is no longer supported by an infinite imagination, it now has only a fraction of what was once imagined.
You can't be overly optimistic about a project when you can measure the number of users and activity.
When you can't measure anything, the moon is not the upper limit of the project, it may fly beyond the edge of the universe.
-
So, are memes and NFT really worthless?
I'm pretty sure I can sell a million dogecoins in a minute.
I came into the industry from traditional finance a long time ago, but initially I had a hard time understanding the "worthless" meme culture.
However, I have now fully accepted the clown world we live in.
You can't change the wind or the world,
But you can adjust your sails, and maybe you can swim in the world of clowns.
Friends, I wish you a pleasant journey!

The original link

Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia