header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Nansen: Analyze the real market making of Uniswap V3 with over 20,000 addresses

Read this article in 8 Minutes
77% of the addresses were passive liquidity providers and 58% had only one liquidity position.

Title: The Market Making Landscape of Uniswap V3

By PNG Young Loon, Nansen Analyst
Jiang Haibo



Why are market makers important


Market-making in finance is not just the equation x*y=k. In the traditional central limit order book (CLOB) market, market makers specialize in submitting buyer and seller orders. When a user trades on the FTX, the counterparty may not be a directed trader, but a market maker! Most HFT firms, and even banks, allocate a portion of their portfolios to market-making activities. Well-known market makers include Two Sigma, Citadel and Jump Trading.


Market-makers are especially important in traditional markets, because directional traders alone do not provide sufficient liquidity for the market. There are several reasons for this:


· Information fragmentation exists. Buyers are unable to communicate effectively with sellers, especially when trading long-tail assets.


· Some market participants demand that trades be executed immediately, when in reality, trades take time to clear.


· Liquidity is affected asymmetrically by market sentiment, increasing in bull markets and drying up in bear markets. This can be seen in the dollar value of open interest in Derbit options.


· Large trades have a high slippage.


These problems mask price discovery and increase market volatility, often making markets less efficient. In DEFI, the lack of market makers to provide liquidity can explain why the price of newly issued tokens fluctuates wildly. That's why users should set smart alerts for large transfers based on how liquid their tokens are.


Why market making


Market makers in DEFI can benefit from trading fees and liquidity incentives. This is not too different from traditional market makers, who profit from bid-ask spreads (the difference between buy and sell orders).


Revenue also comes with risk, with DeFi users fearful of fickle losses and traditional market makers trying to reduce the risk of asset prices changing over time. Market-making has traditionally been a complex business, with institutions competing in a variety of ways. They constantly adjust spreads and buy and sell amounts, buy hedging instruments from the derivatives market and execute light-speed orders on low-latency software.


Because of this, it is difficult for individual traders to make a market in a central limit order book market. While there are procedures to help you do this, organizations have the advantage of scale in almost every respect.


Enter automated market making


Automated market makers turned the old market making model on its head by introducing the concept of lazy market making. The assets in DEFI would be held in contracts known as a "liquidity pool" through which a variety of traders could trade. This is "automated" because asset prices in the AMM change based on predefined mathematical formulas. One of these formulas is the constant product formula of Uniswap x*y=k, where x and y represent the amount of the two tokens in the pool, and the multiplication of the two tokens must always equal the constant k. This article provides a good introduction to AMMS.


Over the years, other AMM formulas have been developed, each with its own price curve. They all have one characteristic in common: market-making is automated and possibly easy.


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


Enter the Uniswap V3


Uniswap V3 offers significant improvements to the AMM model. It increases customizable liquidity positions by allowing users to pool assets within a preset price range. Users can treat a single V3 liquidity position as an AMM of x*y=k, but only within a set price range. Citing Dan Robinson's work, the relationship between assets in a single V3 position can also be expressed by the following formula:


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


The "offset" here refers to the function that sets the lower and upper end of the price range in V3. As mentioned in the previous article, this greatly improves the funding efficiency of assets in the liquidity pool, enabling users to customize their overall market-making positions by holding different liquidity positions simultaneously.


However, the increase in capital efficiency comes at a cost. Users may be exposed to the risk that the market price of the market-making asset exceeds the set market-making range. For example, the user provides liquidity for the ETH/USDC trading pair in the $1000-2500 price range, and ends up holding only ETH when the ETH price falls below $1000. When the price of ETH exceeds $2,500, users end up holding only USDC. In both cases, the user's assets are no longer earning fees, and the single asset held may be exposed to downside risk.


This is the difficulty of market making on Uniswap V3. Providing liquidity is no longer simple and passive, but requires timely monitoring and strategic adjustment. In this article, we use on-chain analysis to discover the reality of market making on Uniswap V3.


methods


Each Uniswap V3 position was represented by a unique NFT, and we analyzed data for five different events related to liquid position management.


By NonfungiblePositionManager. Increase liquidity from the sol (Increasepquidity), reduced liquidity (Decreasepquidity) and Transfer (Transfer) events


Uniswapv3pool. sol issues Mint and Burn events


By combining the data from these events, we were able to find out how often specific liquidity positions (such as NFT) were updated. Through the Transfer event, we were able to determine the ultimate owner of the NFT position. If the ultimate owner is the destruction address, the penultimate owner is considered the owner of the NFT position.


Assuming that NFTs that move from one Ethereum address to another end up belonging to the same owner, since there is no open market to buy and sell Uniswap V3 NFT positions, there is no reason for users to buy NFTs directly instead of buying the corresponding underlying asset themselves and providing liquidity.


If Uniswap V3 liquidity providers are actively managing liquidity, they may change their liquidity positions frequently, either through off-chain algorithms or on-chain contracts. We conducted a brief tentative analysis to understand how liquidity providers use Uniswap V3.


Of all users currently holding Uniswap V3 positions, 58% of addresses have only one liquidity position and less than 10% have more than five NFT positions.


By summing up the number of "increase liquidity" and "decrease liquidity" events that occur at a particular address, you can get the number of activities at that address, which includes the activity of the NFT that has been destroyed at that address. We plot the following scatter plot for the number of positions held and the number of activities at each address.


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


Trends show that the number of activities at an address consistently exceeds the number of positions it has. Few addresses have more than 150 NFT positions. We can also infer that the increase in the number of activities is proportionately greater than the increase in the number of positions held.


Let's categorize the data and add different colors, as shown below.


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


"Simple Passive" means that an address has only one Uniswap V3 position and no changes have been made to it. It represents, in all senses of the word, a "lazy" liquidity provider. "Complex Active" refers to liquidity providers having multiple positions and actively managing them. If the number of activities is greater than the number of positions held, this can be inferred, using 2 as the threshold for activity.


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


We found that a total of 22,864 addresses had or had a position on Uniswap V3, and a large proportion (77%) of these addresses were considered "passive liquidity providers", meaning that they almost never changed their liquidity positions after casting the NFT. Fourteen per cent of the addresses were classified as "Simple Active" and less than one per cent as "complex Active".


There are only 8 "complex passive" liquidity providers, most of which we presume are pledge pools for certain projects, such as RAINI's V3 liquidity provider pledge pool, but 6 of the 8 addresses are actually wallet addresses (not contract addresses).


Historical patterns of liquidity supply


By tracking the amount of historical coins minted and destroyed on a daily basis, historical liquidity supply patterns can be observed from May to June 28. Some tentative observations can be made, but further testing is needed to verify this.


A sudden "surge" in liquidity at a given price can cause a change in the relative ETH price the next day.


Since the middle of June, the overall liquidity depth generally declined.


How does the liquidity in the ETH/USDC pool follow the price of Ethereum? Compare the ETH price corresponding to 25%, 50% and 75% liquidity with the ETH/USD price. As shown in the chart below, it can be inferred that liquidity is usually concentrated in these ranges.


Nansen:透过两万多个地址分析 Uniswap V3 真实做市情况


In May, the liquidity distribution on V3 varies closely with ETH prices. That makes sense, since market makers can reposition to earn more fees. However, V3 liquidity has not kept pace with the fall in Ethereum prices since mid-June. As ETH prices fell below $2,000, liquidity providers on Uniswap widened their market-making range and the price gap between 25 per cent and 75 per cent liquidity widened. Will this trend continue? Only time and data will tell.


conclusion


Active liquidity management is still in its infancy at DEFI and Visor Finance's current strategy is to derive a Bollinger band from the ETH/USD price to create the expected range of active liquidity. Charm Finance runs a passive rebalancing strategy to ensure that the pool of liquidity "catches up" with market prices.


As the data shows, the potential of Uniswap V3 is untapped. Passive, simple liquid positions still dominate, with most of them managed in an arbitrary, unoptimised manner. This is a great opportunity for the new protocol to build an automated on-chain strategy that helps users proactively manage liquid assets and democratize market making for everyday DEFI users. Their success is inextricably linked to Uniswap's success itself.


The original link



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit