On-chain protocols, like traditional companies, are faced with difficulties in the early stage of development. A steady flow of cash is the key to the sustainability of any system, but a reserve asset is the key to its better survival before it matures. Of course, a protocol built on top of a system differs from a traditional company in that the fixed operating costs of the protocol are negligible if iterative updates are not taken into account.
This article, from Blockchain Capital, elaborates on a protocol vault business model and strategy to make protocols sustainable.
This guide and recommendations address the various tools that can be used to manage the balance sheet and vault of the DEFI protocol DAO.
Although this article is a heavily abridged version, it contains many of the key elements of the report, and a more detailed assessment of the tools available and their risks can be found atIn the full reportLook at it.
The purpose of any protocol DAO is to persistently manage and govern that protocol. Therefore, the DAO of the protocol needs to be capitalized to ensure that it can not only operate sustainably, but can continue to invest in its future growth -- not unlike the way traditional companies think about their own capitalization. Just as traditional companies use retained earnings, equity, and debt to fund themselves, the DAO of the protocol has a similar option:
- Retained earnings from the Agreement and non-operating income from the assets in the Treasury of the Agreement
-Sell the original asset of the agreement in exchange for stablecoin /ETH/BTC
- Borrowing debt
As you can see in the figure below, many DEFI DAOs hold almost all of their vault assets in their native tokens. Since the cost of operating the protocol is denominated in dollars/fiat, a bear market could force the DAO to sell its native token at a very low "fire sale" price to keep it in business. Therefore, the DAO of the agreement should have a variety of ways to generate revenue cash flow (that is, agreement income and investment income) to support its operating expenses; But since the Vault needs to have an asset base to generate revenue/non-operating income, the DAO should consider selling tokens or issuing debt to acquire this asset base.

Figure 1. Data dated June 11, 2021
DAO has two ways to generate retained earnings: agreement revenue and non-operating revenue (return on investment).
While many DEFI projects now understand the importance of value accumulation as part of the token economy, not all DAOs retain the fees/revenue generated by the protocol. For example, AOVE, Yearn, BadgerDAO, and Index Coop all keep protocol revenue in their DAOs' vaults, but Sushi, Compound, Uniswap, and Maker currently do not. Like any high-growth company (indeed any company since the Age of Discovery), it makes no sense to pay a "dividend" to shareholders when the return on investment in the core business exceeds the cost of capital. In addition, DAOs should also carefully consider the composition of their revenue: AVE and Yearn derive most of their revenue from the stablecoin, while Index Coop derives most of their revenue from their high-risk products (such as DPI and ETH/BTC leveraged "ETFs"). Therefore, DAOs should retain at least a portion of the protocol revenue and carefully consider the composition of that revenue.
Especially when you consider the size of many DAOs' coffers, it is likely that a significant portion of some DAOs' revenue will come from non-operational income/ROI (at least until the protocol matures). Just as traditional companies invest in assets with varying levels of risk (from risk-free Treasurys and highly rated bonds to risky M&A and venture capital), DAO can look at similar asset classes on the different chains and diversify the balance sheet of the vault into:

See the full report for more details
Currently, even some head agreements do not generate enough revenue to cover the operating expenses of the agreement (auditing, salaries/payments to contributors, marketing, etc.).Yearn, for example, is loss-making even when non-operating income, such as liquid mining, is booked. As a result, the retention of agreement revenues alone may not be sufficient to fund the operation of the agreements (at least until these agreements mature). This means that the DAO may need to raise additional capital to obtain sufficient large asset base, to generate returns, it also offers from how much Treasury assets should be the guidance opinion: assume that under the condition of reasonable and low risk of return on investment, we can launch the non-native assets as investment principal dimension. Once DAOs have established a position in their reserve assets, they can evaluate a variety of investment vehicles based on their risk preferences and determine asset allocation strategies to minimize asset correlation and different dimensions of risk.
Token sales are the best way to diversify balance sheets and build a position in reserve assets. But DAOs only have a few ways to sell tokens:
- Selling at market prices in the open market; But that could be very bad for the price of tokens.
-Conduct OTC sales to investors with the same strategy (negotiate corresponding discounts, lock up periods, etc.); However, the terms of the final sale of such a deal could raise eyebrows among other holders, and it would be difficult to identify strategic investors who could become long-term partners for the DAO.
- Auction (can whitelist a group of buyers and lock up positions, or use the KPI option model); However, the auction mechanism needs to be carefully designed, but if the mechanism is too complex, it may be detrimental to the promotion of the auction.
- financial engineering (e.g., buying covered call options, limiting float, holding short futures/forwards/perpetual positions); However, these options still end up influencing the price of the token at some point, and usually the more "exotic" the strategy is the more expensive it will be to pay the OTC (at least until the Defi derivatives track really matures).
Therefore, DAOs should carefully evaluate their specific requirements to determine which solution is best for them. For example, a DAO may ultimately decide to use a combination of 2 and 3 to introduce a group of investors who will add value to the protocol while incentivizing existing holders.
As with traditional finance, leverage is an alternative and potentially a less costly form of financing than diluted token sales. Therefore, for DAOs whose cash flows from their vaults are solvent, borrowing can be seen as an alternative financing option for token sales.
Currently, loans in DEFI can only be over-collateralized. However, most DAOs use Compound/ AVE /Maker directly to take debt positions -- even though DAOs' native tokens can be found on platforms like Cream or Unit Protocol. The token's borrowing capacity/debt ceiling may also not be able to meet the DAO's funding needs. As a result, most DAOs wishing to borrow can only do so by issuing bonds (zero-coupon, over-collateralised; For example,UMA yield - dollars) or convertible bonds (e.gThe Range of UMA Tokens), which is then auctioned and converted into a ready-made stablecoin.
Although there are unsecured lending options available (e.g., Cream's Iron Bank), this is not an option for most DEFI protocols. Even for those few qualified borrowers of Cream's Iron Bank who are approved,These loans also have credit lines and are intended only for short-term liquidity mining and not for DAO's long-term operations/capex.While there is nothing to prevent an agreement to issue unsecured bonds and auction them, with the promise of airdropping interest to bondholders, such free-for-all credit is unlikely to become the norm. For example, while a Tradfi creditor can initiate a foreclosure proceeding against a debtor company, as provided for in the U.S. 7/11 bankruptcy act, there is nothing in the DEFI agreement to do that. So unless there is a robust on-chain "insolvency" process, or a formal set of measures to protect the interests of creditors, the DAO may not be able to do partial secured/unsecured lending.
Given that DEFI's DAO requires permanent support for its protocols, managing its balance sheet in terms of revenue/expenses is a critical task. The DAOs of most protocols currently only hold their native tokens on their balance sheets. Given the volatility of cryptocurrencies, this could mean that DAOs need to be forced to sell their native tokens (at an inappropriate price) during a bear market to keep their operations going. Therefore, DAOs should first ensure that they have a cash flow of income based on reserve assets, and if the income is not sufficient to cover operating expenses, DAOs should consider raising additional reserve assets through token sales/debt. Doing so will provide the DAO of the agreement with a substantial base of reserve assets on its balance sheet to ensure sufficient additional non-operating income and investment returns to serve as a "buffer" in extreme cases. Following this playbook, any DAO will be in better financial shape and able to keep its agreements afloat even during a multi-year bear market.
The original link

Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia