header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Can I burn my Picasso painting and make NFT?

Read this article in 10 Minutes
If there is any special value in burning the work to make NFT, is it probably easier to take with you when you escape the earth
Author: 0x13, rhythmic BlockBeats


In one of the debates on the topic of "Strange Talk", Li Dan once said, "More beautiful than Mona Lisa, Mona Lisa is burning."

 

Li Dan's words were acting lines on the stage, no one took them seriously, but in the NFT field, the action of burning painting seems to have really become a kind of popular.

 

From abroad to domestic market reaction from acceptance to rejection, until April fool's day was JUST founded Sun Yuchen NFT fund in London Christie's evening sale of art in the 20th century to the price of $20 million take Picasso's "wear necklace lie down naked women", everyone started to doubt: Sun Yu briefings will not burn the Picasso's paintings?

 

Reborn from destruction. That's Banksy.

 

On October 5, 2018, a mysterious man pressed the remote control in his hand with a crisp hammering sound at Sotheby's.

 

Behind them hung on the wall, "Girl With Balloon," a painting by Banksy, a famous street artist, trickling out of its frame, shredded into strips of paper. The painting, which was voted "Britain's favourite work of art" a year ago, went to ruin in the blink of an eye. The audience was stunned, the auctioneer was at a loss on the stage, and the bidders all lowered their heads and covered their foreheads. Sotheby's staff hurriedly carried the "damaged" artwork away from the scene of the accident.

 

"I was taken aback at first, but then I realized I wasn't just buying a work, I was buying art history." The woman, who did not want to be named, eventually paid more than a million pounds for an unprecedented piece of art history that is more valuable than owning a single work. The work was destroyed at auction, but another piece of art was created at the same time. The half-cut piece was put on display at Sotheby's, where thousands of people queued in the rain to see the first artwork ever created in the middle of an auction.

 

 

 

Sotheby's did not know about the shredder hidden in the frame. Banksy told Sotheby's that the frame was part of the work and that Sotheby's did not remove it for inspection. This is not the first time Banksy has publicly mocked a traditional auction house.

 

In 2006, Banksy created a 500-piece painting called "Morons," which depicts an auction in which the work being sold is a painting that simply says, "I can't believe you idiot bought this fucking thing."

 

 

On March 4, 2021, in Brooklyn, New York, the painting burned quietly as the flames raged across the board for four minutes and 39 seconds, until the last charred piece fell to the empty ground and the board became empty.

 

A few minutes earlier, a young man wearing a black mask had set the painting alight from the lower left corner, and he was wearing a black hoodie with the "Balloon Girl" printed on it.

 

He comes from a group called Burnout Banksy, which proclaims in their Twitter profile that they are "on a mission to connect the world's physical art with NFT." They burned Banksy's "Idiot" and cast an NFT version, which sold at OpenSea for 288.69ETH, or about $380,000.

 

Banksy's fans and friends in the crypto art community have expressed their appreciation. Burning a physical work and making it into the NFT is "Banksy", they argue, and by burning the physical work, the value of the physical work will be transferred to the NFT, which is also an "unprecedented" social experiment, and apparently a great success.

 

Another asked: "After NFT, will this painting still be 'Idiot'? Why is this one selling for nearly four times the price of the physical copy of 'Idiot' when the actual copy is sold for less than $100,000?"

 

In the same way that "Balloon Girl" became "another work of art" at Sotheby's, "The Idiot" became "another work of art" at the same time that it burned on a vacant lot in Brooklyn.

 

 

A domestic imitation show


On March 25, 2021, more than 20 people were chatting and laughing under the big electronic screen in Yue Art Museum, Beijing. Three of them went to the front of the stage, unrolled a scroll of Chinese painting, and set it on fire with a cigarette lighter. The beautiful piece of art twisted and charred as the flames ate away, eventually falling into a plastic bucket on the floor. This work is the work of Leng Jun, a contemporary Chinese hyperrealism painter. After it was fully burned, it was made into NFT, and finally sold for 400,000 RMB in Opensea.

 

 

 

After the event, many crypto art community to the matter has reacted with abuse.

 

Community discussion of domestic imitation

 

To many in the community, the so-called exhibition appears to be a parody of the Burnt Banksy, which has received at least mixed reviews from the traditional and crypto art worlds, and the burn has received surprisingly uniform negative reviews.

 

Back to the beginning of the article, on April 1, 2021, the Just NFT Fund founded by Sun Yuchen bought Picasso's famous work Lying Nude with a Necacle at Christie's 20th Century Art Evening Auction in London with a price of 20 million US dollars. Meanwhile, the Just NFT fund won three self-portraits by American artist Andy Warhol for $2 million.

 

 

Once the matter was reported, it caused a great response, the originally quiet community suddenly lively up.

 

Community discussion on Sun Yuchen's auction of Picasso masterpieces

 

People seem to be used to seeing Sun Yuchen's various hyping methods, so the "potential" burning of the Picasso art is discussed in a tongue-in-cheek manner, without anger, without righteous indignation, of course, the reason may be "not burned".

 

Which brings us back to the controversial question:

 

If someone burned a Picasso painting and made NFT, how would you feel about it?

 

To solve this problem, Routine BlockBeats specifically contacted NFT collector Yin Cao, ArtGee founder Feliciache, digital art new media CyberFunkz, and technology art curator Dora.

 

"It's a very disrespectful thing to do with the author. It's an act of grandstanding." Cao Yin, a NFT collector, just finished a live broadcast about NFT popularization. While walking quickly in the street, he sent a WeChat voice message of 15 pieces of tens of seconds. "It is very important that if you burn a masterpiece like Picasso without the permission of the artist, it is actually an insult to the artist."

 

Since art has spread around the world, people have paid more attention to the choice of "artistic medium". Oil painting takes oil color and canvas as the artistic medium, Chinese painting takes ink and rice paper as the artistic medium, music takes sound, rhythm and melody as the artistic medium, and dance takes human movement as the artistic medium... Different art categories will adopt different medium, different art categories are more suitable for artistic media, artists and art media is communication link with the viewer and Bridges, so for the artist, familiar with different artistic medium, choose the most suitable art media from such as shape artistic image and link up with the audience, is a minimum requirement.

 

In tech-based art curator Dora's eyes, Picasso is precious is not just because of the work, in her view, art has already enjoys a good reputation in the secular point of view, is enjoying a high reputation, is often because of precipitated creator, time, art critics, curators, collectors (including individual and venue), the viewer for its contribution to the additional value, such as "the value by repetition is scarce and precious."

 

Feliciache, the founder of ArtGee, said: "Traditional art has a very important characteristic, which is the appreciation and practicability in real physics." And is famous for its innovative ideas and sharp digital art new media Cyberfunkz have also expressed the same view, although the NFT is true, the traceability and can be found on the advantage of easy transfer partial reason, but for art appreciation such perceptual thing, it is not enough: "from the Angle of art appreciation of the user experience, painting must be real. Because oil paints in the real light will present different light and stereo degree. Not to mention, there are too many works of art is an artist to the innovation of different material combination, may be ceramic, wood, cardboard, cloth and so on."

 

From this perspective, NFT is not a "panacea" for all art categories. On the contrary, it has great limitations.

 

To burn or not to burn, that is the question

 

Why can Banksy's work be burned to make NFT? This has a lot to do with Banksy's personal style. Class was more similar to a replicable, print, use make good template in advance coating will work out in the street, and of the west of irony, rebellious spirit, value proposition and block chain natural fit, so although there are a lot of people for the burning of the west of opposition, but his work to make NFT can get people's identity, Cao Yin compared it to "use western classical Musical Instruments to play jazz", the culture, the value proposition of both.

 

And burned LengJun super realism works, or Picasso's cubist works, from the medium of rice paper, canvas and so on all transferred to the medium of NFT, according to Cao Yin words "Musical Instruments playing jazz with people", although also has the very good adaptation, but, after all, only a few more were lost the jazz's original taste.

 

CyberFunkz describes Banksy as a "social activist" whose work is not only about "appreciation", so his work is not limited by form, material or medium, and his message, such as anti-war, equal rights, anti-capitalism, etc., is the essence of his work. This is why the burning of Banksy's paintings does not affect the artistic expression and value of his works, while the burning of Leng Jun's works makes people feel more like a monkey's eye.

 

Which works of art are more suitable to choose NFT as the artistic medium?

 

"I basically don't collect physical works and NFT works that exist at the same time." As one of the earliest collectors of the famous cryptographic artist Fewocious, Cao Yin's unique vision also makes her views more powerful. He believes that the best NFT work should be digital native. Without NFT, the work would not be available to the public. Just as ink on canvas does not produce the effect of Chinese painting, works that live on the screen when printed will also lose their soul. Felicache also said that the traditional physical art of precious on the chain is not meaningful, nor has it been proved to be necessary, "on the chain is just a certificate using the blockchain technology."

 

CyberFunkz points to Cubist artist Gabe Weis, who has entered the crypto art world and matched NFT to physical art. CyberFunkz, on the other hand, believes that in offline exhibitions, collectors can show their physical works, while online collectors can show their NFT works. There is no need for binary opposition or either/or between the parallel universes of the real world and Metaverse.

 

"Man-made burning, destruction is the most undesirable." Feliciache stressed that "one should think about how to better create value, rather than thinking about destroying it." It is true that the value of art is not only a particular pattern, but artists choose art medium, artistic expression, value, the design of some representational multiple aspects, such as mutual integration into the value of art itself, if it is in pursuit of an emerging technology or just a hype, art along with the value of his complete all burned, is really a pyrrhic victory.

 

Also, Dora to rhythm said, in her opinion, NFT is to create digital scarcity, promoting capitalization, establishing the efficient way that the ownership of digital objects, "for digital assets or digital art/collection, have NFT version is more valuable, but the digital assets or digital art/collection, whether you need NFT version, sincere to discuss."

 

"What we need to discuss is not which art forms should be made in the NFT, but which artists bring refreshing ideas and techniques to us in the context of NFT art." CyberFunkz said that Monet, Picasso and Andy Warhol have made tremendous contributions to the breakthrough and development of art in their own times, so in the era of NFT, why do we imitate the predecessors and force NFT attributes into their works? We are waiting for the birth of the artists of our time.

 

"If there's any special value in burning it for NFT," CyberFunkz said with a laugh, "maybe it's easier to take with you when you escape Earth!"



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit