The Real Motivation for Corporate America to Buy Bitcoin
Source: FT Chinese
Bitcoin's $1 trillion milestone on February 19 was driven by two factors: Canada's launch of North America's first bitcoin exchange-traded fund ETF on February 18; The second was MicroStrategy's second use of convertible bonds in three months to add to its bitcoin holdings.
In the Clubhouse, a new favorite of social media, there are special events where people are encouraged to "flash buy" bitcoin to celebrate its continued soaring price.
The Purpose Bitcoin ETF amassed $421.8 million in assets under management in two days, and Bloomberg expects it could reach $1 billion within a week. Another Evolve Bitcoin ETF opened today with a market capitalization of about $14.5 million.
In early February, Tesla disclosed in a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission that it had purchased $1.5 billion worth of bitcoin. As of the fourth quarter of 2020, this amountinvestmentThat's about 7.7% of Tesla's $19.384 billion cash holdings. Tesla also said it would accept bitcoin as payment for its products in the futurecurrencyBut industry insiders say it is currently difficult to use bitcoin as a medium of exchange due to its wide price fluctuations.
While Tesla's bitcoin investment has made a splash, MicroStrategy is the only public company actively borrowing to buy more bitcoin. Chairman and CEO Mike Thaler tweeted in 2013, "The death of Bitcoin is imminent. It seems only a matter of time before we suffer the same fate as online gambling." Yet he is now one of corporate America's most fervent Bitcoin evangelists, including nudging Tesla CEO Elon Musk into Twitter conversations.
Inflows into bitcoin and other crypto investment products reached $1.3 billion through January 2021, according to asset manager CoinShares. But I think the story of Bitcoin is now dominated by a store of value rather than a medium of exchange for money.
Why has the Bitcoin narrative changed? In addition tofinancialIn addition to services as asset allocation or offering financial products, more importantly, there is a wave of U.S. companies that are considering restructuring their balance sheets by buying bitcoin and cryptocurrencies. What anxiety and risk does this create for the capital markets?
To encourage other companies to follow MicroStrategy's lead, MicroStrategy hosted a two-day Corporate Investment Cryptocurrency Summit in early February, where it offered a list of guidelines for teaching how to fight. The summit attracted industry players from at least 16 countries and representatives of more than 1,400 companies.
Mr Thaler likens Bitcoin to a "masterful piece of monetary engineering", a system with "monetary energy" that can prevent "energy leaks" from inflation. He even publicly announced his personal holdings of 17,732 bitcoins, currently worth more than $1 billion.
As of February 2, MicroStrategy had nearly 72,000 Bitcoins, making it the leading Bitcoin holder in corporate America and worth more than its core business. In early February, MicroStrategy had planned to issue a $600 million convertible bond to buy bitcoin with net proceeds. The offering was expanded to $900 million, with an option to increase by $150 million, as investors snapped up the offering. It fully met its $1.05 billion fundraising requirements when it closed on Feb. 19.
MicroStrategy started using corporate cash to buy cryptocurrencies last summer, announced in August that it would invest 85% of its cash reserves in bitcoin, and then in December issued its first $650 million convertible bond to buy bitcoin, prompting Citibank to immediately downgrade MicroStrategy to a "sell" recommendation. However, since the initial purchase was announced on August 11, the price of Bitcoin has increased fivefold and MicroStrategy's stock price has soared more than 700%, clearly bullish on MicroStrategy's bitcoin strategy.
Microstrategy's bitcoin narrative is that the U.S. government is printing a lot of money, making it very risky to hold cash. Led by the Fed and bolstered by other central banks, global QE asset purchases will reach a staggering $6 trillion in 2020 alone, accounting for more than half of the global QE cumulative value from 2009 to 2018. In the US, M2 money supply has risen by more than 25 per cent in the past 12 months.
In response to the new pandemic, the Fed expanded its balance sheet by more than 75% ($3.25tn); Since the end of fiscal 2019, the U.S. Treasury has accumulated $3.7 trillion in debt, while the European Central Bank has added more than 2 trillion euros. Such a massive expansion of financial assets has led many to question the long-term value of fiat currencies and look for alternative assets such as commodities and cryptocurrencies to hedge against inflation.
Mr Thaler reckons that macroeconomic headwinds will affect $400 trillion of capital trapped in depreciating fiat currencies. He also argues that inflation depends on the goods to be bought, not the consumer price index, and that, for example, high tech stock prices mean less purchasing power for cash, with a real return on cash of -30% in 2020.
Thaler thinks the Fed is printing a lot of moneypolicyThe seeds of hyperinflation have been sown, so that cash held on corporate balance sheets in fiat currencies such as euros and dollars will lose about 15 per cent of their purchasing power each year. Since every CEO's most important job is capital allocation, the most important decision every CEO will have to make over the next 10 years will be whether and how to adopt bitcoin, since cash has become a liability.
Mr Thaler argues that in a world of massive money printing, every company has to choose between two options: or it has to reduce capital, which is like self-destruction... Or you have to switch to an asset that is appreciating faster than the money supply is expanding, which is bitcoin.
According to Thaler, the dollar will not remain the world's reserve currency. He also sees bonds, stocks and real estate as placeholders for fiat money, whose returns will become increasingly diluted as long as the underlying fiat currency continues to depreciate. The solution: convert them all into bitcoin.
"Every company on the planet can do that because every company has a certain amount of reserve assets."
The aggressive bitcoin strategy includes: "If you want to maximize shareholder value and want to retain or create shareholder wealth, then companies can develop a bitcoin balance sheet strategy and a Bitcoin-driven income statement strategy." Companies can start by developing Bitcoin tools, building Bitcoin software, and Bitcoin services that provide Bitcoin infrastructure, because Thaler believes "all of that drives revenue growth and drives cash flow."
In an interview with Bloomberg on February 18, Musk explained why Tesla is buying bitcoin and not Dogecoin, the crypto-currency he has fired up with a joke: "Having some bitcoin, which is just a little less stupid liquidity than cash, is risky enough for an S&P 500 company."
Musk also tweeted: "Only a fool wouldn't look away when fiat money has a negative impact on real interest rates... Bitcoin is almost as shitty as fiat money. The key word is almost."
For many institutional investors, buying microstrategy convertible bonds amounts to "almost free bitcoin bullishoptions".
MicroStrategy's convertible bond issued at the end of last year paid 0.75 per cent, and its reissued in February paid 0 per cent, reflecting the fact that some or all of the following may have happened between issues:
(a) Credit spreads have improved
(b) A reduction in the risk-free rate
(c) A change in premium or an increase in volatility assumptions
(d) Market conditions have improved
The latest Convertible Notes will mature on February 15, 2027, at an initial conversion rate of 0.6981 Microstrategy Class A common shares for every $1,000 principal of the notes, equivalent to an initial conversion price of approximately $1,432.46. This represents A 50% premium over the closing price of MicroStrategy Class A common shares of $932.72 on February 19. The conversion rate will be adjusted according to the terms of the bonds.
As with typical U.S. convertible bonds, they are not allowed to convert into stock until near maturity unless certain circumstances occur, such as a corporate merger or a market failure. Virtually no investor will convert before maturity, and in a normal market, the convertible bond will always trade at a price higher than the shares it can convert into, so anyone who wants to convert is really just selling the convertible bond.
Debt for equity is an investor's choice, and microstrategies can choose to deliver equity, cash equivalent to equity, or a mix of both.
For convertible bond investors, if the microstrategy stock underperforms, they can at least get their principal back, but they also have room to rise above the conversion price, and they can make money on volatility by trading options. If a microstrategy owns a lot of bitcoins, or if its "performance" is closely tied to its success, it could be considered a call option on bitcoin, but this "call option" is not really "free," since bondholders would have paid higher interest if they had bought non-convertible bonds.
The appeal of convertible bonds, however, is clearly the opportunity for investors to participate in a microstrategy share price appreciation that may be due to bitcoin's rise -- a bitcoin narrative that is bullish on microstrategies.
Katherine Wood, who heads Ark Investment Management, said on Feb. 17 that if every company in the U.S. invested 10% of their cash in Bitcoin, that single move alone would add $200,000 to the value of the currency.
BCB Group, a digital financial services company, announced on February 19 that it will launch a reserve fund management service to help businesses buy and manage cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin.
Right now, the stock price of Microstrategy is clearly the biggest beneficiary of leveraged bitcoin purchases. But even Mr. Wood, a strong bitcoin supporter, has repeatedly publicly questioned whether MicroStrategy is a tech company or a bitcoin ETF.
Before microstrategies, it was unusual for companies to take risks with corporate cash, as most companies wouldsecurityFirst and second are liquidity and yield.
Shareholders for the company to carry out the business risks usually have a greater tolerance, but to the risk of investment cash for a relatively small, if the currency again experience similar between December 2017 and December 2018, down from about $20000 to $3000, the damage may lead to collapse, tesla and micro strategy of balance sheet cannot achieve expected, resulting in the company's earnings estimate capital markets will be how to deal with?
But Mr Thaler says: "The choice between volatile assets, which can jump 200 per cent, and cash, which has lost value, is simple." Because "the essence of a free market is that capital flows from the weakest assets to the strongest".
Wall Street analysts believe it would be a red flag for investors if a company bought financial assets for speculative purposes unrelated to its core business. A high-risk, high-return strategy like microstrategy could mean that if bitcoin underperforms, there won't be enough capital to meet its working capital needs.
Nor is bitcoin's price volatility the only risk. While institutional investors use custody services to reduce these dangers, bitcoin is also vulnerable to hacking, fraud and password loss. Some industries, such as financial services and utilities, may find it more difficult to add bitcoin to their balance sheets based on contractual requirements.
Other investors worry that investing in energy-hungry bitcoin betrays Tesla's core corporate value of reducing carbon emissions, since energy consumption runs counter to Tesla's mission to "accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy." According to research from Cambridge Business School, the total electricity used to mine bitcoin each year is greater than that used in Argentina and almost more than that used in Norway.
But supporters COINS ano confirm for funds, the banking system use about 2.4 billion joules, gold mining industry to use 500 million joules, and COINS use only a small part of the two, each year 184 million joules, and estimates that renewable energy accounted for 77.6% of the currency total mining power consumption, so the currency mining "negligible" effect on the environment.
MicroStrategies apparently doesn't mind being seen as "half" a Bitcoin ETF. In its most recent annual report, it noted that there are two strategies in operating its business: one is to grow its enterprise analytics software business, and the other is to acquire and hold bitcoin.
When MicroStrategy's cash, cash equivalents and short-term investments exceed its current working capital needs, it will pursue a business strategy of acquiring Bitcoins and may from time to time purchase Bitcoins with the proceeds through the issuance of debt or equity, depending on market conditions.
MicroStrategy believes that its Bitcoin strategy complements its analytics software and services business, and that activities related to Bitcoin and supporting the Bitcoin network can raise awareness of the MicroStrategy brand and can provide the company with opportunity products to attract new customers.
MicroStrategy is also exploring opportunities to apply Bitcoin-related technologies, such as blockchain analytics, to software products. So while U.S. companies may be buying bitcoin to better manage their balance sheets and keep their cash from falling in value, bitcoin's windfall profits could drive more savvy companies to use cryptocurrency investments to polish their income statements. Bitcoin's price breached the $55,000 level on February 19, meaning that Tesla's paper profit since January is about $930 million, which is nearly 30% higher than the $721 million in electric car profits it will make for all of 2020.
However, in its annual report, MicroStrategy also pointed out that its aggressive Bitcoin strategy has exposed the company to various risks related to Bitcoin, including: Bitcoin price fluctuations may be subject to highly uncertain regulation; Historical financial statements do not reflect potential fluctuations in earnings related to Bitcoin holdings that may be encountered in the future; Bitcoin holdings could be subject to regulatory scrutiny; The concentration of bitcoin holdings increases the risks inherent in the bitcoin acquisition strategy; Bitcoin holdings are less liquid than existing cash and cash equivalents and may not provide the same source of liquidity for microstrategies as cash and cash equivalents do; If a micropolicy or third-party service provider experiences a security breach or cyber attack, or loses a private key or is compromised, it could lose some or all of its Bitcoins.
The question we should be asking is this: If the price of bitcoin continues to march toward $100,000, how will the U.S. government face an asset bubble that is now almost entirely unchecked? In a February 20 editorial, The Washington Post called on the Federal Reserve and U.S. financial regulators to confront whether the monetary and fiscal policies pursued in response to the new crown are directly or indirectly contributing to the risk of asset bubbles in cryptocurrencies.
If U.S. regulators have the guts to step in, will there be regulatory limits on the percentage of digital assets that public companies can hold as reserves? There are currently rules in place in the US that restrict listed companies from buying back more than 25 per cent of their average daily trading volume. If US regulators implement similar rules, it would mean that if the price of bitcoin continues to rise, causing the digital currency in their asset reserves to breach the legal limit, it would force companies to sell their bitcoins, creating an unprecedented selling pressure in the cryptocurrency market.
In some ways, microstrategies have been successful in stoking corporate and stock market collective anxiety about hyperinflation by likening the US to Weimar Germany. But will this herding effect, bordering on hysteria, encourage companies to use their balance sheets to prop up share prices? The lack of regulation makes cryptocurrencies more vulnerable to market manipulation.
Global regulators should be concerned about digital asset price volatility, which has the potential to spill over into traditional capital markets and destabilize equity and other asset markets.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia