Original title: Should Bitcoin Be Added to Your Portfolio? "
Original source: Wu Zhijian, FT Chinese website
In the past ten years, what kind of assets The best return? If Bitcoin can also be regarded as an asset, the answer is none other than Bitcoin.
From December 31, 2010 to December 31, 2020, the price of Bitcoin rose from 26 cents to $28,000 Above, the cumulative return exceeds 11 million percent, and the annualized return is 217%, far exceeding the return of the S&P 500 Index (13.9%) and the US dollar bond (AGG, 3.8%) in the same period. If we include the price increase of more than a month in the beginning of 2021, the return of Bitcoin is even higher.
Then the question is, is such an excellent performance enough for Bitcoin to become an asset class like stocks and bonds, making Investors take it seriously and put it in their asset allocation portfolio? How much weight should we allocate if we add Bitcoin to our portfolio?
Let's look at the first question first. What are the reasons to support Bitcoin as an asset choice?
The biggest reason for support comes from the limited supply of Bitcoin, which is a total of 21 million. Since the total supply is capped, bitcoin is like gold: no one has the ability to create more bitcoins out of thin air, and dig a little less. This feature is completely opposite to the banknotes issued by all national central banks.
In the era of banknotes, the central bank of any country can print and issue banknotes without limit to satisfy its currency Policy Objectives. The financial crisis in 2008 made the world feel the power of quantitative easing to print money. The central bank's money supply worth hundreds of billions of dollars has kept bond yields firmly near zero, while pushing up the prices of assets such as stocks and real estate.
More than 10 years after the end of the financial crisis, everyone thought that the global central bank would gradually restore normal monetary policy and bring the benchmark interest rate back to a more reasonable range. Unexpectedly, the new crown epidemic in 2020 completely disrupted the original plan. The central banks of major countries have lowered their benchmark interest rates to zero, or even negative ranges. At the same time, the governments of various countries have launched trillion-level stimulus policies that are larger than the scale of the 2008 financial crisis.
Every time there is a financial crisis, the response strategies of the government and the central bank seem to be nothing new. big. Will such an operation lead to a higher price level, or even hyperinflation? Will it cause systemic risk? The limited supply of Bitcoin is very special in this context, providing an effective hedge to deal with the investment risks caused by the government's excessive currency issuance. Judging from the data of the past three years, the price of Bitcoin does have a negative correlation with the value of the U.S. dollar, which shows that when the U.S. dollar depreciates, Bitcoin can provide a certain hedging function.
In addition to its value as an inflation hedge, Bitcoin also offers value in cross-border payments and capital transfers. If more people and institutions accept Bitcoin, then we may realize zero-cost cross-border payment and transfer, and realize a subversive revolution for the global banking system. The prospect of this use alone is enough to make Bitcoin a hot asset. Since Bitcoin is not a stock or a bond, in a diversified portfolio, Bitcoin can reduce the volatility of the portfolio and increase the Sharpe ratio of the portfolio.
In fact, Bitcoin has indeed been favored by some institutions and companies and has become their investment target. For example, BlackRock, the fund group with the largest asset management scale in the world, announced in 2020 that its three public offering funds will include Bitcoin in their investment scope. US-based MassMutual bought $100 million worth of bitcoin in 2020. In January 2021, Tesla purchased Bitcoin worth $1.5 billion and announced that it would accept Bitcoin as payment for the purchase of its electric vehicles.
After talking about the reasons why Bitcoin can be accepted as an investment asset, let's talk about the reasons for opposing it.
The biggest objection is actually similar to the reason against gold as an investment asset, that is, Bitcoin itself does not generate cash flow, so it cannot be used in traditional financial methods to value it. Assets like stocks, bonds, and real estate generate cash flows, including corporate free cash flow, dividends, interest, and rent. Based on these cash flows and capital costs, we can make a reasonable valuation for them and calculate their intrinsic value. But should a Bitcoin be worth $10, $10,000, or $500,000? Reasonable value seems to depend entirely on market supply, demand and sentiment. This is precisely the difference between speculation and investment: Without the support of fundamentals, relying entirely on market sentiment to determine the price of an asset looks more like speculation than investment.
In 2018, the price of Bitcoin fell from around 18,000 to 3,000 US dollars, and more than 80% of its market value fell. In January 2021, the price of Bitcoin fell by more than 30% in just one month. Have the fundamentals of Bitcoin changed so much in a month? I'm afraid not. So why did its price fluctuate so violently in a short period of time? Probably can only be explained by speculative changes in market sentiment.
If we look back at the price changes of Bitcoin, we will find that it has not played the role of diversifying risks that everyone expected. For example, in the fourth quarter of 2018, global stock markets fell, and the S&P 500 index fell by about 14%. Over the same period, Bitcoin has fallen even more, falling by around 44%. In the first quarter of 2020, the S&P 500 index retreated by about 34% due to the new crown epidemic, while Bitcoin fell by about 38% during the same period. A good asset that can diversify risks, it is best not to fall when the stock market falls, and even the price rises. But Bitcoin does not convincingly provide such value.
Another reason against investing in Bitcoin mainly comes from the attitude of governments around the world. As mentioned above, one of the values of Bitcoin is that it can realize free cross-border payment and capital transfer. But the premise of realizing this value is that the governments of various countries allow Bitcoin to grow and be accepted by more and more merchants, institutions and banks. At least so far, there is no sign that Bitcoin will be recognized by mainstream governments and financial institutions. This also increases the transaction cost of Bitcoin. Whether you want to buy or sell Bitcoin, or invest in Bitcoin funds, you have to pay relatively high transaction and friction costs, and bear certain credit risks. These factors are enough to make investors think twice before buying Bitcoin on a large scale.
So after comparing the supporting and opposing opinions, what attitude should we hold towards Bitcoin?
We might as well use the data to analyze it again. Research (Arnott, 2021) shows that in the past 10 years, although the return of Bitcoin is much better than that of stocks, its price volatility is also very large, with a maximum retracement of 82%. In other words, if an investor buys 100 yuan of bitcoin, in the most extreme case, the market value of the bitcoin in hand is only 18 yuan. Due to the highly volatile nature of bitcoin prices, buying even a small amount of bitcoin can greatly increase portfolio volatility and drawdowns.
If 1% of Bitcoin is replaced in a pure stock portfolio, then the investment portfolio containing 1% of Bitcoin will increase the annual return on investment by 7.3% About, but at the same time its maximum retracement will increase to about 33%. If you replace 5% of stocks with Bitcoin in the portfolio, the annual return will increase by about 30%, but the maximum drawdown will also increase to 62%. And if you replace 10% of stocks with Bitcoin in the investment portfolio, while the annual return increases by about 50%, the maximum drawdown further increases to 71%.
Here, we can see a clear trade-off:If you want to increase the return of your investment portfolio through Bitcoin, you have to accept higher risks of. Including even a small amount of Bitcoin in a portfolio, the market value of the entire portfolio will fluctuate depending on the rise and fall of the price of Bitcoin. For most individual investors, such a range of ups and downs is obviously too large, and it is difficult for people to accept it calmly.
In summary, Bitcoin has achieved amazing price increases in the past ten years. Bitcoin has a certain hedging value against the depreciation of the US dollar and inflation risks, but it does not generate internal cash flow itself, price fluctuations are highly speculative, and the government and financial institutions have an ambiguous attitude towards it. These factors limit the value of Bitcoin. The investment attributes of the currency and the future price increase space. Since the price of Bitcoin fluctuates too much, individual investors should invest cautiously. If you really want to include Bitcoin in your investment portfolio, its allocation ratio should also be controlled at a relatively low level to ensure that the risk and drawdown of the investment portfolio are within an acceptable range.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia
