header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

a16z: Will direct listing be a new trend for tech unicorns?

Read this article in 20 Minutes
Here's everything you ever wanted to know about direct listings.
Original source: a16z
Original title: "All about Direct Listings"
Translator: China Voting


There is a new trend worthy of attention: more and more technology companies are adopting direct listing (Direct Listing) as a way to enter the public market instead of traditional IPO. Spotify pioneered it, and Slack did the same.


Both of these companies are listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE). all available.


However, in a direct listing, the company itself does not sell any shares nor raise funds. So why would a company go public directly? Are there any other major differences between an IPO and a direct listing? What trade-offs does this new form factor entail?


The operation of direct listing is still relatively new. Given that I have some experience in the capital market for a long time, and we are also the investors behind Slack, we have some experience, I will try to introduce direct listing in this article.


How is a direct listing different from an IPO?


The biggest difference between an IPO and a direct listing is that there is no "O" (Offering), that is, a directly listed company does not sell shares to public investors. Beyond that, there are a few substantive differences, but mainly in the order in which the processes operate.


The links involved in the operation of the two processes are actually very similar - registration, investor education and trading. The main difference is when and, in some cases, how these events occur.


1. There is no formal inquiry roadshow for direct listing


In a traditional IPO , Listed companies will work with underwriters (investment banks) to conduct intensive roadshows in various places for more than two weeks, and conduct back-to-back talks with potential investors. This is done not only to market the corporate story, but also to enable the management team to build relationships with investors (often large institutional investors) and for these institutional investors to submit share purchase orders after the process is complete.


Although the company has set an initial issue price range during the IPO roadshow as a guide for the listing price, the company usually will Meet the "market" feedback to adjust the price.


In the traditional IPO process, there are three prices related to the company's listing: the first price is the initial issue price range; the second price is the IPO pricing , that is, the actual price at which the company sells the stock to institutional investors; the third price is the transaction price, that is, the actual opening price after the IPO is priced, which will be determined on the stock exchange where the stock is listed according to market supply and demand.


But how did the company determine its IPO price in the first place? We return to the inquiry stage: this stage, the company and the underwriters will try to determine a stock price for the most ideal investors. Especially those technology companies that want to continue product innovation, they will look for investors who can "understand" their company and support them in the market for a long time.


It's the art of the IPO process, from relationship building to asking price, but basically it's all about getting the right mix of investors at the right price Together. The goal of an IPO is to allocate "just right" stocks for investors. This ratio allows investors to pay attention to the company, quickly appreciate the value of their holdings, and leave a share for future buyers.


Going to this point will involve many links, from IPO pricing discounts, carefully planning "hot" IPO scenes, and stock price surges (this phenomenon appears to be It looks like a big success on the first day of the IPO), to ensure that the company has a series of measures to ensure future growth, such as new products, initiatives and market growth (my partner Jeff Jordan usually advises companies before IPO These).


Similar planning, investor education, and investor relationship building as mentioned above are also very important in the case of a direct listing - just no roadshow for a direct listing Instead, it was changed to "Investor Day". That is, the company generally invites investors to learn about the company in a one-to-many format (such as a webcast). As a result, direct listings are considered a more democratized form, as everyone receives the same amount of information at the same time.


Directly listed companies will also have one-on-one meetings with the largest and most influential investors together with capital market consultants. Note that advisors here are also investment banks, e.g. Morgan Stanley, one of the Big Four investment banks, is an advisor to two direct listing cases so far (Slack and Spotify), but here the role of the investment bank is not the same as The underwriters for an IPO are a little different.


While the parties involved and the process are similar, the scope of investor meetings during a direct listing is much more limited than during a traditional IPO roadshow segment. Most notably, direct listing companies do not sell any shares, so there is neither a price inquiry process nor an order for shares from investors.


Through these, we can come to a conclusion that through a direct listing, the company can achieve many of the goals of the IPO roadshow and sell the stock at a "more realistic" market price pricing.


Directly listed companies will also publicly provide forward-looking financial guidance to investors in the form of earnings conference calls and press releases. But in a traditional IPO, the company doesn't disclose these until the listing is complete (usually in the first quarter revenue disclosure), because the company's S-1 registration form is not effective until the night of pricing (the day before the first transaction) , so companies cannot violate SEC regulations by disclosing financial guidance in advance. In a direct listing, the registration to go public takes effect before the deal (Slack does it 10 days before the deal), so the company can disclose this type of financial guidance before the stock trades. In this way, direct listings can also improve structural issues on the IPO timeline.


2. There is no lock-up period for a direct listing


In a traditional IPO, the company Existing shareholders generally agree to a period (usually 180 days from the date the IPO is priced) during which they are restricted from selling shares.


Although the US Securities and Exchange Commission does not mandate it, investment banks usually require it, because in this way, the company's stock can be traded within a certain period of time, And create transaction records. In theory, issuing a certain number of new shares can provide greater trading predictability, allowing the stock market to stabilize before more shares enter the market.


In a typical IPO, on the other hand, the magnitude of the outstanding shares is very small, usually 10% of the company's total shares. This kind of artificial restriction will limit the investment behavior of buying a large number of stocks, and it will be difficult for investors to observe the real price of the stock, because there is not enough transaction data for both parties to determine the price. Investors usually have to wait until the lock-up period expires and gradually buy stocks to build positions.


3. Direct listing is cheaper than IPO


On the matter of listing , the fee is far less important than a good outcome, but that's another difference between a direct listing and an IPO, so I'll point it out. Currently, the IPO underwriting fee is calculated based on the proportion of the listed company’s fundraising scale, usually around 7%. For some large-scale and well-known IPO projects, the underwriting fee ratio will be as low as about 2%. In a direct listing, there is only a small fixed advisory fee, roughly half the minimum underwriting fee for an IPO.


How a Direct Listing Works


As mentioned above, the main operations of a direct listing and an IPO are Not a huge difference, but there are subtle differences in timing and approach between the two.


IPOs have been around for centuries and more people are familiar with them, so I will focus on direct listings.


1. Preparation stage


The preparation work of the two is similar. It's worth noting that by the time the public sees the company's S-1 registration filing, the company has been preparing it privately for months, and steps include:


● Submit S-1 listing registration documents to the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) (usually in secret).

The Securities and Exchange Commission will review the Form S-1, provide comments and identify questions that need to be answered.

●At the same time, the company will hold an investor education meeting to prepare materials for the investor day. At this time, the S-1 is not yet effective, so forward-looking guidance cannot be provided.

There is also a quiet period during the company's listing registration period, during which all public statements by the company and related parties (board members and major investors) must follow the rules of caution and avoid hype before the stock transaction .

After the initial review period, the company will file a public filing (corporate decision time) where investors and the public will see the amended S-1 registration statement for the first time, but still in draft form.


2. Pre-listing


The next stage - 5 days before the first listing Weeks or so - this is also the stage where the procedural differences between direct listing and IPO begin to appear: 


The company will invite investors to participate in the "Investor Day", At that time they will discuss the company and financial performance publicly, but still only talk about historical data.

The company will conduct one-on-one meetings with investors to determine needs, establish relationships with investors, and build trust between the two parties, but this process does not include inquiry.

At this stage, the US Securities and Exchange Commission will declare the S-1 registration statement effective, the company can then issue forward-looking financial guidance, investors can at least 1-2 weeks before the company goes public Here, carefully consider the stock price intention.


3. Pricing


In the final stage, the existing shareholders of the company also Will start to determine the stock price intention. Remember, the company itself does not issue stock. In any market, there must be shares available for purchase by new investors to ensure liquidity, but this can only be achieved if shareholders sell shares. So far, the company has halted any trading of shares on the secondary market.


The day before the market opens, the stock exchange will negotiate with the company's financial advisor and announce a reference price. This price is the closest to the IPO's initial filing price range, but is really just a guideline to inform the public about recent transactions. In an IPO, the initial offering price range must be at least close to the initial opening price, whereas in a direct listing, the reference price does not actually have any substantive effect. (There may even be an underlying fact that the reference price for a direct listing is set to satisfy the traditional IPO mechanism — cementing the public's fascination with the "hot" opening and rising stock prices.)

< br>

In the early morning of the first day of trading, the auction begins - first indicating the quantity demanded, and then establishing the price based on supply and demand. Buyers and sellers will adjust their orders in the first few hours as the market focuses on the equilibrium price. With the Slack direct listing, buyers and sellers began trading about 2.5 hours after the market opened, faster than most participants expected; the volume of supply and demand was high and the transaction speed was so fast that market makers chose to open earlier stock trading.


Traditional IPO transactions have a similar process to determine the stock price, but in the first 180 days, the newly issued shares can only be sold to new investors, the number of transactions very limited. In contrast, a direct listing can see a truer picture of supply and demand.


Finally, although there is no hard and fast rule, but because it is helpful to the business, I would suggest that those companies that want to go through the direct listing can at least six months or even Earlier, the private second-hand trading market for enterprises was opened. Although most private companies have comprehensive and strict restrictions on private transactions in the secondary market, after entering the market, the company can still go through the equity transfer approval process to maintain control of the company.


The purpose of this is not only to diversify the ownership structure, but also to help companies establish the basis for the initial price before direct listing. The initial price would not be entirely guesswork.


Since the secondary market can bring liquidity to early investors and employees, and has no dilutive effect on the equity of existing investors, why is the secondary market Can't achieve the goal of direct listing?


The secondary market cannot provide real market prices like a direct listing: it is more like a market that matches a single buyer with a corresponding single seller, while Not a true public market, with a robust supply and demand that can match many buyers and sellers.  Trading volume is the key to finding the true market price for a direct listing.


Some misconceptions about direct listings


Direct listings are still a new phenomenon and currently So far only two have gone public through it, but this could become a trend. The traditional IPO process has matured, and now is the time for innovation: The first IPO was technically more than 400 years ago, and the current IPO rules were written nearly a century ago.


But science and technology have changed dramatically since then. For example, Google used a "Dutch auction" for its IPO in 2004, setting the online liquidation price as the IPO price.


There are also other innovative models recently, such as the Long-Term Stock Exchange (Long-Term Stock Exchange, LTSE), the first securities exchange headquartered in Silicon Valley The institute aims to combine company construction and market interests for a long time. Last month, the SEC just approved the Long Term Stock Exchange application (we are also an investor in the Long Term Stock Exchange).


Direct listings occur because the timing structure, sequence of operations and listing mechanisms need to change. A direct listing is also a natural evolution, given how the capital markets have changed over the course of the past decade.


Before that, a company going public would have a Series A round, then a Series B round, a Series C round... and then an IPO. The fundraising scale at that time was much smaller than it is today, and most of the early investors were venture capital institutions.


Companies today may raise five to seven rounds of financing, raising hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars—not just from VCs, but from From hedge funds, mutual funds and sovereign wealth funds.


Companies can get all their money from the private market and no longer need to rely on the public market for fundraising (we used to call this phenomenon "quasi-IPO") . Also, these companies can still build long-term relationships with investors in the public markets, which is something I recommend companies do as soon as possible.


A company's decision to go public today is usually driven by capital needs or considerations other than investors, so a direct listing offers a more mature route to listing.


Below I will talk about some common misconceptions about IPOs and direct listings to help people better understand direct listings.


Myth 1: Price appreciation is the measure of a successful listing


The biggest IPO of the modern era The misconception (aided and instigated by media coverage) is that stock price appreciation is a measure of listing success, not business success. That doesn't fit the reality of a direct listing, nor does it fit the traditional IPO situation. A surge in IPOs might get a lot of attention, but it's also a sign that IPOs are mispriced.


In the case of a direct listing, the most important measure of deal success is volume - which is more reflective of truly balanced pricing, i.e. many buyers and sellers trade in relatively discrete price ranges.


Note that in a traditional IPO, the total float issued and traded during the lock-up period is usually very limited, which limits how many buyers and how many sellers can really be sure The ability of the market to clear prices.


Of course, this means that if there is not enough transaction volume, there may be problems with the direct listing. In our first direct listing (Spotify), we learned that the stock opened on very low volume, resulting in it opening near the day's high and closing near the day's low. But in Slack's case, 45.5 million shares traded at the open, the most in NYSE history.


Myth 2: New public companies need discounted prices to attract new investors


Currently , the IPO will attract investors at an excessively discounted price and facilitate them to make quick profits. In a direct listing, however, all investors enter the market at a market-clearing price that matches the company with the most suitable investors. Great companies attract discerning investors, but good companies at a reasonable price also attract good investors.


In many ways, a direct listing is a more egalitarian process for companies and investors looking to build long-term relationships than via a solicitation Create a transactional relationship.

Institutional investors themselves are constantly evolving and spend a lot of time finding, building relationships with, and investing in promising companies that are still private.


In the past, companies going public often met their lead investors for the first time during the IPO roadshow. Now, this practice is less common.


Traditional IPO, the reason why there is a roadshow is entirely because large mutual funds and hedge funds are far away and not easy to get close to, so investment banks need to be present in the roadshow Act as a bridge. In a traditional IPO, the banks themselves play a dual role, as their clients include both the IPO-going company and the investors involved in the deal, who are often regular customers they must satisfy.


To be clear, investment banks add enormous value to a public company, but in a direct listing their role shifts from being an underwriter to a more Consultant to the Coordinator. When Slack went public directly, Morgan Stanley used the lessons learned from the Spotify case to achieve a solid launch and flawless operation of Slack.


Myth 3: IPOs are financing


Companies today stay private longer , given this phenomenon, an IPO is not so much a financing event as it is a move to ensure that the business is "well run" and remains robust and durable. What investors want to see today is a company that already has good financial performance, profitability and cash flow when it enters the public markets.


In the IPO financing level, the company will be listed at a level lower than the market clearing price, adjusted to meet the liquidity of the open market (about 10%) and the company's needs s price. Take the recent Zoom IPO as an example (note that we are not investors and the following is not investment advice):


 Total shares outstanding or available for IPO are: 8% of the current stock total, about 21 million shares

IPO issue price: US$36/share

 Stock price to start trading: US$65/share

 Current market price: around $85-90 per share


Since the company and selling shareholders have raised a total of about $700 million (the company like Like many companies, it was forced to underpricing its IPO), leaving the company with around $1.2 billion in headroom based on the current value of those shares.


How much different would it be if these companies were listed on the public market at an equilibrium price, like a direct listing?


Misunderstanding 4: Companies that need financing cannot go public directly


Since today’s IPO behavior is not It must be for financing, so what about those companies that need financing and want to go public directly?


In my opinion, these companies can do this: instead of raising capital through IPOs, artificially discounting, selling more shares than they really need, they can do it while they are private Raise capital and then, when the time is right, initiate the direct listing process. By separating financing and listing, companies can better determine the number of shares to be offered and the market price, and they don't need to give excessive discounts.


Assume that a company valued at $10 billion needs to raise an additional $300 million, with sufficient reserves in operation for the next few years. If a traditional IPO is carried out, it will result in about 10% equity dilution, and the transaction price will also be greatly discounted; while the direct listing will only have about 2-3% dilution, and the transaction price is relatively reasonable.


If further financing is required in the future, the company can enter the capital market as a mature issuer, which is one of the main benefits of going public. If Slack had gone public with a traditional IPO, even with $800 million on the company's balance sheet, it would have had to sell about 10% of the company (by market standards) to meet liquidity needs and take unnecessary dilution.


In contrast, if it is a direct listing, Slack does not need to sell shares and will not generate equity dilution. After becoming a public company for a period of time, Slack will be regarded as an experienced issuer. If there is a financing need, Slack can decide the timing of financing according to its own situation.


Myth 5: Public market investors don’t like direct listings


In the past few I have heard this argument many times. When I ask why, two common responses are: there is no price appreciation in direct listings, and there is no lock-up period in direct listings to predict selling pressure.


I think these two statements are exaggerated for the following reasons:


Discount pricing of the IPO Not a feature, but a bug. As mentioned above, there's little benefit in the stock's rise since the company undervalued the stock, leaving what was really valuable on the table.


Frankly, the discount is relatively inconsequential to institutional investors, the ideal shareholder of a public company. Floating shares make up a tiny fraction of a typical IPO and are nothing compared to large mutual funds that hold billions of dollars in stakes. Therefore, only when there are more stocks in the market after the unlocking period, will there be greater liquidity and investors can hold positions on a larger scale. A direct listing resolves this timing mismatch.


The lock-in period is not as predictable as people think. Any benefit gained from tradable shares is lost in limited numbers and heightened volatility.


There is no 180-day lock-up period for direct listing, existing shareholders (including employees) can sell shares; Illiquidity is also eliminated.


Ideally, if the price is right, there will be enough tradable shares in the market that there will be no high volatility and constant Selling pressure - This is the predictability companies and investors want.


Myth 6: Only “well-known” brands can go direct


This statement may apply That’s true for Spotify, the first direct listing (a mainstream audio service), and it could even apply to the second, Slack (a SaaS offering widely used by consumers and businesses). But what about the fifth? What about the tenth house? As direct listings become more popular, brand names won't matter as much.


Whether it is a traditional IPO or a direct listing, what investors have to do is to understand those companies before they go public. Therefore, even if the company to be listed is not a popular, consumer-oriented brand, or even a consumer-oriented brand, at least in the investment circle, this company will be well-known.


You may ask, what about retail investors or individual investors? First, note that retail placements — the number of shares to individual investors — typically only make up about 10% or so of all IPO placements, and tend to be less. For the most successful IPOs, this is not a necessary source of what is needed.


That is to say, the advantage of direct listing is that the threshold for retail shareholders and investment institutions is the same.


There is a lot of media coverage about technology companies these days and there is a lot of information available in the market, so if a company is good enough to go public, investors of all kinds will come to welcome it .


Of course, there are still many things to be solved in the direct listing, such as better understanding of supply and demand, more efficient and automatic pricing mechanism, etc., and direct listing It's still early days, and the SEC may gradually change the rules to accommodate more innovations.


However, direct listings are a corresponding, wider natural evolution of what we have seen over the past decade - private markets becoming more active Increased exposure to IPOs of more mature companies and other macro trends.


Therefore, if the goal of listing is not only to raise more funds, but to establish a long-term business, the listing mechanism should be considered to a certain extent.


The company has a history of hundreds of years, and the current IPO regulations have existed for decades. As technologies, companies, and markets evolve, it's time for more innovation.


Original link< /a>


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit