Original title: SADDLE FINANCE
Original source: Rekt
Original compilation: 0x26

< /p>
It is understood that Saddle is a subsidiary spun off from Thesis, and the parent company Thesis is the crypto venture capital firm behind projects such as tBTC, Keep and Fold. The Keep Network team has pledged to provide 125,000 KEEP per week as rewards for Saddle liquidity providers.
In addition to code duplication, there was also a case where arbitrageurs exchanged 0.34 sBTC for 4.36 wBTC at the beginning of Saddle’s launch Incident, a large amount of arbitrage caused the loss of users who deposited funds into Saddle in the first time.

Transaction hash: 0x3c351cea655b8a50348e6ff a1bfff5b4ce68f99366cfad3d8a02ffb01f63138a
In this regard, Rekt summarized the Saddle Finance incident, and Rhythm summarized the full text as follows:
< /p>
Some things are better left alone.
Why fund a fork without innovation?
The DeFi industry is still very young, there are still many things waiting to be built, why spend time and money to replicate What about existing products without adding any value?
When not those well-known small teams complete branches quickly, it can usually be understood-anonymous developers just for Get some "quick cash". However, this is a project that has received a lot of funding and marketing and is nothing new to the community.
Raising $4.2M, Copying Curve’s Code, Then it is "harvested".
If you can’t fully understand the behind Curve Finance Mathematical principles, why imitate it?
If you have enough money to start a VC, it means there is enough cash to invest in those Projects that bring something new to the world. So, why invest in a fork?
Any investment that supports this project They all regard profit as more important than industry development.
This includes new (and old) media companies that take money from Saddle, we know startups It's hard, sometimes having to take this kind of work, but think about your reputation.

Maybe the only field that Saddle has not set foot in are restricted by intellectual property law.
With millions of dollars arbitraged within hours of going live, the Saddle Finance team had to defend their Express issued an official news release, which included unacceptable slippage in a protocol designed to "solve the DeFi slippage problem."
The execution of some early trades showed a large
user High slippage warning may have been ignored;
In response to some early high slippage trades, we updated the front end to make high slippage warnings more explicit.
The Block researcher Igor Igamberdiev issued several warnings, advising users to withdraw from the Saddle Finance liquidity pool , and Thesis founder Matt Luongo has no sympathy for users who have suffered losses from using Saddle.
At least three arbitrages from early LP took away 7.9 BTC.
4.01 BTC $139,961 Jan-19-2021 04:06:5 4 PM +UTC
< /p>
0.79 BTC $27,573 Jan -19-2021 04:08:46 PM +UTC
3.11 BTC $108,548 J an-19-2021 04:12:37 PM +UTC
Those users who deposit funds into Saddle Finance within an hour of the product launch will never get as much money as they put in, Now they can only hope that LP returns are good enough.
There is no way to stop imitation, but at least you can focus on the results .
Maybe this is all part of Saddle Finance's marketing plan. If any publicity was good publicity, then maybe they would have won,but this time it was the early LPs who paid for the bad promotion, not the rich the VC.
At least they went to Quantstamp for a contract audit, but if no one reads these audit reports, then the audit What is the value of
Quantstamp has conducted a contract security review on Saddle Finance’s StableSwap. It is worth noting that this project is from Curve The Finance contract was copied, and the Curve contract was used as a reference during the review process. In the end, a total of 14 security vulnerabilities were identified, in addition to some deviations from the specification, code documentation issues and best practice issues. Due to poor documentation, we cannot determine how the developers derived some implementation formulas from the StableSwap white paper. Also, we noticed that all tests in the current test suite use only 2 tokens in the pool, and we strongly recommend that projects add more tests that use 3 or more tokens and fix any issues found before Deploy the code to production.
The actual implementation is different from the original StableSwap, we can't understand how this is calculated from the original StableSwap document come out.
Curve's Ben Hauser says:
"The comments in the Saddle codebase contain various parts of the Curve codebase. When explaining something, it also mentions 'Check out the curve .fi". They obviously don't care about my gas optimization, or just don't understand why I can do gas optimization."
Valentin Mihov said:
“In the open source world In , rewriting the code rather than directly forking has certain implications. For example, if tomorrow Curve implements new features in the protocol, the rewritten system cannot incorporate these new features. They will need to spend a lot of time on their system. Not Sushi or DSD, that's the difference."
Courtesy of Ivangbi, Administrator of Lobsterdao I made the following analogy:
I did not copy your book, I just translated it into English and added two pictures .
Considering the cost of Saddle Finance porting Curve code from Vyper to Solidity After six months, the end result left a lot to be desired.

We look forward to old memes from Matt Luongo and his team.

The founder of Saddle Finance has a close connection with Thesis, the parent company of tBTC, so veCRV holders voted to express their views on the Saddle Finance project - reduce the tBTC pool CRV bonus.

"The good ones imitate, the great ones plagiarize".
Immature poets imitate, mature poets steal. Bad poets destroy what they've got, and good poets make it into something better, or at least something different. A good poet infuses his stealing with a unique feeling quite different from being torn.
The founders and funders of Saddle Finance are mature enough to understand the situation better. In this industry, there are many opportunities to make money without plagiarizing other people's works.
This project will not replace its predecessor (Curve), but it can reveal the true face of those who promoted it.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia