header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Don't be too obsessed with the second-tier solution, the new public chain has a greater chance

Read this article in 13 Minutes
Co-founder of Multicoin Capital is more optimistic about the new public chain than the second-layer solution
Original title: "The Bull Case for Ethereum Challengers"
Original author: Kyle Samani, Co-founder and Managing Partner of Multicoin Capital



Looking at the current development of Ethereum, people would think that it is the most likely protocol to harvest the fruits of DeFi. The main advantages of Ethereum include:


-Ethereum Zone The currency value of the block chain is higher: an asset with a currency premium has a base layer with greater security than those protocols that do not have this advantage;

-Ethereum has the widest network effect: DeFi protocols, Developer tools, mind exchange, Layer 2, everyone in the crypto space is developing a bridge to Ethereum as an economic link. For DeFi, Ethereum-level network effects are very powerful.


Faced with these advantages of Ethereum, how can the new public chains stand out? This question is difficult to answer. When Multicoin made an encryption investment decision, I thought about it thousands of times. In this article, I will try to answer this question from the perspectives of DeFi insiders and outsiders.



Image source: DeFi stack


DeFi internal perspective


“People often ask me the question: ‘What do you think the world will be like in 10 years? What else remains constant in the world?” I actually think the second question is more important, because knowing the answer to it allows you to build a business strategy around those constants… In the retail industry, we are able to determine that customers want lower prices, and I know that will be true in 10 years; they also want faster logistics; they want more choices. It's hard to imagine One day, 10 years later, a customer came to me and said, "Jeff, I love Amazon; I wish your prices were higher," or "I love Amazon; I wish your shipping was slower." — that’s simply not possible. So we spend our time on these constant things, pushing them forward, and we know that the energy we put in today will pay off for Amazon’s customers 10 years from now. When you’re sure If you know something is right (even in the long run), you can put a lot of energy into it." - Amazon founder and CEO Jeff Bezos


Crypto advocates (myself included) love to discuss the monetary value of base layer protocols. This is understandable to some extent, after all, the current perspective on encryption technology is mainly divided into two types: monetary encryption and technical encryption.


But in my opinion, a lot of opinions about cryptocurrencies is wrong (at least for now). It is too early to treat these trust-minimizing assets as money at this stage. The reality is that very few outsiders will be using anything other than stablecoins for the foreseeable future. I think it's best to use underlying currencies like BTC and ETH as collateral at the moment.


For smart contract platforms, encryption is important at the moment Technology, not monetary attributes. If a smart contract is technically successful, it has the opportunity to create a certain currency premium, but this usually takes a long time to verify, and a technology will only generate currency after it has proven itself in the public for a long time premium.


Ethereum currently has hundreds of thousands of daily active users, DeFi users Just a small part of it. From a technical point of view, when will a certain technology stand out and gain hundreds of thousands of DAUs?


We know there will be a variety of Two-tier solutions, but considering the actual flow of capital in the system, they cannot completely solve the overall ecological level problem. These second-tier solutions can only solve local problems, and even in the most optimistic cases, they cannot completely solve the core problem.


To understand this point, let’s look at the current Ethereum funding A few examples of liquidity in DeFi:


Scenario 1: Ordinary investor - we assume he holds ETH. He deposited ETH into Aave, obtained USDC, and then pledged it to dYdX (Starkware two-layer network) for ETH leveraged trading. The profit he made in the process was in USDC and he wanted to use the profit to buy some AAVE, so he withdrew his USDC from dYdX. In a world where Layer 2 networks are flooding, Uniswap is also cloning a Layer 2 version, so now there are two Uniswaps. In order to get the best price, ordinary investors also use tools like Paraswap to get quotes directly from market makers, where Paraswap acts as a bridge connecting Layer 1 and Optimism Layer 2. Then this USDC-AAVE transaction generated 3 on-chain transactions: 1) Connecting to the Uniswap exchange pool at Layer 1, 2) Conducting USDC-AAVE atomic transactions with market makers on Layer 1, 3) In order to hedge risks, market makers Submit a transaction to Uniswap on the Layer 2 network.


The efficiency of this capital flow method is much higher than the original one ? Actually not.


Scenario 2: Market Maker—Assume that we are in a world where multiple second-tier derivatives exchanges coexist. Their matching mechanisms, technologies and market strategies are different, but they all control their own executive layer. Suppose these exchanges are Perpetual Protocol, dYdX, DerivaDEX, MCDEX, Futureswap, Injective, and Vega (similar to the current 8 major centralized exchanges where encrypted derivatives are concentrated in the head). To balance positions (to avoid being liquidated) in times of wild market volatility, market makers need to move funds from one exchange to another. When the market fluctuated violently, Uniswap, Balancer, and other Layer 1 liquidity pools also encountered a surge in traffic. At this time, deposits and withdrawals on the second-tier network are much more expensive than Uniswap transactions (and also more expensive than direct withdrawals from one centralized exchange to another, which is a common practice for market makers).


Is this method of capital flow more efficient than the status quo? I think it's getting more expensive because the gas cost to enter/exit Layer 2 is at least 10x the fee to withdraw an ERC20 token from one CEX to another (which is what's happening today).


These examples show that scaling through Layer 2 breaks capital The continuity of flow, and this is where the magic of DeFi lies. To be clear, the results DeFi has achieved so far are enormous (ignoring gas costs, latency, and transaction failures, etc.).


Although the second layer solution may solve the problem of individual blockchain or Some pain points of specific applications, but moving to the world of second-tier solutions destroys the foundation of DeFi's greatness. In addition to making DeFi slower and more cumbersome, a fragmented Layer 2 world will fragment liquidity pools, ultimately increasing transaction and borrowing costs.


With the fragmentation of existing liquidity, the problem will become more serious. Let's take an AaveDAO from Delphi as an example (this will split the size of the Aave pool to be smaller, thus reducing the global risk). Because the liquidity is dispersed among multiple Layer 1 and Layer 2 AaveDAO fund pools, the cost of new fund pools is more expensive.


Layer 2 expansion can indeed improve a single point of a system speed, but it fails to solve the core problems related to capital efficiency and composability - and it is these two points that make DeFi. But second-tier schemes are not useless, they are very useful in a self-contained money flow (like a player who enters a casino and plays 10 different games in it before leaving). What I want to point out is that the second layer solution does not solve the problem of expanding liquid capital on a global scale, and the flow of capital between multiple financial infrastructures.


It is also worth noting that while all of the above scenarios assume In the context of rollps (including optimistic and zk), in fact, the same problem exists in the sharding solution. The advantage of sharding over rollup is that in a well-designed sharding system, the underlying system can automatically process transactions between different shards, and developers or users will not feel which shard the transaction occurs on. Also to be clear, the automatic passing of information between shards also does not solve the core problem described above.


In reality, mobility is usually concentrated in a few Several exchanges (be it spot, loan, futures or options). Liquidity will not be a winner-take-all, or even a moat that monopolizes most of the market, but liquidity is indeed concentrated in a few major places. Liquidity trading venues will also not be distributed in the long tail (for example, there are more than 100 exchanges in the market, which are located in different layer-2 networks or shards, and have their own independent liquidity pools and/or market makers). This shows that in order to scale, what we have to do is to extend the capacity of a few trading places, rather than simply increasing the number of trading places.


So what is the correct solution ?


Before answering this question, let’s imagine a perfect exchange. First of all, most of its transactions cannot be spot, but some leveraged collateral transactions (such as futures, options, etc.). This perfect exchange:


- The more types of spot trading The more the better

-The more assets that support borrowing, the better

-Given the risk of less liquid collateral, support the use of multiple assets as collateral

< p>-Margin at the portfolio level (rather than at the position or account level)

-Supports (multi-asset) long-short hedging, thereby increasing the leverage of the portfolio

< br>

In traditional finance, all of the above services are provided by prime brokers. They have a large balance sheet and therefore provide hedge funds with multiple trading platforms (NYSE, CME, NASDAQ, FX market, bond market, etc.).


In the crypto space, the closest exchange to this model is FTX. FTX came out of nowhere in 2019 and was able to stand out from the competition because its team understood what traders wanted and built a crypto exchange based on their dreams. In reality, FTX doesn’t offer all of the above (e.g. it doesn’t support long-short hedging through multiple assets, it can’t increase portfolio leverage), but it’s the closest you can get to a prime broker.


The reason why FTX is so successful is because it employs a logic Centralized risk engine responsible for managing global risks. For example: For every $1 worth of BTC that a user pledges, he can only get $0.95 in collateral. $1 of ETH pledged can only be loaned out for $0.90. These pledged tokens can be of any kind and can be adjusted according to real-time conditions. The specific ratio parameters are not important, the most important thing is that there is a consistent global rule that applies to the entire exchange, and it is this that makes the exchange's trading efficiency the highest.


So in order to create the best DeFi place, there are two An important requirement:


1. A stable, Based on the blockchain platform based on predictability, the transaction volume of the first few trading venues is expanded based on this.

2. A logical centralized place to manage risks.


Looking at the current blockchain industry, Solana satisfies the first point, and Serum Achieved the second point. The combination of the two is unprecedented on Ethereum or other public chains.


The relationship between the blockchain and the exchange is interdependent . The FTX team chose to build Serum on Solana not only because Solana can scale transaction throughput for a certain trading venue, but also because Solana's underlying foundation is very stable. The FTX team believes that DeFi can rival CeFi to a certain extent. Their thinking is that if the scale of DeFi scales to the scale of CeFi, it is especially important to have a stable foundation on which they can continue to develop for many years. In a rapidly changing world, stability becomes an advantage.


According to Moore's Law, Nvidia New GPUs will be released with twice as many cores as the previous generation of chips. As the verification nodes continue to upgrade their hardware, Solana's overall throughput will continue to increase as the number of GPU cores increases.


After talking about the internal perspective of DeFi, let us now take an outsider Think about it from the perspective.


Outsiders' opinions and inherent prejudice

< p>

Let’s review Bezos’ famous quote first:


< p>

“People often ask me this question: ‘Do you think this How will the world change in the next 10 years?" This question is very interesting and common. But I almost never get asked the question: "What will remain the same in the world in the next 10 years?" Actually I think the second question is more important because knowing the answer to it allows you to build a business strategy around those things that don't change...in the retail industry, we are able to determine that customers want lower prices , I also know that this will become a reality in 10 years; they also want to make the logistics faster; "Jeff, I love Amazon so much; I wish your prices were higher," or "I love Amazon; I wish your shipping was slower"—that's just not possible. So we spend Building on these constants, driving them forward, we know that the effort we put in today will pay off for Amazon's customers 10 years from now. When you're sure something's right (even in the long run), you can Put a lot of energy into it." - Amazon founder and CEO Jeff Bezos


I repeat this over and over to emphasize: Stability is very important.


2017 is the cryptocurrency bubble period. On the other hand, the bubble also has a positive effect, that is, it has attracted the attention of all walks of life. In 2017, many entrepreneurs and businesses around the world looked at Ethereum (the only smart contract platform available at the time) and thought very seriously about what they could do on top of it.


Did they end up with anything? In fact, there are not many.


What is the reason? Because they lack a stable technical foundation, and based on this, smart contracts will be extended to millions of users.


Three years have passed, and there is still no clear And stable, developers will rely on expansion solutions in the next few years. In theory, Ethereum has a variety of expansion solutions, but their implementation is relatively difficult. On Reddit, there is a post on a large collection of expansion solutions, which lists dozens of solutions. They really want to solve the performance problem of Ethereum, but they just can't solve it completely.


There are currently many large corporations looking to expand permissionless encryption , some of these companies also disclosed their ambitions to the public:


1.PayPal

2.Twitter

3.Square

< p>4.Brave

5.Reddit


Additionally, the Libra Alliance has abandoned permissionless scaling in favor of a permissioned model (mainly for legal reasons).


All of the above and companies that have not publicly demonstrated their crypto aspirations are Looking for a stable, scalable foundation. Once they find such a platform, they will attack immediately, and those traditional web2 companies will bring innovation to the encryption field, and then there will be a Cambrian explosion.


Imagine if a circle completely unfamiliar with cryptocurrency What will outsiders think when they see the Brave browser running on Solana, PayPal running on Algorand, or Reddit running on Near. With Ethereum currently having less than 1 million DeFi users, these new public chain-based applications are likely to easily gain millions of users.


If this happens, public opinion will be turned upside down very quickly!


A developer can expand the stability Basics are very important. I believe that eventually Ethereum will be able to achieve this, but it is not clear when or how. At this time, a new public chain with a lighter burden (such as EVM) can provide a reliable expansion solution.


Actually, the number of people who want to adopt a permissionless blockchain Companies with millions of users rolling out new features don't exist in the imagination. What they want is a solution that can be expanded now and in the future. They don't care whether it's 1,000, 10,000, or 100,000 nodes participating in the consensus. Their focus is not on sovereign-level censorship resistance, since businesses themselves are, by definition, subject to the oversight of sovereign states.


Bankless readers may often forget the The degree to which the crypto industry is out of touch with the mainstream world is huge. Mass adoption will lead to improved infrastructure, which in turn will lead to more adoption. Although Ethereum is at the top of the encryption industry, we need to be clear that the current participation of outsiders is still zero.


In general, the reason why we are optimistic about the new public chain is that : Encryption developers and enterprises value permissionless innovation, they value transaction speed and cost for users, and they value a predictable, scalable, and solid foundation—on this foundation, they can freely release their creativity and develop with peace of mind.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit