Original title: Dialogue wang Wei: Reinterpreting DeFi from first Principles
Source: Chain Catcher
Recently, the 17th issue of the Catchers School hosted by Lianchon invited CTO Wang Wei, co-founder of Lianchon, to share the theme of "2020 Annual Summary - DeFi Special Session".
In the catcher in the school community, wang wei in 2020 from the Angle of the first principles to analyze the DeFi logic, the development of the market share in detail the root cause of the outbreak of the market this year, a lot of dry goods, such as industry trends judgment and answered why domestic rare quality problems such as DeFi application, now to sort out the full text is as follows, hope to inspire readers.
Finishing | Henry
Chaincatcher: The DeFi ecosystem has exploded in the past year, and there's been a lot of conversation around DeFi. What do you think is the biggest misperception people have of DeFi? How do you understand DeFi from a first-principles perspective?
Wang Wei: I think the first principle is very good. If you don't look at things from the first principle, it's easy to make some mistakes. For example, DeFi has two types of typical extreme views, both of which belong to this kind of mistake.
One is the question of whether DeFi has any real value. Some argue that this boom is all the result of liquid mining, and when the boom passes, so will DeFi. This completely ignores the fact that mainstream projects like Uniswap and Compound have been in the $1 billion range for the past two years, with more than $10 billion in trading volume, without the opening of a liquidity mine.
On the other hand, some people think that DeFi can do everything. For example, in the previous paragraph, the lending platform proposed to do "credit loan", that is, the loan with no collateral or the amount that can be borrowed is higher than the value of the collateral. The Compound General Counsel has written on the subject, and I've argued in a recent post that credit lending, which is essentially a financial activity based on testing the ability of people in the real world to pay back their loans, is less suited to DeFi.
The core questions of value and what can be done and what cannot be done can only be reasonably answered by thinking in terms of first principles. In my opinion, the whole financial system can be divided into two parts: the "creditworthiness" part and the "computational" part. The creditworthiness part is responsible for the expansion and reduction of credit, while the computational part is responsible for the circulation and allocation of resources.
The first principle of DeFi, the answer to the question "why we use DeFi", is that there is a better way to implement the computational part of the financial system -- the blockchain + intelligent contract, which is also the value network and its exchange rules. I believe that in the future, the computational part of the whole financial world can and should be realized by blockchain + intelligent contract. This will make the financial system of the whole society more transparent and efficient, which will benefit the general public and facilitate effective supervision. It is an ideal model. This is my thinking on DeFi's first principles.
Some deep thinking about the financial system is involved here, and the development history of DeFi reflects the differences mentioned above: The earliest mature DEX is a trading platform, because it is the trading behavior of buyers and sellers, which does not involve the credit issues of traders. One party has assets, one party has funds, the price is right can clinch a deal, so it is basically a computational process, can be realized through intelligent contract directly. Secondly, the current mainstream DeFi lending platform, as long as there is excess collateral, does not involve repayment credit, and the whole process can be realized by intelligent contract without human involvement.
The aforementioned "credit lending", since it involves credit rating, cannot be done entirely on the DeFi platform. But we can also make further analysis, and it may be a good idea to take apart the computational part and combine it with the credit system. From the field of insurance, derivatives, and so on, I personally feel the latest DeFi project are to develop in the direction of this - when people through research, analysis, effectively peel a certain financial scenario "credit" and "calculation", DeFi platform in the field of the will, this is typical of the innovation process.
Chaincatcher: Many people will attribute this year's DeFi outbreak to mobile mining. What do you think is the root cause of this year's DeFi ecological outbreak? From what Angle should we view the rationality of each project's liquidity mining mechanism and economic model?
Wang Wei: I think the explosion of DeFi this year is mainly due to the maturity and usability of some major DeFi platforms, as well as the composability of lego models among multiple DeFi platforms. Fluid mining is indeed a very effective catalyst.
Uniswap, for example, has been a hit this year with the v2 release, which introduced custom trading pairs and quickly increased market activity. In fact, Uniswap was the TVL of several hundred million dollars in v1 period, and V2 stabilized it to the level of 1 billion dollars (Sushiswap did some work in the middle, but eventually returned to this level).
After Uniswap launched the UNI mine, the TVL peaked at $3.3 billion and has since returned to $1.5 billion. From this context, it can be seen that the liquidity mining will play a great role in promoting the development, but it does not change the fundamentals and orders of magnitude of a platform product. Other platforms, such as Compound, are basically the same.
Each project has its own mining mechanism. I am not an expert in this field, and I do not have much comment on it. However, I always believe that the mobile mining mechanism is an important means for a platform's start-up stage or some upward breakthrough stage, rather than a core factor for the platform's development and success.
Chain Catcher: With this wave of DeFi this year, there is an obvious feeling that the good projects are abroad, so we started to think about the question, why there are few good DeFi applications in China?
Wang Wei: In fact, there are many good projects in China. There are also many good DeFi developers and teams. But after all, the DeFi wave started from abroad, and the country is the follower/pursuer. In this sense, it is also an objective fact to lag behind abroad. DeFi, after all, is part of the blockchain, so it is naturally open and global, and the country boundaries are not as strong as a centralized system. Now some of the DeFi projects that are being done here in China are also very popular with the foreign community, some of the DeFi projects abroad have a lot of Chinese people on the team.
I think we all have our own answers to this question, such as technological level, social environment, regulatory conditions, etc. What I want to talk about most is the aspect of the geek spirit. Over the past decade, domestic innovation has been driven mainly by investment and is closely related to the rapid economic development of the whole country. And foreign innovation, there has been a main line of the geek spirit, and investment drive is parallel, and even most of the time is the dominant position.
In the Internet sector, where domestic success now seems to be more pronounced, Internet innovation is generally moving toward a broader integration with life, such as the recent boom in vegetable sales by giants. At this level, the investment driver has a clear advantage. However, investment-driven innovation is not the decisive factor for all innovations, especially for many very early projects. In fact, ideas and implementations do not require a lot of money, but are more dependent on innovative ideas or even feelings, especially in a purely digital field like DeFi.
An inappropriate-case example would be JK Rowling writing Harry Potter in a cafe while she's on unemployment benefits. No amount of money would make it work for her. So the early blockchain and now DeFi, both have the shadow of cyberpunk behind them, emphasizing "High tech, low Life" and focusing not on making big money, but on a more free and fair environment. This, too, may not be easy for investors looking for financial returns to back.
At a deep level, it is also a microcosm of our entire domestic society. The slogan "High tech, low Life" is unlikely to appear in a person who actually lives low life because he doesn't have any money, otherwise many people might even laugh at his spirit.
I would argue that the pressure on most of our young people to make a living is indeed damaging to the creative impulse. In this environment, it is natural to hope for more investor support.
Chaining Catcher: There have been a lot of "innovations" in the DeFi industry this year. For example, the recent algorithmic stabilizer coin has attracted a lot of attention and controversy. What do you think of the value of algorithmic stabilizer coin? How do you distinguish real product innovation from hype?
Wang Wei: With this example, I want to use the model that divides the financial system into "credit" and "algorithm" to do some analysis. In a nutshell, algorithmic stabilizers include the concept of "stability" in the algorithm. What is the "stable" source of stability currency? Simply put, stability is our subjective feeling that money is the unit of account for everything else in our daily lives. Living in Japan, for example, the yen is the "stability currency", but it can actually fluctuate quite a bit against the dollar.
I know of many kinds of algorithm stability coins, the design logic is not the same, some design exquisite, can not be generalized. Let me give you a simple example. Stock exchanges all over the world have the ability to "split shares" and "partnership shares". Every time a price falls to a certain point, a partnership becomes the price that precedes the fall.
So the nominal price of the stock can stay the same, but if it's a good company that pays a lot of dividends every year, and everybody buys it, then after three years the stock looks the same, but the investor actually makes a lot of money. On the other hand, if it's a bad company, its stock price keeps falling, and it still ends up losing money. So some algorithm to keep the nominal value constant does not make this asset a "stability coin". This kind of algorithm stabilizes the coin, is actually a kind of game structure formed by taking advantage of people's hope to make money and worry about losing money.
So in my opinion, the concept of "stability" of a stable currency is derived from why it is accepted as a unit of account for other assets, and this is a concept derived from external circumstances and people's subjective opinions, which actually belongs to the "credit" part of the financial system, rather than the algorithmic part. For example, the legal tender of a country is determined by its national environment. The USDX or XUSD in our digital currency field is determined by many factors such as exchanges, and it is difficult for algorithms to play a similar role.
This leads to the second question, how to distinguish between financial innovation and gimmicks? My suggestion is to do more analysis from the perspective of financial logic, that is, "credit" and "calculation", including making more analogies.
Chain Catcher: Multicoin Capital proposed in its recent research that DeFi project may have many risks, such as contract error, poor protocol parameterization, congestion on the chain, wrong prediction machine, failure of administrator robot /LP, etc. Meanwhile, industrial safety accidents are also occurring frequently. To what extent do you think these risks can be alleviated in the future? Will DeFi security incidents significantly decrease in the next few years?
Wang Wei: I'm a technology person. Generally speaking, security incidents can be divided into two categories: one is inherent in blockchain, such as congestion on the chain; Another classic human error is what we call a bug or a lack of optimization.
First of all, the inherent situation of blockchain is congestion, which is the most talked about. In essence, we should pay corresponding costs or costs, including speed, congestion and GAS fees, when we enjoy the ability of this special computing system of blockchain. Pinning hopes on Ethereum 2.0 to solve these problems, at least, won't be a straightforward outcome.
To put it simply: If Ethereum 2.0 deals fast and low fees, then people will do more deals, and by the nature of the blockchain consensus mechanism, the overall average speed will go down again (because a block has a limited capacity). At the same time, if the speed of a single transaction is indeed much higher than 1.0, then people will be more inclined to pay high fees in exchange for speed. Those who pay low GAS fees will still encounter congestion if they can't get in line. If everyone is competing for resources, GAS prices will rise again. So ultimately, it's the choice of the market and the user, not just the technology.
Another type of problem is that the program is written by human beings in the final analysis. As long as the program is written by human beings, they will make mistakes, including many platforms being attacked. The main problem is the design idea or the logic of the code. I've been doing traditional IT myself for many years, and IT's fair to say that smart contracts are no more problematic in this respect than traditional IT.
The problem is that the whole blockchain and intelligent contract system are exposed in front of everyone, without the protection of traditional firewall and layered system, so any problem can be attacked. Therefore, these errors are more likely to cause problems than the traditional closed system, the loss may also be greater. The DeFi industry has been working on this, and I should say that so far it has been effective, and the whole ecosystem has grown.
Chain-catcher: The CeFi ecology is also developing rapidly. What do you think of CeFi and DeFi's respective positions in the industry? Or what is the future relationship of existence?
Wang Wei: Uniswap surpassed Coinbase in trading volume for the first time on August 30, and in September also surpassed Coinbase in total trading volume. I think the general trend is to surpass or even replace CeFi in terms of DeFi being able to achieve products with the same capabilities as CeFi.
Generally speaking, the rapid development of CeFi is in two directions: first, the logic of some products is relatively complex, and the implementation of intelligent contract at the present stage is inefficient and difficult to achieve results; On the other hand, the ability of a centralized system to be a counterparty, which is what we've been emphasizing, the ability of credit, for example, for some derivatives, maybe the platform is not a neutral role, but has its own capital to run. The former is mainly a technical issue, which I think is where Ethereum 2.0 could be strong, otherwise other public chains might come from behind. In short, if the technical issues can be solved, the general trend of DeFi coming from behind will not be changed. In the latter case, as we said earlier, DeFi has overrides because algorithms alone cannot solve credit problems.
Therefore, I believe that CeFi and DeFi should form a relationship of competition and cooperation in the future. The competition points are mainly in transaction, mortgage lending and other functions that can be realized by both sides. In this respect, DeFi's advantage is definitely growing. The point of cooperation lies in the different links in the long chain of asset issuance, circulation and liquidation, where each of us can play our respective roles and learn from each other. In this context, I want to emphasize that the main direction of CeFi must be to get through to the real world, including digitization of legal currency, credit lending, mortgage of real assets, etc., which can only be completed by relying on the information or credit of people in the real world.
I believe the final big trend is that there is no longer a distinction between CeFi and DeFi. For example, Maker is introducing real world assets as collateral, and there must be a centralized management link. Is it fair to say that Maker is also moving into CeFi's turf, or has become CeFi too? This goes back to the first question answered by DeFi: in the future there will be no difference between CeFi and DeFi, but between "credit" and "computing" in the financial system.
Chain Catchers: There are more and more mergers and acquisitions between DeFi projects represented by YFI. What do you think will be the impact on the industry?
DeFi platform is a set of intelligent contracts. It is code running on the blockchain. Project M&A is code m&a code? One smart contract and another smart contract? Obviously not, so it's still people and teams.
In the DeFi world, where everything is open source and transparent, intangibles like code, intellectual property, patents and so on might once have been included in a corporate acquisition. If there are any intangibles out there, it's the ones in the developer's head that haven't yet been implemented, as well as the release rights for the existing running platform, including the Github repository, the private key to the platform's managed address, and so on. In this view, in fact, the purpose of the merger is very clear, is for the team integration/collaboration behavior.
Further analysis, the DeFi protocol is inherently connectable and stackable. What are the benefits of team integration? There is only one benefit, that is, through team cooperation, the connection between the merger and the acquired project can be optimized, whether it is the interface, the process simplification, the reduction of gas fees, or the coordination of user revenue between protocols, etc.
Assuming that mergers and acquisitions do have this effect, and that more and more of them do, the result is likely to be that the DeFi world will move from individual protocols to more interconnected and synergistically efficient "family of protocols."
If this trend occurs, it will have a profound impact on the development of the DeFi industry, whether it is a good thing or a bad thing is unknown, and it requires continuous observation and deep thinking.
Chain Catcher: What do you think are the three most important trends for the DeFi industry in 2021?
Wang Wei: I think there are three trends or directions in the DeFi industry next year:
The first trend is "innovation" because the DeFi industry is so early and there are many new areas to explore. By innovation, I mean the ongoing dismantling of the "computability" part of the financial sector as described in DeFi's first principles. Whether it is insurance, interest rate, derivatives, there are many directions of innovation, but the direction of innovation should be grasped. This is the first problem in the development of DeFi, and mastering this law is an effective innovation that will succeed. Whatever new idea you come up with is at best a flash in the pan.
The second trend is "security". 2020 is the year of the DeFi outbreak and the first year of the systematic, large-scale attacks on DeFi, with hundreds of millions of dollars lost from the beginning to the end. But I think new things have to go through that process. With the law of intelligent contract security being more and more mastered, the auditing capability becoming stronger, and the price determination mechanism becoming more and more rigorous and reasonable, DeFi will be greatly improved in terms of security in 2021, which will play a vital role in the healthy development of DeFi.
The third trend is "integration", which has many aspects. For example, the project merger mentioned above is also a kind of integration. But what I want to talk about most is the integration with physical assets. This year Maker began to introduce assets under the chain as collateral, and many projects are also exploring how real economy financing activities can be combined with DeFi.
I would have thought it would be another 2-3 years before that happens, because AFTER all DeFi is suited to native digital assets, introducing physical assets too early, and not making the same mistake as the blind "blockchain +" that happened a few years ago. But given how fast DeFi is growing, and given that DeFi is in its third year of native digital assets this year, next year could be the start of a new phase, a new phase of integration with downchain assets.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia