Original title: "Understanding the Next Institution-level Blue Ocean with Aave and MFT as Examples: Fixed-Rate Lending"
Source: Block chain Institute
Borrowing is DeFi's core business, and three of the top five lockers in DeFi are lending products.
The main lending model in DeFi is the floating rate model, in which the borrowing rate and deposit rate fluctuate according to user demand. When the market demand for an asset increases, it will significantly increase the interest rate on borrowing an asset. The interest rate on borrowing depends not only on demand, but also on the total amount of assets in the pool, and the more assets you can borrow in the pool, the lower the interest rate on borrowing in general.

Currently, DeFi's borrowing agreements are based on a floating rate model. When borrowing is in high demand, borrowing rates are likely to rise sharply, but for many users, predictable financial spending may be a better option. Fixed-rate borrowing has already taken off in Aave.
Predictability is an important point for a lot of people. Unpredictability is often a risk, and the outcome can be good or bad. It's actually a gamble. Especially for traditional financial institutions, if they want to make large borrowings or deposits, but the result is unpredictable, this may become an important factor hindering the entry of institutions. Today I would like to talk about which platforms provide fixed loan products in the market and what are the differences in the models?
Aave is a well-known lending platform, one of the leading products of DeFi, with strong innovation, high visibility and a relatively large user group.
In addition to floating rate lending, Aave also provides fixed rate lending services, as shown in the figure below:
Fixed interest rates in Aave are not absolutely fixed, and may be rebalanced in extreme cases. The conditions for rebalancing are: when the average lending rate is below 25% and the utilization rate is above 95%, the interest rate will be rebalanced. The interest rate will change, but the odds of rebalancing are low.
In Aave we can see the relevant data for each asset, which includes the fixed interest rate borrowing share. At present, USDT, USDC and DAI account for 42.4%, 27.6% and 15.9% respectively in Aave V1. But if you take it from NBSP; For the V2 version, USDT, USDC, and NBSP; The proportion of DAI is as high as NBSP; 56.7%, 57.9% and 67.2%.
Aave fixed rate borrowings and floating rate borrowings use the same capital pool, which is no different from floating rate borrowings in essence, except that the interest rate paid no longer varies with the demand.
YIELD is another model of a fixed-rate borrowing agreement whose business logic relies on a Maker, with which it is deeply bound.
The overall process for borrowing DAI using YIELD is as follows:
Users can only lend DAI if they first deposit ETH. At present, ETH mortgage is only supported and DAI can only borrow this asset. The mortgage rate is the same as Maker, which is 150% at present. This corresponds to the first step in the flowchart.
Then the loan is made in the Borrow, which corresponds to the second and third steps in the flow chart.
In fact, both step 2 and Step 3 are hidden from the user. In these two steps, the user first coins yfDAI, that is, the blue token in the flowchart, and then the system automatically exchanges yfDAI into DAI for the user to achieve the third step.
The exchange of yfDAI and DAI is automatically conducted through the Pool, and users can also inject liquidity into the Pool to support the exchange, and will receive commission dividend if liquidity is provided.
There is a discount between yfDAI and DAI, such as 0.97:1, in which the discount is the interest paid by the user for borrowing money.
In the Lend interface, users can deposit DAI to get yfDAI with a discount, and the discount part is the yield to maturity. When purchasing, they can choose different terms, and the yield to maturity is different. After maturity, you can use yfDAI 1:1 exchange back to DAI.
For now, the overall YIELD data is mediocre, and the number of lockers is small.
The essence of the YIELD model is that a tradable zero-coupon bond with a maturity date is issued at a seigniorage, giving that bond the right to redeem the asset at maturity at a certain percentage.
Judging from the current fixed interest rate products in the market, most products use this pattern, and UMA and Mainframe are similar patterns. UMA hasn't tried much in this area. Mainframe is a Mainframe product that aims to provide fixed interest rate loans to users. Check out below.
Mainframe has not been online yet, and we have completed a round of audit. Mainframe is expected to be online in January next year, with MFT as token.
The structure of Mainframe is similar to YIELD, but very different. Look at the main drawing:
The Mainframe system consists of four parts: lender, borrower, guarantee pool and redemption pool. As can be seen from the figure above, the borrower casts yDAI through the collateral assets, which are sold to the lender, and the lender's DAI for payment is put into the redemption pool.
Within the guarantee pool, users can inject funds into the guarantee pool to earn clearing proceeds, and the proceeds would be injected into the guarantee pool in Mainframe, where the borrower's mortgage assets would be used to generate proceeds from lightning loans.
The biggest difference between Mainframe and YIELD is that yfDAI of YIELD is the system that automatically sells the Mainframe to the user via the pool, changed to DAI, and the Mainframe is sold to the lender.
A possible problem with selling directly to a lender is that when there is insufficient demand from the lender to buy, the transaction cannot be closed, and may require a substantial discount to close, and the borrower may pay higher borrowing costs. But we also see a disconnect between borrowers and lenders in YIELD, where borrowers get their money from pools of capital rather than lenders, and the size of the pool determines its size.
As you can see from the figure, the guarantee pool also supports cToken and aToken injection, which provides additional revenue streams for users of Compound and Aave platforms.
According to the latest news, since DAI's fluctuation caused the liquidation of $85 million in the last quotation, Mainframe decided to change the initial asset from ETH to WBTC, and change the target asset from DAI to USDC.
At present, DeFi products offering fixed interest rate are not many in the market, and the most mature one is Aave. In the current Market of Aave, fixed interest loan products have occupied a large share. Data shows that fixed interest loan products do have demand.
There is no essential difference between the fixed interest rate products of Aave and the mainstream floating interest rate products, except that the borrower pays a fixed interest rate.
YIELD's zero-coupon bond model, in which borrowers issue bonds at a premium, lenders buy them at a discount, swap them at maturity for a YIELD, and the bonds are tradable, transferable and more flexible in form. Fixed rate lending has not yet caught on, but in the future we will see the emergence and adoption of more fixed rate lending products, which will also clear some barriers for institutions to enter the market.
The resources
https://docs.yield.is/FAQ.htmlhttps://yield.is/YieldSpace.pdf
https://docs.aave.com/faq/borrowing
https://medium.com/aave/aave-borrowing-rates-upgraded-f6c8b27973a7
https://mainframe.com/static/Mainframe-Whitepaper-485f32bbcc4dc9308ec1ee36084757d8.pdf
https://blog.mainframe.com/compounds-dai-liquidation-event-and-it-s-impact-on-mainframe-84f9b826044f
Statement: This article is the author's independent opinion, does not represent the block chain institute (public number) position, does not constitute any investment opinions or suggestions.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia