header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

A Solution for Giving Liquidity to Staking

Read this article in 9 Minutes
The main mechanism to motivate PoS network participants to act in accordance with network rules is pledge, but since both pledge and liquidity provision need to lock the network Token, the liquidity of the PoS network will be affected by transactions.
Original title: "Paradigm丨Exploring the Possibility of Combining Staking and Liquidity Supply"
Original source: Paradigm


Introduction< /h3>


Proof of Stake (PoS) is becoming more accepted due to its higher efficiency, lower environmental impact and greater freedom to engineer reward systems Higher and higher, which was not possible before.


The primary mechanism for incentivizing PoS network participants to behave according to the network rules is staking. It means locking a certain amount of the network Token in the protocol as collateral to qualify for validating transactions and earning deposit rewards. Although this provides a solution to the waste of computing resources of the PoW mining mechanism, since both staking and liquidity provision need to lock the network Token, the liquidity of the PoS network will be affected by transactions.


This kind of transaction is especially obvious in PoS networks with a high proportion of pledged assets, because pledges and liquidity are "competing for resources", and liquidity is often in the Disadvantage, either due to the fact that the staking mechanism was not designed with this in mind, or the incentives are biased in favor of staking.


This is a big problem for the PoS network, because on the one hand, a higher pledge ratio improves the security of the network, but at the same time, the network Token liquidity is negatively affected. This can lead to significant slippage for users trying to buy/sell network tokens, along with token price volatility and poor price discovery.


It seems that in the field of PoS, there is a need for other pledge mechanism designs and incentive models. capital to align the interests of all participants and take into account the needs of the community.


In addition, this research report will focus on exploring different methods of combining staking with liquidity provision.


Delegation Credentials


One of the ways to realize the Tokenization of rights and interests is to propose through Chorus One certificate of entrustment. The mechanism is summarized in Figure 1.



Figure 1: Authorization Credentials


In this method, user 1 deposits their funds into verifier 1's fund pool, and receives a certificate token representing their rights and interests, and then can trade freely (for example, with user 2), and act as verifier 1's fund pool Claims on the winning asset.


This approach has several advantages.


The authorization certificate represents the pledged Token holder, not the exchange.


There may be incentives due to the replacement of reward distribution with claims on pool shares.


This may be the basis for a more advanced solution that works around some limitations.


At the same time, there are some limitations.


Tokens are specific to validators due to different reward and risk characteristics, so tokens are not interchangeable between different validator pools.


This in turn causes the overall liquidity to be split by different validator tokens. Liquidity is created for Tokenlize's stake, not for the underlying assets.


There does not appear to be much financial incentive to adopt this solution.


Projects working hard to implement liquidity staking and similar solutions.


StaFi

LiquidStake

RocketPool

Staker DAO

Ramp DeFi

Acala DeFi

Kira Network


Proof of Liquidity


In a typical PoS encrypted network, staking means taking the network Token out of circulation, thereby reducing liquidity.


It seems like it would be better if liquidity could grow with more stake, which is what the Proof-of-Liquidity method introduced by Joel Monegro from Placeholder aims to do. The main idea is to use liquidity pool tokens (e.g. from Balancer, Uniswap) as proof of liquidity. These LP Tokens can then be staked instead of Network Tokens - increasing staking in this way will ensure higher liquidity.



Figure 2: Liquidity Proof


Liquidity Pools act as automated market makers (AMMs) and maintain the ratio between the Tokens they contain. For example, if a pool contains 60% DAI and 40% ETH, an automated algorithm will maintain this ratio by buying and selling DAI/ETH. For the contribution to the liquidity pool, the user will receive a corresponding amount of LP Token from the liquidity pool. For example, if you deposit 20% worth of liquidity into the pool, you will get 20% of the LP Token, which can be exchanged for 20% of the entire pool share. Of course, since LP Token represents a claim on some assets in the pool, and the underlying assets are traded on decentralized exchanges (to maintain the set ratio between assets in the pool), LP Token may also be used as a liquidity proof of sex.


This method may solve the problem of consistent pledge and liquidity provision, but the pledge smart contract may need to be adjusted to allow pledge of LP Token. The staking reward can be based on the balance of the corresponding share of the network Token in the liquidity pool.


In addition to this, staking liquidity rules allow stakers to earn fees from transactions against Equity value fluctuations caused by other assets (such as DAI, ETH, etc.)


What needs to be considered is that this method is likely to require an audit of the liquidity pool and be eligible to provide liquidity proof for pledge.


Simple staking


xDAI is a layer2 zone on top of Ethereum Blockchain solution, where native token (xDai) is equivalent to DAI.


The xDai team has designed a unique incentive structure that encourages higher deposit amounts and longer deposit The rewards not received by depositors are given to liquidity providers. First, there is an annual cap of 15% on the agreement's total emissions.


The annual rate of return depends on 2 factors.


Supply-based: Depends on the ratio of pledged tokens to the total token supply.

Time-based: The length of time a certain deposit has been pledged. The longer the time, the higher the rate. The increase in the rate is non-linear, so after about 4 months of staking, the marginal increase in the rate starts to flatten out.


Each factor can result in an annual interest rate of up to 7.5%, and the sum of the interest rates derived from these two factors will determine the pledger's annual interest rate. The difference between the annual interest rate dedicated to stakers and the annual emission cap is distributed to liquidity providers on average every 7 days (the exact date is random). Table 1 is an example of such a return distribution.




In the example calculations below, we will assume that 25% of all network token supply is staked. If a staker deposits 1000 tokens into the staking contract for 28 days, his annual interest rate will be calculated as follows.


Supply based: 0.25 * 7.5% = 1.875% 

Time based APR: 28 days would correspond to 4.53 %.


For stakers


Yield365days = 1000Tokens * ( 4.53% + 1.875%)/100 = 64.05Tokens.

28-day output=64.05*28/365=4.91Tokens.


For Liquidity Providers


Yield365days = 1000Tokens * ( 15% - (4.53% + 1.875%))/100 = 85.95Tokens

Output for 28 days=85.95*28/365=6.59Token


In this special case, liquidity providers will share the resulting 6.59 Tokens according to their respective liquidity shares in the pool.


This approach effectively penalizes short-term stakers with low annual interest rates, while funneling the difference (and annual emission cap) to liquidity providers. It might be interesting for long-term pricers to allocate a portion of their pricing capital to liquidity providers, diversifying their pricing rewards.


By adopting a similar solution, crypto networks are likely to see an increase in the liquidity available in liquidity pools. At the same time, such a reward sharing model also seems to be a recognition and reward for those liquidity providers who bring value to the network by using their capital in the liquidity pool.


Comprehensive Solution


This section introduces the Comprehensive Solution and describes how the previously discussed Combine different methods.


Liquidity staking combined with liquidity provision


This solution is supported by  Inspired by the architecture of DeFiDollar 


The main idea revolves around abstracting part of the process from the user, And liquidity staking is handled through Ethereum smart contracts. An outline of the architecture can be seen in Figure 3.



Figure 3. Comprehensive solution: liquidity provided by liquid staking


This comprehensive solution has several components:



1. Main contract: smart contract, docking with users, coordinating all Tokens Flow/flow to liquidity pools, pledge contracts, and issue pledge certificate Tokens, and distribute cumulative rewards to token holders.


2. Pledge contract: A smart contract that allows depositing LP Token for pledge. The contract can then delegate the underlying network token in the provided LP stake to selected validators. All generated staking rewards will be forwarded to the main contract for distribution.


For users, this process is similar to the liquidity staking (delegated Token) scheme described above There is not much difference, that is, the user deposits a certain amount of tokens to the main contract and receives a token representing the pledged amount, which can then be exchanged with other users. These credential tokens will represent a requirement for the amount of deposit provided, as well as rewards generated through deposits and LP transaction fees.


The composite approach has several benefits that create greater flexibility.


Certificate Token holders can get rewards and LP transaction fees at the same time.

It is possible for the pledge contract to be implemented in a way that makes the generated certificate Token verifier agnostic, meaning that it is interchangeable regardless of the verifier.


Special considerations for this solution.


Staking LP Token: It is not a trivial matter to choose a mechanism from LP Token representation to calculate the number of pledged Tokens, because the underlying network Token The amount may change due to exchange rate fluctuations and may rise or fall significantly over time.


Delegate token amount to validators: One solution could be to distribute the amount equally among all validators, or w.r.t. the amount at risk for validators . In this way, the user will not be exposed to the risk of any specific verifier, and the resulting credential Token has nothing to do with the verifier.


Redefining fraud: Pledging LP Token means that in the event of fraud, LP Token will be destroyed instead of the basic network Token locked in the liquidity pool . This requires changing the punishment mechanism and potentially redefining punishment. One of the benefits is that, in this case, the penalty does not necessarily have to affect the liquidity supply.


Preliminary Conclusion


It seems that there are several Provides a combined approach that has the potential to be successful in practice. In fact, the xDai model is already live and has generated a relatively stable amount of liquidity on Uniswap of about $2.4 million at the time of writing this research report.


Given the uncomplicated nature of the solution and the consistency of liquidity staking and liquidity provisioning, the implementation of Proof of Liquidity also seems promising.


Finally, there is a large field of possible composite solutions that combine individual solutions in different ways, similar to the flows briefly discussed in the previous section A combination of property pledge and delegation credentials. Although there are some aspects that require deeper analysis, such as the fungibility of the resulting stake representations, and the development of a robust accounting mechanism for staking and rewards.


It is worth mentioning that implementing either solution has its own benefits and drawbacks, as well as less obvious positive and negative externalities that may potentially significantly impact network incentives, governance, and security. These effects must be carefully considered and modeled in conjunction with specific network conditions.


Further research could focus on the more practical side of these solutions, looking at the specific staking and governance mechanisms used. This will allow us to provide a contextual recommendation on which approach is the best solution combining staking and liquidity provisioning.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit