Original title: "Vitalik's latest speech: The Quadratic Fundraising Revolution of the Ethereum Foundation"
Original source: Dimensionl Tech
Speech: Vitalik Buterin
Editor: Rosa
On October 20, 2020, at the "Fifth Annual Conference of Network Society·Practical Wisdom Network" and "Tianwen: At the Dialogue of World Views event, Vitalik Buterin, the founder of Ethereum, delivered his latest speech on the theme of quadratic fundraising. In this speech, he introduced the one-and-a-half-year-long community experiment of the Ethereum Foundation: how to use quadratic fundraising to reduce human rule and better provide financial services for the community.
What is quadratic fundraising? It is a new financing mechanism for public goods. Through this mechanism, we can better allocate the funds used to fund public goods to where they are needed in a fair, democratic, and efficient manner.
Suppose you have a pool of money (or say a foundation) and now you want to use that money to fund projects that benefit the public. However, spending money is not easy, there are many projects in front of you, and you are not sure which one is worth supporting. So, you want to get input from the general public to help you make a judgment call; but with the public opinion, you still need to decide how to allocate the funds.
Simply subsidizing matching donations based on the number of supporters, or simply matching donations based on the amount of support, cannot fairly reflect the real needs of the public. For example, there are now 100 people in the community, 99 of them have one yuan, and the other has 10,000 yuan, and they use this money to set up a foundation. Now, 99 people want to donate $1 to Project A, because this project is in the interest of the general public, and the only rich man in the community wants to donate money to Project B. You can’t say that because this certain project is supported by 99% of the community members, allocate 99% of the money to Project A; The money is allocated to Project B. The former ignores the contribution of capital, while the latter ignores the interests of the community.
Aiming at this problem, the second-party fundraising can take into account both the number of people and the amount of money.
The distribution of the quadratic fundraising is done through a special formula. A project usually receives several donations. Then, we can first take the square root of each donation amount, then add these square roots, and finally square the result of this addition. The final result is all donations received by the project.
It can be proved mathematically that when there are more than one participant, the re-square of the sum of the square roots is greater than the arithmetic sum of the donation amount. Especially when there are many participants, the difference between the two will be huge. There must be a certain party to provide subsidies, and our capital pool will undertake this function.
There are two aspects of quadratic fundraising a very obvious benefit.
First of all, the more people who participate in the donation, the better the matching effect will be. For example, if there are n people in a project who each donate $1, then the amount obtained by the entire project is the square of n. This compensates for the tragedy of the commons. Straightforward and simple donations don't work well because each participant gets only nth of the value of this public good.
Secondly, small donations were well matched. The formula determines that every donation will be matched, but judging from the ratio, smaller donations are magnified by higher proportions. This largely eliminates the dominance of the rich, as people who donate just $1 get more matches than people who want to donate $10,000.
So, the second-party fundraising can take into account both the number of people and the amount of money.
There are many jobs facing the Ethereum community: we have a lot of software to write, a lot of research to do, and a lot of documentation to compile. In addition, we also need to provide education, law, translation and other public goods.
Currently, the Ethereum Foundation is the central to allocate funds to public goods in a standardized manner. The annual budget of the Ethereum Foundation is 30 million US dollars. It is trying to be a fair fund distribution organization, but the foundation is still controlled by a small group of people, sometimes because it only supports projects in limited fields. been criticized.
Instead of hiring a few people to focus on distributing funds, it is better to delegate this authority to the community. We now need a way to make fundraising and decision-making more diverse, more democratic, more open and inclusive, and quadratic fundraising is the perfect solution to this problem.
We decided to reduce the rule of man, but this does not mean throwing everything to programs and codes lazily, but requires continuous experimentation, improvement in practice, Iterate and refine new ideas.
Gitcoin is a quadratic fundraising experiment in the Ethereum community. In the beginning, the quadratic fundraising on Gitcoin only provided rewards for those who wrote code for new projects, but now the scope of rewards has been integrated into many subdivisions of the Ethereum ecosystem to support the development of various public products. operate. After one and a half years, Gitcoin has carried out 7 rounds of experiments, and since the third round of fundraising, the project has reached a very high level of application.
Funding source: most of the subsidy comes from ether Fang Foundation, others from Consensys and individual donors. In the recent seventh round, some DeFi projects also donated. The largest donation came from BalanceLabs, followed by Synthetix Optimism, ChainLink, Learn, and other investment funds or individuals. This shows that the quadratic fundraising mechanism is becoming more and more important, because more and more projects are willing to participate in the matching.
Negative Contributions: Experimental funding projects are mainly divided into two categories, one is technical projects and the other is media projects. Technical projects include Uniswap, Saliber, Dappnode, etc. In the media category are the Week In Ethereum News - a collection of news related to Ethereum, and the twitter account @antiprosynth. Technology projects are generally not controversial, but media projects are different. Some people think that media classes are of little value and may even have negative effects. So we came up with the idea of modifying the formula to allow people to express the opinion that they think an item has negative value.
So in the fifth round of fundraising, we experimented with negative donations. We experimented with a mechanism where people could not only donate money, but also take money from projects and redistribute it to other projects. In fact, the effect of this experimental mechanism is not good, and few people actually make a "negative contribution" in the end. People are frustrated with the possible consequences of this mechanism. They don't like to see people using this mechanism to hurt each other. In the sixth round of fundraising, we terminated this "negative contribution" setting. In fact, if we can achieve a good enough anonymity performance in the future, negative donations can also be tried again.
< br>
However, in the following experiments, the community's controversy over media projects seems to have disappeared. Seventh Among the top 10 projects with the most funds raised in the round, the media category is quite good. There are Bankless, Week in Ethereum News, and some decentralized financial tutorial projects, such as Ethereum Magicians, Zero Knowledge Podcast, etc. This It is a valuable podcast on Ethereum, which will explain zero-knowledge proof and zkSNARKs technology in depth. In addition, there are RadicalxChange Foundation, ETH Memes, @antiprosynth, etc.
Income stability: We hope that through quadratic fundraising, people can not only get a little extra money on top of the income they have already received, but also be able to rely entirely on quadratic fundraising as a living income and become a quadratic freelancer or. The problem is that the amount of money people get in different rounds is very volatile. So in the sixth round, we experimented with automatically rolling donations from previous rounds to the next, but it didn't actually make much difference in the end .However, we will continue to pay attention to this issue.
Collusion and fake accounts: in the fifth round We found collusion and fake accounts. Collusion and fake accounts are a tricky problem based on how quadratic fundraising works. For example, a user who splits donations among 50 accounts gets more matches than an honest Users get a much larger match. So in round 6, we also added phone verification to the identity verification round, which made it harder to make a lot of fake accounts. In round 7, we added decentralized identity verification. BrightID is a decentralized identity platform that creates a decentralized, social network-based mechanism to prove that certain accounts correspond to a single individual. In addition, we have also modified the formula, after the modification The formula for is called "bounded quadratic fundraising". To minimize the risk of cheating, match amounts are always divided by a number (at least ten). Overall, the mechanic works well.
First of all, the quadratic fundraising mechanism is useful. In a fair, democratic, and efficient manner, it better distributes the funds used to fund public goods to where they are needed. Current practice has proven that it leads to some good results.
Secondly, quadratic fundraising is not only efficient in allocating funds (such that The Ethereum Foundation does not have to allocate funds itself), and is creating a civilized and open community participation culture, many people have found a way to express their opinions, and they can talk about things they think are valuable in the Ethereum ecosystem. I think it's definitely useful for creating a really nice, collaborative ecosystem. Many people are very active in giving.
Overall, the effect is quite good.
Quadratic fundraising still needs improvement in some areas . We might wish for more ways to make it easier for people to determine which projects are worth contributing to and which ones aren't, allowing for more proxy delegation. We also want to continue to improve security, make fundraising results more inclusive, and expand the distribution of fundraising results, such as expanding communities and projects beyond Europe and the United States, such as Asia and Africa.
Another very important thing is that for any new community, quadratic Capital is a new thing, and it takes a few rounds of work to make it work better. In the Ethereum community, we conducted at least four or five rounds of experiments before people really understood how quadratic fundraising works. Therefore, although the effect of the first experiment or two is not obvious, we should still stick to it. It works even better if it's done every three months and very reliably for two or three years.
The Gitcoin Grants team is trying to apply quadratic fundraising to other scenarios. They did a "city stimulus" experiment, applying quadratic fundraising to businesses, such as some local companies in Denver and Colorado, and the results of the experiment look very good.
We learn more and more with each funding round .For example, in terms of what projects should be donated and the norms that community participation projects should have, we are becoming more and more aware of how to implement them correctly. In general, quadratic fundraising is still evolving and improving.
< p>Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia