Original title: "Why Optimism?"
Original source: Kain Warwick, founder of Synthetix
Original compilation: Rhythm 0x49
The emergence of DeFi has clearly shown that Ethereum needs to expand before reaching the ETH2.0 stage, At the same time, the DeFi ecosystem also needs to coordinate on a single scaling solution in order to maintain composability.
Thankfully, the market is very good at anticipating and addressing challenges like this, and there are many scaling technologies in the market today. Kain Warwick talked to a number of teams that are primarily working on scaling solutions, and after reviewing each of them, Kain believes Optimistic Ethereum is the scaling solution that is likely to reach consensus within the community.
This article will detail why Kain Warwick thinks so, and at the same time, will also address the concerns raised in the community about Optimistic Ethereum launch concerns. This article will also shed light on the governance process required to implement a variant of the Synthetix OVM on mainnet and under what circumstances another scaling technology could replace Optimistic Ethereum. The premise is to ensure that the community has the information it needs to reach a consensus on the migration of Synthetix to Optimistic Ethereum.
Suggested reading: A rollup-centric ethereum roadmap》
< /p>
There is no silver bullet for scaling, each approach requires significant trade-offs, each All of these expansion techniques require further trade-offs in the specific implementation. All solutions are played in the context of a high-stakes meta-coordination game, because it is not enough to choose the right design and tradeoffs, Optimistic must also optimize the solution that is most likely to be chosen by others . Therefore, scaling is not only a technical challenge, but also a social coordination game.
When Kain read "Optimistic Rollups" for the first time, Ethereum gas fees had not yet reached the red alert. So it seems like an elegant solution to both technical and social challenges. But Kain noticed that no matter which expansion option we choose, we need to bring other projects with us. The demo of Unipig with Uniswap gives Optimism a great opportunity to gain social consensus by combining one of the most high-profile projects on Ethereum. So Kain chose to be part of the solution not only to provide Optimism with feedback on how to solve DeFi-specific challenges, but also to help lead the social coordination within the community.

Synthetix has both advantages and disadvantages in Justin Moses, he established an out-and-out Rigorous engineering culture, but averse to things beyond cognitive abilities. This means that deploying Synthetix to L2 requires a delicate balance between minimizing risk and reducing changes to the codebase. During this transition period, there is zero chance of two different codebases running on L1 and L2 at the same time, and zero chance if the contract is rewritten in a different language.
Synthetix is one of the most complex smart contract suites on Ethereum, which increases the risk of having to maintain a separate codebase. This is what we discovered in our failed attempt to port the Havven network to EOS.
What happened: https://twitter.com/kaiynne/status/1166234541616316417?s=21
We also need to prove to the community that this technology is feasible and suitable for further investment. Then try to build consensus around that as a scaling solution. at present. The OVM transaction demo helps solidify this, and members of the community have already shown interest in this approach. While there are ample signs of community consensus on Optimistic Ethereum, it has yet to reach the point of SIP and testing.
But before talking about the specific trade-offs, Kain gave an overview of the current direction of smart contract execution expansion:
p>
1. Fast Blockchain, also known as "Ethereum Killer", is equivalent to an alternative L1, That is, the real fast blockchain;
2, ETH 2.0, maybe it will take 2032 to see it (joking);
3 , status channel/payment channel;
4, side chain;
5, Plasma (Omisego);
6, ZKrollups and other zero-knowledge solutions;
7, Optimistic Rollups (Optimistic Ethereum);
8, Lightning
Given the limitation of only maintaining a single code base during the transition period, most of the solutions above are considered excluded. Of course, many people claim to be compatible with EVM, but this is not as easy as it sounds, and even if Optimism has clearly exceeded the index under this specific constraint, it still requires small modifications to the contract. The following options can basically be ruled out: fast blockchains, ZKrollups, Lightning, state channels, and Plasma. Even with the rapid development of ZKrollups, all current versions require contracts to be rewritten in the new language. While this is not insurmountable, the maturity of the tooling around these languages is minimal, which greatly increases implementation risk.
There are indeed some fast blockchains that are EVM compatible, allowing the deployment of solidity contracts. Kain feels that there is not enough combat power to prove its viability, consensus mechanism and security.
The requirement for generalized computation is a second blow to state channels and Plasma for now.
In this way, the only options left are side chains and Optimistic Rollups. Sidechains like xDAI were first ruled out because of the need to keep assets worth hundreds of millions of dollars safe and potentially higher than that in the future.
After looking at all the alternatives, Optimistic Ethereum is currently the best trade-off, and the team’s positioning is also Great to follow their roadmap.
Optimism Ethereum is not live yet, so there is still a lot of execution risk, which is why no SIP was proposed to shut down Synthetix on L1. However, of all the solutions listed above, it has the right mix of tradeoffs and risks to justify the significant effort. To this end, Kain not only migrated Synthetix, but also migrated the rest of the DeFi projects. The reason for being one of the most mature DeFi protocols and taking the risk of early migration is that it will help Optimism Ethereum build consensus in the community. So far, the general acceptance of users is high, and no one has yet questioned why Optimism Ethereum is allocated resources.
However, as the transition to mainnet draws closer, three major concerns have been raised:
1. Fraud (raud proofs)
2. Centralization
p>
3. Withdrawal delays
The most critical technical issues is the problem of fraudulent state transitions. Some claim that the current implementation stage does not include fraud proofs, but in fact they do, but the automatically generated fraud submissions do not exist. But there are no automatically generated fraudulent submissions. The Optimism team chose a phased approach to test specific functions such as deposits and withdrawals before adding complexity. However, this could point this out more clearly in the testnet roadmap to avoid any confusion. Automated functionality for fraud proof submissions will appear before mainnet goes live. Without fully functional fraud proofs, mainnet funds may not be deposited into the Optimistic Ethereum network. I would personally vote against any SIP that proposes moving to a low security assurance network and recommend that others in the community do the same, which is one of the reasons why xDAI and other POA networks are considered unfeasible due to their lower security assurance .
Another major concern is that certain centralized applications of Optimistic Ethereum are perceived by users as decentralized. This is a wrong view. Over the past few years, the community has devoted enormous time and resources to continually decentralizing the protocol, but regressing for gas cost or throughput is a poor trade-off. But that's not the case here, the sequencer can significantly improve the user experience with minimal downsides.
These concerns arise from the sequencer's position within the Optimistic Ethereum network. It should be noted that the sequencer is not a necessary condition for accessing Optimistic Ethereum, it exists to improve the user experience. Most people also think that a single sequencer means a single point of failure, which would be bad. The downside is that we already have poor L1 UX. Obviously, falling back to L1 block times is not ideal, but there are many potential solutions, including a backup sequencer that can step in if the active sequencer fails or is attacked. All of these concerns are only temporary, as our goal remains to move towards a sequencer network as quickly as possible.
The last major obsession is about the effect of exit delay on cross-layer composability, in addition to the backup L1 scheme, Basically all scaling solutions will have such concerns. Latency means funds are locked in the L2 network.
There are currently several workarounds to solve this problem, one is provided by the validator network on both sides of the bridge Funds and provides instant withdrawals at risk for a fee. In fact Connext has already started work on this, more details can be found here (https://medium.com/connext/introducing-spacefold-d1c227a29d3) found. This doesn’t quite solve the composability problem, as funds still need to be confirmed on mainnet before another transaction can be initiated, but this is basically the root of all scaling solutions and cannot be escaped. Why is it critical to launch parallel versions of all major DeFi protocols on Optimistic Ethereum as soon as possible? This will enable almost all current DeFi transactions to take place on L2. Staking is also very likely to be fully migrated to L2, but transaction contracts will continue to run on both L1 and L2 in parallel.
It should be noted that before SIP is proposed to start Optimistic Ethereum mainnet migration, everything required for functional mainnet will be released, and Kain believes those conditions will be met in the coming months.
While synthetixDAO will likely be funded in the first few weeks after mainnet, we will need a SIP to Proportional protocol rewards are transferred to Optimistic Ethereum. Once protocol rewards are offloaded to this parallel network, adoption can be monitored, allowing the market to price the risk of migration. Presumably, Optimistic Ethereum will have lower yields given the reduced gas cost. But since most SNX holders postpone the migration, platform risk has the potential to generate higher yields.
Kain believes that sUSD issued for Optimistic Ethereum SNX is not too similar to sUSD issued for custody SNX. So the team made the decision to allow sUSD issuance against custodial SNX to maximize available collateral. SNX being transferred to L2 can be transferred back if necessary, meaning it should be considered valid collateral within the network, just with a different status than L1 SNX. Therefore, sUSD minted on L2 should be interchangeable with sUSD from L1. Of course, there are opposing points, including the complexity of implementation. The team has to decide which approach works best as a community.
If this transition works, synthetix has a pretty powerful lever to influence the rest of the migration: just Continue to transfer larger percentages of inflation rewards until 100% of inflation rewards are sent to L2 and all active SNX staking is on L2. By this time, support for the exchange of Synths on L1 and L2 must exist. Along the way, there are many interrelated dependencies that need to be managed.
Kain has publicly expressed his belief that Optimistic Ethereum will be the DeFi chain between now and the launch of ETH 2.0. If the rest of the Synthetix community finds this to be credible, a plan is needed to embrace the network and migrate away from L1 entirely. Of course, caution is required, but Synthetix Spartans has never shied away from asymmetric bets, and Kain believes it is one of the biggest.
To perform this work, the Synthetix team will need a series of SIPs and SCCPs, listing the intended changes and the rationale behind each release, this will ensure maximum transparency and accountability to all token holders.
Scale The race to modernize Ethereum and smart contract platforms in general is a multi-billion dollar project. There are many competing teams in this high-stakes game, so while a team has faith in Optimism, it is possible that another team will overtake them as well. If so, one must be prepared to shift focus to this competing scaling technology, especially if the social consensus in DeFi projects is found to shift from Optimistic Ethereum to another alternative.
The Synthetix team must prepare for the worst-case scenario: Optimistic Ethereum rollout fails or aborts. In this case, resources had to be quickly shifted to due diligence on other solutions, while efforts were also made to optimize existing L1 systems. In fact, the Synthetix team has already begun building contingencies, the rapid implementation of the Debt Snapshot SIP being one example. While it had been on hold for many months, the project was sped up to address L1's immediate gas fee issues.
Thankfully, we've been given a temporary respite, but it probably won't last long. If for any reason we fail to reach consensus on migrating to Optimistic Ethereum, we must come together as a community to choose an alternative scaling solution.
This The article aims to solve the problems raised by the community, but also hopes to explain how the Synthetix team got to where it is today, and the specific progress of the project throughout the migration process. Nothing is set in stone, and even SIPs that have been ratified and implemented can be overturned as circumstances change.
However, Kain firmly believes that if consensus on SIP is to be achieved, a commitment from the entire community is needed to help Build the most viable network to scale DeFi. Kain is confident that this will be achieved while Synthetix is running on a fully functional Optimistic Ethereum mainnet.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia