What does it mean that DAI now has 60% centralized assets?
Source: Encrypted Valley Live
In the past few days, there has been a flurry of discussion on Crypto Twitter about Mr Maker's collateral situation.
Some users point out that 40% of the collateral in Maker is now IOUs' items, not digital items like ETH. These are all centralised assets.
Related assets have become increasingly popular, namely USDC ($387 million), WBTC ($162 million), TUSD ($50 million), and PAX ($31 million). The IOUs issued on Ethereum represent U.S. bank dollars or BitGo hosted Bitcoins.

Snapshot: 25.09, 2020, 21:00 UTC
However, this figure understates the seriousness of the situation. Although centralised collateral accounts for 40 per cent of collateral, not all collateral has the same proportion. That ratio determines how much DAI is available for every dollar of collateral. Although they need $150 ETH or WBTC to produce 100 DAI, they only need $101 stability COINS to produce the same 100 DAI.
As a result, 61% of DAI are backed by these centralised assets, and 52% of those DAI come only from centralised stabilisers.

Snapshot: 25.09, 2020, 21:00 UTC
DAI's growth depends in part on the support of centralised asset managers. For example, Circle can freeze all USdcs in a Maker (but not a single CDP), in which case the system will cast more MKR to compensate. In this article, we will explain why it still makes sense to allow a stabilisation currency, but why it is almost certainly temporary.
MakerDAO is an unlicensed credit mechanism that allows users to generate DAI, or debt tokens, against various forms of collateral. It also priced the tokens at $1.00, a task that has been difficult for them over the past few months.

Source: Coinmetrics. IO, 7-day moving average
Like other assets, DAI's prices are the result of supply and demand. When it trades above $1.00, there is more demand to hold the token (long DAI) than to create and sell it (short DAI) from CDP.
There are two reasons for the explosion in demand: DAI's use in liquid mining and the general demand for stable assets in times of global uncertainty.
It was this persistent mismatch between supply and demand that put Mr Maker in the corner. At a high level, there are three mechanisms for stabilising the currency.
· Interest rate policy
· Open market business
· Collateral policy
We have made a detailed analysis of these three schemes in previous articles.
The point is that Mr Maker has reached its limits in interest-rate policy (it is reluctant to go below zero, which amounts to taking a long position and paying a short one). They are also reluctant to engage in any open market operations, presumably for regulatory reasons.
So the only tool left in their toolbox is collateral policy. To increase the supply of DAI, Maker must strike a balance between adding collateral to the system and what users want to borrow against. They are actively adding more untrusted forms of collateral, but until the recent surge in DeFi, there were few good collateral assets (LCR, COMP and LINK are about to join).
So, in the absence of faster due process on Ethereum and more types of untrusted collateral, the only way to meet DAI's explosive demand is to allow centralised assets, especially stabilisation COINS, into the system.
Their addition creates a fantastic arbitrage opportunity for traders. For example, you can get 100,000 DAI's with a $101,000 USDC -- because the mortgage rate is 101%. If DAI trades at $1.02, you can sell 100,000 DAI for a USDC of $102,000 -- a short-term arbitrage cycle.
Not only did you instantly make $1,000 on the trade here, but you also kept the option open, so that if DAI ever traded below $1.01, you could re-buy $101,000 of USDC in CDP for a profit.
There are three implications:
1. This arbitrage well explains the increase in the proportion of stabilization currency in Maker.
DAI can never exceed $1.01 again as long as the deposit rate of the stabilization currency reaches 101%. At any time above that price, arbitrageurs would convert more DAI and sell at an instant profit, pushing the price down.
3. When DAI returns to supply and demand, stabilizers will naturally disappear from the system.
The last point may need to be interpreted. When DAI returns to $1.00, arbitrageurs have two incentives to unwind stabilisation positions. First, there is a charge (currently 4%) for the stabilisation currency vault. Second, they will use DAI, which is now cheaper, to buy collateral again.
DAI could return to $1.00, and if it is because there is less demand to hold it, supply will naturally follow. Keep in mind that DAI is a coinage debt created by CDP. So when arbitrageurs go, DAI must be destroyed in the process. In addition, demand for DAI casting is likely to increase, at which point more supply will need to be created to meet market demand.
Among them, I'm very interested in the yETH V2 Vault, soon to be released, which generates DAI from ETH collateral and is used to extract CRV liquidity from Curve. If V1 Vault is any indication, this could generate billions of DAI.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia