Original title: "Will the crazy DEX 'Big Casino' cause big problems? Some mainstream DEX flaws have been exposed"
Original author: Five fireball Lord, vernacular block chain
Recently, the word "hot" can't be used to describe DeFi, or even "crazy".
Each DeFi related currency, in the last two months at least 3,5 times, more than 7,8 times, so that many mainstream currency and Taiwan dollar investors are envious of the red eyes, but dare not easily change positions, for fear of accidentally become chasing high catcher.
In DeFi, the track that attracts the most attention and captures the most value is definitely DEX. After all, leaving DEX and DeFi is just talk. Several DEX projects, whether with or without money, have become the representatives of the stars who are frequently searched in the circle recently. KNC, LRC, BNT, Uniswap, Balaner,Cruve...
The colloquial blockchain was published on June 1 with the title "Centralization of small platform continues to run", DEX activity "surge", or there may be a new dividend? The article introduces the rapid growth of DEX this year. If readers buy the leading currency mentioned in the article, they should have a 2-3 times profit now. In the last post, we said that "the overall trading share of DEX has increased fivefold from 0.1% at the beginning of the year to 0.6% in just a few months." Now a month later, the share of DEX relative to Cex has continued to grow rapidly to the critical level of 2%.

In particular, if you take into account the general brush behavior on CEX, the actual volume of DEX is estimated to be between 5% and 10% of CEX. At least, believe it or not, if you look at the dismal decline in traffic on CEX in June.

However, today's article is to pour a little cold water on the current over-hot DEX, to reduce the temperature. Although things are good, we should also make an all-round investigation, and see whether they are good or not? Since the previous article covered many of DEX's strengths, this one will focus on the weaknesses.
& have spent 01 & have spent & have spent Universal defect
1. The high thresholdYou have to be able to use a wallet, like Metamask, and know and be familiar with private keys, mnemonics and things like that, which alone can kill more than half the players in the industry, after all, a lot of people come in and just bet on dogs to get rich.
However, like any financial market, this world is not immune to the 80/20 rule. If you think you're the number two, you have to think about why, and what's your advantage over the other 80%. And if you can't get past this very basic threshold, it's hard to believe that you'll make 20% of your money.
2. Few currencies and poor depth: current DEX, largely concentrated in the etheric ecosystem, mainly ERC20 tokens, trading, cause like BTC, ZEC, these have their own main chain currencies are rarely traded in DEX, however the problem with cross chain technology, development, such as Ren not ERC20 mainstream currency slowly into DEX can pass across the chain, so should not what big problem in the future.
As for the depth, compared with the professional market makers of CEX, the former depth of DEX can be said to have been blown out. However, with the rise of concepts such as liquid mining and AMM automatic market makers, the depth of DEX has gradually increased, and the gap with CEX is getting smaller and smaller. In some currencies, IT can even surpass CEX, such as Cruve's stable currency exchange. So the depth of the problem, has been gradually solved.
3. The speed is slow: This is the biggest weakness of DEX, this is not a problem of DEX, it is more a problem of ETH, we can only hope Layer2 and ETH2.0. In Layer2, DeversiFi exchange using Validium and road printing DEX using Zk-rollup reached 2000+ TPS, and the trading speed was not much different from CEX. The only problem is that in terms of depth, there is no way to adopt AMM automatic market maker mechanism due to the order book mode, so to speak, there is speed without depth. At present, AMM is difficult to effectively combine with Layer2 due to its mechanism. Therefore, if DEX has both speed and depth, it may be possible to wait for ETH2.0 or Boca molding.
02 & have spent & have spent Several issues with the mainstream DEX
First, the Kyber
1. The release of good is exhausted-- Kyber is undoubtedly the market leader of DEX. Trading volume and destruction have been steadily increasing since last year. Recently, Kayalyst has been upgraded with a big move, and the model of pledge and DAO has been opened.
2. Less trading depth than Uniswap- the author encountered in Kyber twice liquidity pool depth is not enough, prohibited operating hints, to trade the two currencies are also relatively well-known currency, is nothing ono COINS, only 2 or 3 thousand dollars, also will appear this kind of hint is really an accident, the same type of currency, in Uniswap did not appear this problem, in addition to several major currencies, to say the Kyber Uniswap than the depth of the obvious.
And you can see that half of Kyber's transactions are in its own platform, stabilizers and ChainLink currencies.

3. Ultra-high P/E ratios-- KNC's p/E ratio has been estimated
KyberDAO's first round of voting was 65 percent fee allocation, 30 percent reserve, and 5 percent buyback destruction. With the listing of KNC futures, there will be a risk-free arbitrage portfolio. Annual fee income of approximately $2 million based on minimum annual transaction volume of $1 billion, distributable fee income of $1.3 million, minimum APR (annualized rate) =0.4% (equivalent to PE (P/E ratio) 250). The minimum APR=4% (equivalent to PE25) will be risk-free if the average daily turnover of COen is 2.8 billion USD in 2019.
Kyber's trading volume was $6 million the other day, which adds up to $2 billion for the full year. That's double the lowest APR, or the PE ratio of 125, which in traditional financial markets is the price/earnings ratio for ultra-fast growth companies.For Kyber to maintain that market cap, or price, it's going to take more than just staying ahead of the curve, it's going to take time to see if it's going to continue to grow.
Second, the Uniswap
Uniswap is definitely one of the hottest DEX in the world right now.
The reason is simple: it's a haven for onokazu COINS, and the liquidity provided by AMM has made the "flea market" that nobody wanted to visit suddenly popular. However, Uniswap has a lot of problems.
1. It's expensive
A lot of people buy things like SNX and Link on Kyber, and each transaction costs hundreds and thousands of dollars, and they pay $0.5-1.
However, when playing small currencies on Uniswap, people usually buy them for tens or hundreds of dollars due to high risks and insufficient pool depth. At this time, the poundage of 1 dollar is relatively large.
But more importantly, the ETH slightly a brick wall, your trade is likely to have 10 a few twenty minutes to clinch a deal, at that time, people will choose to accelerate, let trading a minutes to complete, and a speed, less is $0.5, more than 2 - $3, all, buy a small COINS, ETH throw slippage, but trading and accelerating costs accounted for 1%.
2. The deal fell through
Uniswap up and under a lot of small COINS on the price changes quickly, so when you buy or sell, could you Swap the moment, the price may be failure to change more than outside the scope of your slide set, you will fail this time, the failure probability is quite high, as far as I concerned, almost about 10-20% of the time.
What's more, due to the characteristics of DEX, even if the transaction fails, your Gas fee and acceleration fee will be deducted accordingly. Basically, if the transaction fails once, 2 or 3 dollars will be gone.
3. Fraud runs rampant
For those of you who play Uni, there's a lot of jargon.
Such asfishing-- Send a coin, wait for someone to buy, after receiving some ETH, directly withdraw the coin and ETH flow pool.
Such asdogs-- The fisherman's Project.
On Uniswap, because there is no threshold, anyone can issue a coin, almost at the rate of dozens of new COINS a day. Snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch, snitch.
"Uniswap COINS. Website. Icon. Twitter. Telegram group. White paper. Pap exchanges. One-stop service.
Third, BNT
Bancor is the ancestor of AMM, was virtually unknown before the DeFi craze, leading many to believe that AMM was invented by Uniswap, but the prospect of an upgrade to the V2 version sent BNT prices rocketing in the last two months.
V2 is to solve a very important problem in AMM, namely, the "volatile loss" of liquidity providers (for example, if you provide liquidity for THE ETH-DAI token pool, but if the ETH rises very fast, then the cost gain you get from providing liquidity for the token pool may not be as good as the gain from directly holding the ETH, which is the volatile loss).
This is the AMM pool is currently the most unfavorable for liquidity providers, and also one of the biggest obstacles to DEX development,So the V2 version of BNT is very exciting to look forward to, there are a lot of good design ideas in it, such as 1. 2. Update the proportion of token pool according to the price of the prediction machine, which is also the model of dynamic pool.
However, one of my DeFi friends has a point. She says that it is good to introduce external prices to make an effective range for prices, but there will be many challenges in practice. For example, if you have no trading pairs at all on a centralized trading platform, you have a chicken-and-egg problem. A bigger problem is that lP (liquid provider) is more likely to lose money when volatility is high, and there is counterparty risk.
Curve, Balancer
The current king of stable coin converters, and Uniswap, which one of the KOL's in the circle joked was Newtonian mechanics, and Balancer was relativistic.
The big problem, however, was that Uniswap hadn't made its money yet, and Balancer was launched first. Due to the small circulation, the price was inflated. In terms of full circulation, the market value was already $1 billion, even far beyond the leading KNC.
The problem now is that whale providers are throwing money at each pay call, causing the secondary brother players to complain, along the same path as the former Compound.
And Curve money is a given, and given the outperformance of the last two months, valuations are likely to be no lower than Balancer. Balancer has problems in the secondary market, and Curve might as well.
Moreover, the current DEX, moat is not high, AMM is where the profits are high LP will run, users naturally there is also a good trading experience, deep, where to trade, anyway, it is their own wallet, DEX as long as connect, there is no need to re-register the account +Kyc set. So today's leader, next year may not be you.
V. 0X, LRC, IDEX
0X is actually the most famous project in the DEX agreement, and the new Matcha aggregation trading platform is definitely all the looks in the DEX.

LRC needless to say, domestic, TPS2000+ DEX, speed leverage, V god himself praised for many times.
IDEX is probably the most familiar DEX, which has been used most before, and V2 version will be released recently. Optimistic Rollup greatly improves the transaction speed, and the token model has also been changed.
However, these three face the same dilemma, that is, this year's order book type of DEX, really not popular. This year, AMM is king...
Finally, the No.1 DEX aggregator, 1inch, is generally good because it aggregates traffic and helps you automatically find deals with the lowest slip-points.But it's really expensive to use, a transaction fee of 5-10 DOLLARS, the author of a friend once even spent 20 dollars, is really, do not bother.
03 & have spent & have spent summary
Of course, having said so many shortcomings, the author is still firmly optimistic about the development of DEX, and the future is bound to be an era when DEX and CEX are neck and neck. It's just not clear how DEX will be able to enjoy AMM's depth of fluidity while using Layer2's technology for acceleration before ETH2.0 sharking.
Text link:https://www.hellobtc.com
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia