Original title: "why might automated market makers lose money?"
Original post: Nate Hindman
JT, blue fox notes
Introduction: the decentralized market maker model is very popular, among which liquidity providers who provide liquidity for decentralized trading are the key players. Providing liquidity can earn fees or tokens, but the current design does not guarantee a return. Providing liquidity, relative to holding assets, can also lead to losses if the price deviation is large. If the value of the assets held rises quickly, the portfolio assets in the liquidity pool may be worth less than the portfolio assets held. Of course, there are those who argue that it cannot be seen as a loss and that it is essentially a matter of portfolio rebalancing. In any case, if you are a liquidity provider, you need to look at relative returns when providing liquidity to liquidity pools such as Uniswap and Balancer. In order to solve this problem, Bancor proposed to use the predictive machine to minimize price deviation and other measures. The writer is Nate Hindman, translated by "JT" of the blue fox notes community.
DeFi has a bad secret: users who provide liquidity to automatic market makers (AMM) may see their pledged tokens lose value, rather than simply holding them. Nevertheless, automated market maker (AMM) technology has come a long way.
This risk, known as "impermanent loss," prevents many mainstream and institutional users from providing liquidity. Because unlike most equity pledged products, AMM faces the risk that its returns could now be outweighed by a basic buy-and-hold strategy. (note: in staking economy, one is to have the exposure of the token, the other is to harvest more tokens)
Some users are completely unaware of this risk, while others have a vague understanding of the concept. But most people don't really understand how and why "impermanent losses" happen.
This article attempts to explain "impermanent losses" in simple terms and to explore potential ways to mitigate these losses through the design of AMM, which is more beneficial to liquidity providers than arbitragationists.
What is "impermanent loss"?
In simple terms, impermanence loss is the difference in value between holding tokens in the AMM and holding them in your own wallet.
This happens when the token price in the AMM diverges in any direction. The greater the deviation, the greater the impermanence loss.
Why are there impermanent losses?
As soon as the relative price of the token in the AMM returns to its original state, the loss disappears and you get 100% of the transaction fee. But that rarely happens. Often, volatile losses can become permanent, eating into your transaction fee income or resulting in negative returns for users.

Although LINK rose 700% (in dollar terms) last year, the return on providing LINK/ETH liquidity on Uniswap fell -52.67%.
Why did this happen?
To understand how volatile losses occur, we first need to understand how AMM pricing works and the role of arbitraggers. In its original form, AMM is separate from the external market. If the token price in the external market changes, AMM does not automatically adjust its price. It requires arbitrageurs to come in and buy undervalued assets or sell overvalued assets until AMM offers a price that matches the outside market.
In the process, arbitraggers extract profits from the pockets of liquidity providers, which can lead to volatile losses.
Consider, for example, an AMM pool with two ETH/DAI assets, each 50 percent. As follows: changes in ethereum prices provide arbitrageurs with opportunities at the expense of liquidity providers.

If you look at different price changes, you will find that even small changes in the price of ETH can result in impermanent losses to liquidity providers:

Clearly, this issue needs to be addressed if AMM is to be widely adopted by ordinary users and organizations.
If users expect to continuously monitor changes in the AMM and act on them, then liquidity reserves become a game only for senior traders.
Rather than designing a second layer of tools to monitor and manage AMM risks, you can mitigate volatile losses at the protocol level.
How to mitigate impermanence loss?
Fortunately, the encryption industry is struggling with volatile losses and making progress. This progress began with the realization that if we could minimize the price deviation of tokens in the AMM, we could reduce the risk of impermanent losses. If the relative prices between the tokens in the AMM remain the same (assuming that none of them fail), the liquidity provider takes less risk and is confident of making a profit through transaction fees.
As a result, AMM (or tokens that maintain a constant price ratio) with "mirror assets" has proved particularly resistant to volatile losses, attracting large amounts of liquidity because of its profit-optimized structure. These include the AMM on Uniswap (such as the sETH/ETH pool) and the stable currency AMM on the Curve (such as DAI/USDC/USDT/sUSD).
Because the price deviation between sETH and ETH is so small, sETH/ETH & NBSP; The impermanent losses of AMM are negligible.

Source: ZumZoom
However, AMM with mirror assets is essentially limited to stable or packaged and synthetic tokens. Moreover, when providing liquidity, users cannot maintain their long positions and must instead hold additional "reserve" assets. Bancor V2 will be launched in June 2020, which aims to address this issue by extending the concept of mirror asset AMM to volatile tokens.
By integrating with the Chainlink price predictor, Bancor V2 enables the creation of AMM with anchored liquid reserve assets, which holds the relative value of the tokens in the AMM constant. This new type of AMM effectively relies on a forecaster to balance prices, rather than relying solely on arbitrageurs. In this way, they eliminate the risk of volatile losses in stable and volatile tokens.
Importantly, the design also allows users to provide liquidity without having to hold additional packaged or synthetic assets. Instead, you can provide liquidity and still have 100% exposure to a single token in the AMM.

Bancor V2 supports the creation of AMM with anchored liquidity reserves. This type of AMM keeps the relative value of its reserve assets constant, eliminating the risk of volatile losses.
conclusion
Volatile losses are detrimental to AMM's commitment as a civilian liquidity reserve mechanism that supports passive market making by any user with potential capital.
Minimizing the risk of liquidity reserves and the benefits of having a single token exposure make AMM a more powerful and effective solution to drive decentralized liquidity.
Original link:https://mp.weixin.qq.com
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia