What you need to know before investing in DeFi tokens
Lucas Campbell, Fitzner Blockchain Consulting & DeFi Rate analyst
Unitimes_Charles
Annualized returns have begun to be one of the most effective metrics for valuing DeFi tokens and protocols. This article values the most commonly used DeFi tokens and protocols through annualized revenue.
The birth of cryptographic capital assets & Cash flow on the chain
The emergence of cash flow on the chain has given rise to a new asset class, crypto capital asset (local tokens of the DeFi protocol, such as MKR, SNT, ZRX, BNT, LEND, KNC, etc., which can bring returns to investors). The great thing about crypto-capital assets is that investors don't have to wait for an investment company's quarterly earnings report as they would in traditional financial markets. In contrast, for investors in cryptographic capital assets, the DeFi benefits are readily available and are updated approximately every 15 seconds.
Through an open and transparent mechanism to calculate the earnings of DeFi protocol, we can evaluate DeFi protocol by applying the PE Ratio, an ancient indicator used to evaluate capital assets in the traditional financial field. Put simply, the p/e ratio is a way of understanding how the market values an asset based on the income it generates (some tokens are simply not worth buying).
For example, Apple ($AAPL) was trading at 23.75 times earnings at the time of writing, which means investors are currently willing to pay $23.75 for every dollar the company earns. An asset with a high p/e ratio generally means that it is either overvalued or has high growth expectations. Conversely, a low p/e ratio for an asset means that it is either undervalued or has low expectations for future growth.
In the DeFi domain, we can use this exact same framework to see how some token protocols are valued relative to others.
While it may seem difficult to collect the cash flow data from the main DeFi protocol on its chain, fortunately, Token Terminal already provides available data about the current revenue status of the various DeFi protocols.
DeFi currency protocol
The following is a brief introduction to the DeFi protocol and its revenue mechanism to be included in this article:
0x - liquidity agreement, market fee will be distributed to ZRX token holder/liquidity provider.
An aave-money market agreement whereby a portion of the accumulated interest is distributed to LEND token holders by way of destruction.
Augur - derivatives agreement that predicts market transaction fees will be distributed to participating REP token holders.
Bancor - liquidity agreement where a portion of the transaction fee will be allocated to the BNT liquidity provider.
In a Compound money market agreement, a portion of the interest paid by the borrower is allocated to the insurance reserve.
DYdX * - a liquidity agreement for margin trading where transaction fees are distributed to the parent company of the agreement (there are no local tokens in the dYdX agreement).
Kyber-liquidity agreement whereby a portion of the transaction fee is distributed to KNC token holders either through destruction or as a share in the governance participation (based on Katalyst upgrade).
Maker - stability protocol. The stabilization fee generated by the outstanding DAI will be distributed to MKR holders by means of destruction (the stabilization fee is paid in MKR, and the destruction stabilization fee will bring MKR appreciation).
Nexus mutual-derivative agreements, which sell policies to earn premiums;
Synthetix - derivatives agreement. The transaction fee will be distributed to the SNX hypothecate issuing the synthetic asset.
Uniswap* - liquidity protocol. Transaction fees will be allocated to the liquidity provider of Uniswap.
Note: the DeFi protocol with * is the DeFi protocol that does not issue local tokens or the public cannot access its local tokens.
DeFi protocol annualized benefit analysis
& have spent
各 DeFi 协议自 2019 年以来的 30 天平均年化收益趋势,图源:Token Terminal
Benefits of the Maker (MKR) protocol
In 2019, it is clear that the Maker protocol has a dominant role in the annualized returns of its MKR tokens. The simple design of Dai (now Sai), a single mortgage, allowed the agreement to generate very handsome returns for MKR token holders, even by today's standards.
In the case of single-mortgage Dai, the Maker agreement destroys MKR tokens by collecting the accumulated interest generated by outstanding Dai (i.e., the stabilization fee that users pay when borrowing Dai), effectively providing MKR token holders with significant cash flow during the first year of the agreement's availability.
However, the introduction of Dai with multiple mortgages has brought about a new trend. Most of the revenue generated by the agreement (the stabilization fee) will be distributed to Dai holders through the Dai deposit rate (DSR), rather than to MKR holders. Thus, the difference between the DSR and the stabilization fee is the "net profit" of the agreement.
Although the margins on the Maker deal have been squeezed by the upgrade of mdai, that is not the worst part. In response to the "black Thursday" of March 12, the current stabilization fee for all supporting assets (ETH, BAT, USDC) was reduced to 0% (note: the current user mortgage ETH, BAT, and USDC Dai is required to pay 0%). As a result, the expected annualized return from the Maker agreement is at its lowest level since its inception.
Benefits of the Synthetix (SNX) protocol
While Maker has dominated in the past, the Synthetix agreement rose to prominence in the second half of 2019. Synthetix, a derivatives agreement that led the DeFi industry in annualized earnings, was soon found to have issues with pre-emption.
Synthetix encounter, beat traders (front - runners) by tracking (or sometimes manipulate) the price of an asset in the spot market, and then the machine update price predictions on Synthetix trading before the asset (note: Synthetix predicted by chain machine feed price, price updates may be delay), effectively created significant arbitrage opportunities, while SNX tokens, pledge will pay for it. In the end, such front-running attacks plagued the Synthetix network, yielding a disproportionate benefit to the derivatives agreement.
Fortunately, the issue of front-running has been largely suppressed, and Synthetix is back on track to deliver accurate earnings.
Benefits of Kyber (KNC) protocol
With Maker and Synthetix currently showing tight earnings, dYdX and Kyber networks are currently leading the DeFi space.
The on-chain mobility protocol of Kyber Network has developed rapidly and has shown a prominent position in the DeFi ecosystem. In march alone, Kyber facilitated nearly $200 million in transactions at about 13,000 individual addresses. As a result, the Kyber transactions have translated into significant revenue for KNC token holders -- an annualized revenue of approximately $2.89 million based on their April transactions. See below:
& have spent & have spent
& have spent The annualized revenue of each DeFi protocol is expected to be generated in April. Photo source: TokenTerminal & have spent
While the chart above shows Synthetix as the leader in April earnings, this is largely incorrect, as the Synthetix agreement continued to address the issue of front-running deals until mid-april.
In the first 15 days of April, the Synthetix agreement averaged annual revenue of about $6 million; Expected earnings for the second half of April are about $640,000, an order of magnitude lower than the previous half of the month. Despite the drop in revenue, Synthetix appears to have resolved the front-running issue for now, as the agreement releases more accurate usage and earnings.
The benefits of the dYdX protocol
The second biggest gainer in April was dYdX, a platform for margin trading and derivatives (see chart). With the dYdX, users can trade on margin, borrow or lend out a range of backed assets. The dYdX team recently announced the BTC perpetual contract, a derivative that allows users to permanently go long and short.
More interesting about dYdX is that while the team maintains and builds products based on the protocol, the transaction fees generated are collected by the underlying company, rather than a decentralized ecosystem of token holders. Thus, although dYdX runs a user-driven unmanaged trading platform, it is actually closer to being a centralized trading platform than the DeFi protocol because the revenue generated from transaction fees flows directly to its parent company.
Benefits of the Uniswap protocol
In terms of decentralized trading platform (DEX), Uniswap is one of the major contributors to DeFi's revenue. As of April, the permission-free liquidity agreement is expected to generate revenue of about $1 million (that is, transaction fees paid to the liquidity provider). Although Uniswap has fallen since its peak of $1.75 million in early march, the agreement's expected revenue is still up 110 percent year-to-date.
& have spent & have spent
& have spent The percentage trend of the revenue generated by each DeFi protocol as a percentage of the total revenue in the DeFi domain. Photo source: TokenTerminal & have spent
In addition, the upcoming Uniswap V2 will introduce an agreement charging mechanism, namely liquidity providers to obtain cost will be reduced from 0.30% to 0.25%, the remaining 0.05% will be directly through a process of decentralized mechanism to determine its distribution (note: this part of the expenses will be allocated to the maintenance of the contributors of this agreement, including Uniswap development team, etc.). This seems to strongly imply that Uniswap will issue local governance tokens.
The rise of governance tokens coincides with the future development of Uniswap local tokens. It will not only provide an exit opportunity for former Uniswap investors, but will also provide a long-term sustainable model for the agreement. Having said that, the Uniswap V2 announcement blog post does not directly state that there will be Uniswap governance tokens, and it is not impossible that the protocol will be governed entirely by the liquidity provider and its liquidity pool tokens.
Benefits of the Aave protocol
The last notable tool in the DeFi domain is Aave (decentralized lending protocol without local tokens), which is one of the newer currency market protocols in the DeFi domain.
According to DeFi Pulse, Aave ranks fifth with $42 million of locked assets, so the deal quickly became a favorite among DeFi community fans. In April alone, loan agreement Aave's annualized revenue rose from $314,000 to $746,000, a 137% increase in less than 30 days.
P/e ratio analysis of DeFi protocol
Now that we have seen how some DeFi protocols accumulate in terms of revenue, let's apply them to the token protocols and see how these DeFi tokens are valued relative to the revenue they generate (note: Compound, dYdX, and Uniswap do not have native tokens and are therefore not included in the chart below).
& have spent & have spent
& have spent A low p/e ratio means it is cheaper to buy assets with a unit interest rate. Data as of May 1, 2020 & NBSP; & have spent
Compared to other DeFi token protocols, 0x and Augur have very high p/e ratios, currently at 6,935 and 16,761, respectively. These figures are largely invisible in traditional financial markets and may indicate that investors have high growth expectations for liquidity protocol 0x and derivatives protocol Augur.
On the other hand, Bancor, Aave and Kyber are currently trading at low multiples in DeFi. Although Bancor has the lowest p/e ratio (56 times), the average expected earnings from this liquidity agreement are approximately $327,000, and its local token BNT has a market capitalization of $13.6 million (its market capitalization is the lowest in DeFi).
The next lowest is Aave, at 74. In addition, Kyber's p/e ratio has risen considerably since our last report, to 80 times.
As a guide, a p/e ratio of 50-100 is fairly normal for many high-growth tech stocks in the traditional financial world. Netflix, for example, currently trades at 86 times earnings. Therefore, given that a small number of DeFi protocols trade at a p/e ratio below 100, this may mean that the valuation of DeFi tokens based on earnings is relatively fair, and that it is a good option for potential investors.
Price performance of DeFi tokens
By looking at DeFi token price performance so far this year, the DeFi tokens included in our analysis are up an average of 43%. Two of the clear winners are Aave (LEND) and Kyber (KNC).
With the upcoming Katalyst upgrade, Kyber Network has seen significant growth in volume and earnings, driving the bull market in KNC tokens this year. The dollar value of KNC tokens has risen 213% since January.
Aave, which changed its name to EthLend in January, is a close second, with its LEND token up 135% so far this year. Much of the increase in the price of Aave tokens can be attributed to the protocol's rise in DeFi. The money market agreement has grown dramatically, locking in a value of $50 million in just a few months.
On the other hand, the worst performers so far this year are Maker (MKR) and Synthetix (SNX), which are down 22.41% and 36.56% respectively in value for DeFi protocol tokens.
In fact, prior to black Thursday, Maker's local-governance token MKR performed quite well, with annual growth reaching a peak of 47.61% by the end of February. However, MKR's price eventually fell sharply after "black Thursday" and the subsequent debt auction diluted MKR token holders, for which Maker issued 20,980mkr. While the Maker system has been hit hard by the volatility of the pandemic, MKR has begun a slow recovery, up about 74% since hitting $200 at the end of march.
& have spent & have spent
& have spent Price performance of each major DeFi token, source: TokenTerminal ; & have spent
In Synthetix's case, SNX's revisions are likely to depend on the resolution of its front-running issues and a more accurate description of the benefits of the agreement. As a result, SNX tokens have fallen sharply since peaking in late 2019.
Aave and Kyber were the winners, Maker and Synthetix were the losers, while 0x and Augur, two tokens with astronomical p/e ratios, remained stable: Augur's REP token has performed well, up 16.64% so far this year; The 0x token ZRX has a similar performance, up nearly 10% so far this year.
Is the yield of DeFi protocol related to the token price?
After understanding the benefits of these DeFi protocols and the price performance of the underlying tokens, we can now see if there is a correlation by plotting the difference between the change in price and the change in the annualized benefits of the protocol.
See below:
& have spent & have spent
& have spent The price performance of DeFi tokens relative to the change in DeFi protocol revenue
The growth in Kyber and Aave annualized earnings seems to have translated into positive trends in their token price performance.
However, we cannot be 100% sure whether the token price is driving the DeFi protocol revenue growth or the revenue growth is driving the price. Intuitively, as protocol usage increases, so should the revenue generated by the protocol, which means that the underlying tokens are more valuable to potential investors. And vice versa.
Cryptographic assets are a highly nascent and immature asset class, and the cryptographic market is essentially inefficient. As a result, many cryptographic asset valuations are driven by speculation, and it is entirely possible that the agreements will increase in value based on investor speculation, which will lead to more users flooding into the ecosystem, driving the use of more protocols and thus higher protocol yields. Unlikely as it may seem, we live in the wild west of the unknown.
Although causality is not guaranteed, it is clear that there is a clear correlation between the benefits of the agreement and the price of the token. We will continue to explore this relationship in future articles.
Write in the last
We are slowly beginning to understand cryptographic assets.
The combination of open and transparent cash flow on the chain and token protocol creates a new asset -- cryptographic capital asset. The emerging nature of this new asset class allows us to apply familiar valuation frameworks common to traditional finance.
Many DeFi tokens allow holders to take a share of the cash flow generated by the growth of their ecosystem.
Whether by participating in protocol governance, being a provider of protocol liquidity, or simply holding such tokens, holding these DeFi tokens represents an economic right to the benefits of the agreement, which enables us to view these assets within the traditional capital asset framework.
While nearly $1 billion of value is currently locked into DeFi, the industry as a whole still shows marginal gains. Overall, ethereum's DeFi currency protocol generates a combined annualized revenue of less than $10 million, a tiny number even in the broader cryptographic ecosystem.
However, the path to de-banking is not accomplished by locking in just $1 billion of value, but hundreds or even tens of thousands of dollars.
We have a long way to go before this new cryptographic capital asset and the entire DeFi domain can grow. Although we have learned a lot so far, there is still much to discover! & have spent & have spent
Source:https://mp.weixin.qq.com
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia