Original Title: "Why Solana Needs Network Extensions Instead of Layer 2 Solutions?"
Original Authors: Dr. Yugart Song, Stepan Soin, Qinwen Wang, Lollipop Builders
The rapid development of blockchain technology has seen Ethereum (EVM) and Solana (SVM) emerge as two dominant design philosophies, each taking a leading position in its respective domain. Historically, Ethereum has led the Total Value Locked (TVL) of the EVM chain with its unique philosophy and approach, while Solana has dominated among non-EVM chains. However, as activity has grown and new chains have emerged, Ethereum has started ceding its dominance to faster EVM chains and has turned to Layer 2 (L2) scaling solutions. In contrast, Solana's monolithic architecture has avoided this split through unique technical innovations and significant performance reserves, but at the cost of requiring higher bandwidth and speed.
Simultaneously, the concept of Rollups has provided dApps with a significant opportunity: the creation of customizable execution environments. However, this has led to an interesting phenomenon where L2s have fragmented Ethereum's liquidity and user base, with L2/L3 application chains further exacerbating this split. While Solana has adhered to the idea of a monolithic ecosystem, the benefits of providing a customizable environment for different use cases are undeniable.
From 2017's Plasma to Optimistic and zk-rollups, Ethereum's scaling journey clearly illustrates the necessity of addressing scalability issues. However, it is worth noting that a portion of Ethereum's L2 TVL is backed by bridged ETH, which remains on L1.
Nevertheless, these scaling solutions have also exposed a significant risk—the fragmentation effect on liquidity and users, known in the blockchain space as the "vampire effect." The significant drop in Ethereum's fee income post-implementation of EIP-4844 is a testament to this. Analysts including Justin Bons of Cyber Capital have pointed out that Ethereum's fee growth is being cannibalized by L2 solutions.

Figure 1: ETH Supply Dynamics Source: ultrasound.money
This indicates that when users exit L1, the remaining fees on L1 decrease significantly, leading to a decrease in the burn rate. This should have been clear from the beginning. Now, usage and revenue are being captured by L2 aimed at rent-seeking! This is exactly what makes them greedy, as only a small portion of the fee returns to L1, with the rest being retained by commercial entities. At the same time, these entities have also lobbied to maintain the limited block space of ETH L1. A chart published by Unchained Pod even shows that for every $1 fee paid on Optimism (OP) L1, $300 in revenue can be earned:

Figure 2: Revenue Earned by L2 for Every $1 Paid in L1 Fee Source: GrowThePie
Therefore, it is clear that L2 exhibits a "vampiric effect" on L1's transaction activity and economic attractiveness. Turning to application-specific chains (Appchains) independent of Ethereum further exacerbates this situation.
This view is supported by Anatoly Yakovenko, who posted the following on Twitter: "If the Solana ecosystem to support all user transactions breaks L1 execution optimizations for a generalized L2 'arb/op' stack, it will result in a parasitic effect on Solana's mainnet. This is not difficult to understand. When L2 gets more priority transactions from the base layer rather than new ones, they become parasitic. Because the mainnet will continue to maximize its throughput, 'L2' or any other SVM will find it challenging to compete on price. User fees should not be cheaper than the mainnet."
Kyle Samani, Managing Partner at Multicoin Capital, also expressed a similar view, writing: "Anything that could have happened on L1 but happens off L1 is parasitic by definition. Therefore, I am not interested in EVM/SVM rollups. They are effectively no different from L1. I am very skeptical that these copy-paste L2s will succeed on Solana, as L1 is already good enough."
In this context, Solana's core approach to preserving network properties by maintaining a monolithic architecture and a unified ecosystem concept appears very attractive.
But how can we avoid a situation similar to Ethereum's L2? Let's delve into it.
Compared to traditional blockchain systems designed around the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM), the Solana blockchain presents a brand-new architecture.
Solana adopts Proof of Stake (PoS) as a mechanism to prevent Sybil attacks, while also introducing one of its core innovations—the Proof of History (PoH) algorithm. PoH is a verifiable delay function (VDF) used to order and timestamp transactions propagated over the network. Furthermore, Solana distinguishes itself through the use of high-performance hardware, a transaction forwarding protocol without a mempool (Gulf Stream), support for parallel processing with Sealevel, and a design different from the traditional blockchain account model (similar to a file system in the Linux operating system).
Solana follows a monolithic design philosophy, achieving significantly higher scalability, speed, and throughput through its unique consensus mechanism, technological innovations, and continuous architectural optimizations.
Solana also benefits from a strong developer community: over 2500 developers are actively involved. This has driven significant growth for Solana. Solana's Total Value Locked (TVL) has grown from $210 million in 2023 to its current $7.73 billion in 2024, almost a 35x increase. Compared to November 2022, Solana DEX trading volume has grown by 200-300 times year over year, and since the summer of 2023, Daily Active Users (DAU) have grown 5 times. As of November 14, 2024, Solana's transaction volume is more than 4 times that of Ethereum. The number of active wallets continues to grow, reaching a peak of 9.4 million active users on October 22, 2024.

Figure 3: Solana DEX Trading Volume and Active Wallet Dynamics Source: Dune, Artemis
Therefore, Solana is a robust ecosystem with a large and active user and developer community that has experienced exponential growth in user base and activity. This growth trajectory highlights Solana's importance as a leading non-EVM chain, especially in its dynamic expansion.

Figure 4: Non-EVM Blockchain TVL Comparison. Source: DefiLlama
Decentralized Applications (dApps) on Solana have significantly improved their functionality by enhancing adoption and user-friendliness. It is evident that Solana is becoming a super system with outstanding characteristics. However, some applications, such as Zeta Market, plan to launch their own instance (L2) to achieve the same goal.
One particularly notable fact is SVM's performance in an isolated environment. This has been well demonstrated through applications like Pyth Net, Cube Exchange, which leverage SVM to support the application chain, also referred to as Solana Permissioned Environments (SPEs) within the Solana ecosystem.
Despite the use case for standalone "specific application" SVM chains, which do not significantly differ from a regular Solana client, we believe that the value of native Solana Layer 2 extensions (vanilla Solana forks) is limited. This approach could still lead to Ethereum-like fragmentation.
Evidently, Solana needs a distinct approach to avoid compromising the characteristics of its monolithic architecture. This is why Lollipop has developed Lollipop Network Extensions, which will significantly alter the landscape of the Solana ecosystem.
These factors have prompted the Solana community to discuss the necessity of offloading certain computational tasks elsewhere. Extensions are not a new concept for Solana. As early as 2022, Token Extensions emerged, providing new features such as Confidential transfers, Transfer hooks, Metadata pointer, among others.
Therefore, in the effort to enhance Solana's functionality and expand dApps, proposing the concept of "Network Extensions (NE)" makes logical sense. In addition to enhancing Solana's capabilities through extensions, Network Extensions (NE) also introduce modular elements to the ecosystem — different environments in NE can be customized according to specific needs and shared across multiple dApps and protocols.
Based on insights and discussions within the Solana ecosystem, we have identified several key principles that should define Network Extension (NE) architecture and functionality. These principles are designed to ensure seamless integration with the Solana network while maintaining its core architectural advantages:
· Avoid "liquidity fragmentation"
· Avoid "user base fragmentation"
· For users, the interactive experience is the same as when using Solana directly
· Unified technology stack
· Network Extension (NE) directly sends transactions to Solana validation nodes
For NE, Solana serves as a true settlement layer where fund movement occurs at that level. The network extension acts as a true execution layer that does not fragment from the main chain and interacts directly with accounts and programs at that layer.

Figure 5: Lollipop Network Extension (NE) Simplified Flowchart
These characteristics differentiate Network Extension (NE) from rollups, sidechains, shards, various L2 variants, application chains, and other scaling solutions. Compared to similar solutions, Lollipop aims to develop a technical framework for Network Extension (NE) that enables developers, consumers, and end users to seamlessly interact directly with Solana's liquidity and user base at the Solana level.
Currently, Lollipop is the first solution that provides direct connectivity to the Solana mainnet without causing liquidity or user fragmentation.
Lollipop's native environment can serve as the foundation for new products and support the migration of existing dApps without disconnecting from the Solana ecosystem and liquidity. For existing dApps, this will enhance their speed, stability, and expand their functionality.

Figure 6: Comparison of Solana's Existing Solutions
Key differences from L2, shards, and sidechains:
· L2: L2 aggregates transactions and sends their proofs to L1. Execution and settlement actually occur within the rollup, while L1 (such as Ethereum or Solana) is used for proof validation. Network Extension (NE) directly sends transactions to Solana's validation nodes and programs.
· Sidechain: A sidechain has no direct connection to the main chain. While a sidechain can anchor data to the main chain, the gap between ecosystems is significantly larger compared to L1 and L2. In fact, a sidechain is a completely independent network.
· Subnet: In the current implementation, a subnet may establish an independent ecosystem within a subchain, with its liquidity and users concentrated in a different space.
The projects most aligned with the network extension concept in the Solana ecosystem are Getcode and Sonic SVM (based on HyperGrid). However, Getcode only serves as a fund transfer layer, similar to Bitcoin's Lightning Network, and does not support the deployment of complex environments. Although Sonic achieves a 10-millisecond latency and can delegate programs deployed on Solana to its instance, it is more focused on the gaming sector and lacks the flexibility and customizability envisioned by Lollipop's goals.
Network Extension (NE) collaborates directly with Solana liquidity, avoiding the formation of different chains, spaces, and communities.
Network Extension (NE) can provide infrastructure solutions for Solana and its decentralized applications (dApps), supporting the operation of these dApps themselves. This concept is somewhat similar to the idea of appchains and L2. Many dApps are transitioning to their dedicated instances to improve performance, scalability, and user experience.
In L2, there are many such solutions: OP-Stack, Arbitrum Orbit, Polygon CDK, StarkEX, zkSync Era, Termina, and more. These toolkits have enabled many L2 projects to launch successfully, significantly advancing the scalability and usability of blockchain networks.
However, as we have seen earlier, the current layered model and fragmented environment approach are not suitable for Solana's monolithic architecture.
The above cases and narratives reflect a broader trend: decentralized applications (dApps) are creating independent instances. This allows them to optimize operations and functionalities to provide better services to users. These applications can be DeFi dApps, games, validation and identification protocols, privacy protocols, institutional and enterprise solutions, etc. These environments are mainly built on different rollup implementations.
As mentioned earlier, rollups have a vampire effect on the underlying chain. Lollipop aims to address this issue while introducing modularity to Solana without disrupting its monolithic architecture.
The following is the revolutionary significance of Network Extensions (NE) for Solana:
· Custom Execution Logic: Whether developers need unique governance rules, specific reward structures, or a decentralized computing environment, NE can meet all detailed requirements. Developers can deploy modified SVM instances in NE, adjust parameters such as latency, block time, block size, etc., which may enable the running instance to have real-time performance and create other currently less obvious use cases.
· Direct Settlement: Despite NE running independently, all transactions are still settled directly on Solana. This maintains liquidity and user flow within the blockchain unified, without causing fragmentation or vampire effects.
· Economic Flexibility: NE leverages Solana's efficiency to introduce innovative economic models. For example, dApp users may enjoy a gas-free economic model through a subscription-based model.
· Frictionless Flexibility: Unlike L2, NE does not create isolated spaces. Everything remains unified—think of it as similar to Token Extensions.
· Seamless UI/UX for End Users: Unlike subnets or L2/L3 solutions, NE provides a superior user experience. Users do not need to switch networks, use cross-chain technologies, or worry about address issues but can interact directly with Solana.
· Reduced Program Deployment Costs: Currently, if a developer needs to deploy a standalone program on Solana and has few dependencies on other programs, they would need to pay 1-3 SOL or more in deployment fees, depending on the program's size. Through delegation and proxies, NE offers the possibility of deploying multi-component complex programs in different environments, which is much cheaper than deploying directly on Solana.
NE may also cover use cases related to AVS (Automated Verification Systems) based on a re-staking protocol. These use cases include decentralized oracles, co-processors, verifiable computation, decentralized ordering, fast finality, etc. All of these benefit from the adaptability of the NE environment.
Another key scenario for NE is the ability to create a gas-free economic system within an environment similar to EVM Account Abstraction. This is very useful for protocols that can generate a large number of transactions—such as high-frequency trading (HFT), gaming, rebalancing protocols, dynamic pools with concentrated liquidity, and more.
Therefore, Lollipop has proposed the following key directions for NE's use case:
1. Gaming: Imagine a game with no Gas fees—players enjoy a seamless experience, and developers adopt a subscription-based model for stable revenue. This brings a new way of developing Web3 components for games—interacting with wallets or markets without leaving the game environment.
2. DeFi: Build a high-frequency trading platform using session-based fees instead of transaction-based Gas fees, making transactions faster and cheaper. A new logic is formed through an off-chain order book and settlement design. The higher execution speed enables protocols to use higher leverage.
3. AI Models: Settle each transaction directly on Solana while deploying compute-intensive AI environments using GPUs. This can be applied to various scenarios: security assessments, routing, arbitrage, model implementations for various intents, and more.
4. Enterprise Solutions: Tailor environments for enterprise and institutional clients with strict management, policy, compliance, encryption, and governance rules.
5. PayFi: Provide a programmable environment for complex financial challenges such as supply chain finance, cross-border payments, company cards supported by digital assets, credit markets, and more.
6. Decentralized Computing: Enable advanced decentralized GPU or TEE (Trusted Execution Environment) computing—applicable to cryptography, coprocessors, AI models, or data-intensive tasks.
7. Trusted Environment: Deploy trusted environments for use cases such as oracles, decentralized storage (DAS/DAC), verification systems, decentralized physical infrastructure networks (DePin), and more.
Therefore, the main task of the Lollipop team is to: Ensure that dApps and protocols can create a customized environment within the Solana ecosystem and interact directly with Solana. In other words, conceptually, the execution seems to occur off-chain in a Network Extension operation, but all actions, settlements, and final confirmations take place on Solana.
At the same time, the user's wallet itself should reside within the Solana block space. After a long and in-depth development process, the Lollipop team has finally achieved the current Lollipop design.
Lollipop enables projects to modify the Solana client in an off-chain execution environment and seamlessly transfer the execution result back to the Solana mainnet, avoiding the need for creating a separate chain. Solana itself lacks a global state tree, which is crucial for ensuring the secure settlement of off-chain execution results. Lollipop addresses this issue by introducing Sparse Merkle Trees (SMT) in its Network Extension to cryptographically verify the execution result.
Key technical features:
· Off-chain Execution Environment: Lollipop allows dApps to process their complex logic off-chain while ensuring that the result of each operation can be cryptographically verified through Sparse Merkle Trees, ensuring security and integrity.
· Sparse Merkle Trees (SMT): SMT is a special type of Merkle tree used to verify the existence of a particular piece of data without storing all data. It enables Lollipop to efficiently and securely validate the results of off-chain execution, ensuring these results can reliably settle on the Solana mainnet.
· Seamless Connection to Solana Mainnet: Lollipop achieves a direct connection to the Solana mainnet through its Network Extension, avoiding the fragmentation issues of traditional L2 or sharded chains and ensuring the consistency of liquidity and user base.
Advantages of this technology:
· No Need for Creating a Separate Chain: Projects no longer need to create an additional chain or ecosystem but can modify the Solana client through Lollipop to achieve off-chain execution. This reduces both development and operational costs while ensuring tight integration with the Solana mainnet.
· Decentralized and Secure: By using Sparse Merkle Trees for cryptographic verification, Lollipop ensures that off-chain execution results are not tampered with or inconsistent.
· Compatibility with Solana dApps: Lollipop enables decentralized applications on Solana to better scale their functionality while avoiding performance and security issues that off-chain environments may introduce, making it an ideal choice for Solana dApps.
The approach of Lollipop provides Solana with an innovative solution to enhance scalability and operational efficiency without introducing fragmentation, making it an indispensable part of the future Solana ecosystem.

Figure 7: Lollipop Conceptual Diagram
The Lollipop architecture consists of several main components:
1. Network Extensions Layer (NE Layer)
2. Programs on Solana Layer
3. Polkadot Cloud Layer
Lollipop is built directly on Solana, leveraging its parallel processing capabilities and unique transaction data structure. The parallel processing capability of the Solana Virtual Machine (SVM) relies on the Solana client itself. By modifying the Solana client, Lollipop maximizes the performance gains from Solana's native advantages.
This architecture enables decentralized applications (dApps) to seamlessly migrate from Solana's L1 to Lollipop's NE Layer without any modifications to their program code. At the same time, it consumes fewer resources while supporting the same tools and developer stack as Solana.
It is important to note that SVM's parallel processing is based on Solana's unique transaction data structure. In each transaction, the initiator predeclares the account information they intend to read from and write to. This allows the SVM to efficiently process a batch of transactions in parallel based on this account information, ensuring that concurrently executed transactions do not simultaneously read from and write to the same account. In other words, simply porting the SVM to another execution framework does not yield the benefits of parallel processing.
Lollipop aims to be a trusted supercomputer for network extension, providing both permissioned and permissionless environments, multicore execution, global consistency, customizability, and cost-effectiveness. The Lollipop network offers a complete infrastructure for NE deployment, including shared sequencers, validators, and stateless validated contracts.
By leveraging Polkadot Cloud, Lollipop can also realize itself as Data Availability (DA). Each contract runs on a dedicated core, supporting parallel synchronous execution across validators, sequencers, and DA to ensure efficient processing capabilities.

Figure 8: Lollipop Architecture Diagram
Lollipop's Network Extension (NE) is a significant advancement to enhance the functionality of dApps and protocols within the Solana ecosystem. By providing a new development approach for dApps and protocols in the Solana ecosystem, Lollipop ensures seamless integration with the Solana mainnet while maintaining a monolithic architecture and avoiding chain fragmentation. Unlike traditional Layer 2 solutions that often create isolated environments leading to liquidity fragmentation, Lollipop ensures liquidity and user base remain unified across both tiers through its direct connection to Solana.
Lollipop's Network Extension (NE) offers developers a generic framework to create custom runtime environments to meet specific requirements for different use cases. In particular, the Network Extension (NE) can provide a more efficient operation for a perpetual decentralized exchange (Perp DEX) by deploying a speed-optimized SVM instance. They can also reduce the user interface and user experience friction for decentralized applications (dApps) in the Solana ecosystem by introducing Intent and Account Abstraction. This capability could act as a catalyst for Web3 gaming growth on Solana.
The NE instances, along with Solana's configuration independence, further pave the way for enterprise-grade products, institutional solutions, PayFi applications, and even niche applications such as insurance products.
Ultimately, Lollipop's design offers a forward-looking solution for the scalability of dApps on Solana, laying the foundation for a new era of high-performance blockchain environments. As the Solana ecosystem continues to grow, Lollipop's unique architecture positions it as a key driver of future innovations, providing developers with the tools they need to build secure, efficient, and sustainable applications.
Lollipop Related Links:
Twitter: x.com/LollipopHQ
Blog: medium.com/@LollipopBuilders
Website: https://www.lollipop.builders/
Litepaper: https://lollipop.builders/research
This article is submitted by a contributor and does not represent the views of BlockBeats.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia