Why you can swap Bitcoin for many things, but not buy anything with IT 
Original article by Brett Scott& NBSP;
Compiled by 0x71 Beat BlockBeats
In 2008, Satoshi Nakamoto published a white paper on Bitcoin, calling it "a peer-to-peer electronic currency system," envisioning that "a true peer-to-peer electronic currency should allow direct online payments from the originator to the other party, without the need to go through a third-party financial service institution."
Since its inception, there has been a lot of debate about whether Bitcoin is money or not. Through a series of thought experiments, author Brett Scott clarifies a lot of discourse about Bitcoin as a currency in the current crypto media, and disproves the view that Bitcoin will replace the conventional currency. Through this article, we believe that readers will have a deeper understanding of Bitcoin and the nature of money.
The following is the original:
用比特币交换相机
I designed this image to illustrate the concept of "Countertrade," a key concept if you want to understand how a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin works. The picture is intended to show that a person who "buys" an item with bitcoin, such as a camera, is ultimately paying for it in dollars.
I'll explain this in detail in the next article. But I'm writing this because there's so much misinformation about bitcoin in the media right now. If you follow the news, you're bound to see a lot of excited pundits saying that "digital money" is being adopted to replace regular money. This article will help you see through the facts by introducing you to the concept of "trade-offs," which will take you deeper than most analysts. Let's imagine a supermarket.
At a very early age, children learn to distinguish between different currencies and all the items on supermarket shelves.
Imagine yourself as a kid who gets a $25 allowance from your parents and walks into a supermarket. The money is in your hand, but when you see it, your mind jumps to things other than the money. Maybe you think of candy, toys, or children's magazines on your shelves. You know these items are made by different companies and serve different purposes. But as you know, these items all have prices, and these prices use a common symbol that allows people to compare goods.
As you walk through the shelves, you calculate the combination of goods that $25 can buy. Maybe you could buy five packs of candy for $5, or a toy for $15 and a magazine for $10, or a football for $25. This mental process does not compare goods with money, but rather evaluates different goods with money.
货币体系有一个非常有趣的特性,那就是无所不在:所有商品都有价格;然而奇怪的是,它也不可见:你的大脑被计算所占据,想着哪种商品比其他商品价值更高。当你评估商品价格时,潜意识里,你在通过一个共同的衡量标准(这就是货币的「记账单位」功能),将该商品与其他商品进行比较。确实,如果没有提前知道其他商品的价格,要评估一个商品的价格几乎不可能。例如,你知道 500 美元一杯的咖啡很荒谬,是因为你曾看到 5 美元就可以买一个面包。价格是一个关系概念,商品在同一个货币体系里相互比较。你会自动拒绝这样一杯昂贵的咖啡,纯粹是通过直觉意识到其他商品是如何定价的。
So when you -- the kid in the supermarket -- ask yourself, "Is this football really worth $25?" ", you're dealing secretly with the question "Is this football really equal to five candy bars, or a toy and a magazine?" This thought process.
Imagine you're in the supermarket mulling over these choices, but your parents are urging you to hurry, they want to leave the supermarket. So you need to make a decision as soon as possible. You panic under the pressure and hastily decide to spend the entire $25 on football. After you spend it, you suddenly regret it and realize that you don't really like football and would rather have the other combination. You suddenly turn around and rush back to the store, football in hand, pointing to the toys and candy section, tearfully explaining to the cashier. The cashier, understanding the situation, smiled and said, "So you'd rather have a toy and candy?"
At this point, the cashier has two choices. They can take the ball back, refund you $25, and you're back to where you started. You can walk around the store with your money and pick up new items to the checkout counter as you did before. Alternatively, the cashier can take the ball back, but without a refund, and simply allow you to choose items of equal value. Let's say the cashier chooses the latter option, and you hand in the football and take back a toy and two candy bars.
Let's take another twist in this thought experiment and imagine an alien observing this interaction from outer space through a powerful telescope. What did they see? They see you hand the cashier a ball and get a toy and candy. If aliens were really lazy analysts, they might think the ball is a form of "currency" that you're just using to "buy" toys and candy.
Of course, we know the real story, and it's not about buying toys and candy with balls. It's the exchange of one good worth $25 for another good worth $25. The technical term for this process is "trade-off". There are many forms of "offset transactions," but they all involve goods priced in currencies that offset each other (settle or net settle). An offset transaction actually compresses two monetary transactions into one non-monetary transaction: Technically, the child "resells" the football to the cashier for $25, and then uses the money to buy new goods, but the end result appears to be a ball in exchange for new goods. The currency would still be dollars, not soccer balls, but there would be no public transfer of dollars.
Let's change the scene. Imagine now that you're an adult and you win $25,000 in the lottery. You are very happy, but face similar choices as children who get allowance. A very large number of goods are priced under the same currency system in the "great supermarket" of the whole economy. Should you spend that $25,000 on a range of goods, such as a vacation, a used motorbike, some Apple stock, a high-quality camera, and an antique guitar? Or should you spend it on something big, like a car or a renovation of your house? Or should you use all your money to buy the limited number of bitcoins your trading partners have been talking about? Here are three possible combinations.
Suppose, on impulse, you choose the latter. You go to a website called Coinbase, which is like a supermarket for digital currency. You bought a bitcoin for $25,000. Ten minutes later, you suddenly feel remorse and realize that you'd rather have a classical guitar, camera and car.
There is no "cashier" to run back to like a child. However, you can go back to Coinbase, sell your bitcoin again, and get back $25,000 (assuming the price hasn't changed dramatically since you signed on). You can use the money to buy what you actually want.
Then, imagine that you're still holding Bitcoins, but discover an online camera store that accepts Bitcoins as payment. You find the camera you're looking for, and you notice that the online store offers a choice of prices in U.S. dollars and bitcoin. The dollar price is $5,000. Bitcoin prices indicate that the camera requires "0.2 BTC." You browse the site for a while, and when you return to the camera page, you find that the price has been reset and it now shows "0.21BTC." Five minutes later, the price was "0.19BTC" again. You go back to the dollar price screen, and the list price is still $5,000.
The reason for this is simple. The actual cost of the camera is $5,000. That's the real price. However, the store keeps asking Bitcoin exchanges like Coinbase how many Bitcoins they need to sell in order to get $5,000. That amount fluctuates with the price of bitcoin against the dollar (reflecting its relationship to other commodities through the monetary system). If you choose to pay bitcoin for the camera, the store will accept it and immediately sell the bitcoin on Coinbase for $5,000.
Another way to do the same thing is to sell your bitcoins, get $5,000, and give the dollars to the store. As it stands, the store offers to help you sell your bitcoins, which is why they're asking for $5,000 worth of bitcoins. This is called a reciprocal trade. The price of the camera dollar stays the same, while the price of Bitcoin fluctuates simply because the latter is not a price tag: it is simply a ratio of transactions against each other. The camera's currency price is offset by the bitcoin currency price, leaving only the exchange rate between them. Because bitcoin's currency price is constantly changing through speculative market transactions, online stores have to constantly change exchange rates to maintain the $5,000 price.
Many theories about bitcoin are based on the idea that it is challenging the monetary system. In a limited way, it is. If many people start trading against each other indirectly in dollar-priced digital currencies, rather than buying goods directly in dollars, it could affect the surface of the monetary system. I myself have used bitcoin on many occasions to trade against each other.
But make no mistake. Just as a child's exchange of balls for toys does not disrupt the Federal Reserve system, where dollar issues are priced, the exchange of dollar-denominated bitcoins for dollar-denominated commodities does not fundamentally change the structure of the monetary system.
In fact, a cryptocurrency trade-off can only work if bitcoin is first priced in dollars on the speculative market, which in turn allows it to trade with other items at prices in the consumer goods market. This is fundamentally different from the real monetary system, which is used to establish relative values between different commodities in all markets. We can say that Bitcoin has a very high degree of trade-off, which is not a trivial asset, and it's useful.
However, it is important to be able to distinguish between the object of an "offset transaction" and the currency, and very few people can do this right now, which is why the media has been flooded with stories about Bitcoin as a "currency". Unlike soccer balls, which are clearly not money, Bitcoin is surrounded by monetary language and branding, pre-packaged as a currency myth (think of a moveable ball with a currency image attached to it). This makes it easy to confuse Bitcoin with actual money.
Bitcoins only become real money when a child (or adult) takes them and imagines how much they can buy in a supermarket, rather than how much they can sell for. The key sign of money is that when you hold it, your mind doesn't think of money, but of the goods on the shelf. Right now, Bitcoin is the opposite. It comes from a digital "shelf" in a digital supermarket and then reminds people of the dollar (or whatever other currency they use). This means that Bitcoin can be used for "trade-offs" rather than "purchases."
Finally, we use this theory to analyze the latest news from El Salvador. El Salvador's president, Nayib Bukele, has claimed that Bitcoin is the "national currency" there. This is not true. Mr Bukele is simply pushing people to use bitcoin for "trade-offs". They don't use bitcoin to set "prices" for goods. Bitcoin's currency price is still based on the international speculative market (far from El Salvador and disconnected from local activity). But in Salvadoran stores, bitcoin can be used to calculate the exchange rate for goods priced in dollars (the country uses the U.S. dollar).
Once you know that, many of the conclusions about Bitcoin become clearer. In the future, I'll post more guides like this to help you navigate the crypto community's language games.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia