header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Crisis apocalypse: the rise and fall of the repo model and the end of a decade-long bull market

Read this article in 15 Minutes
Let t's return to the original investment value: focus on trading platform performance growth and ecological construction of Taiwan dollars.

Original author:William & NBSP; principal investigator, OKEx Research;


In the early spring of 2018, the northern hemisphere was just beginning to recover. Although the price of bitcoin continued to plunge after it peaked in January, it did not hinder the public's good hopes for the future development of digital currency and blockchainThey have launched their own Taiwan dollar, and has opened the Taiwan dollar buyback destruction mode. When the time comes to 2019, the Taiwan dollar buyback destruction mode has become the consensus of the industry, and all parties continue to increase, have said that more trading platform business revenue will be included in the buyback funds.


In the spring of 2019, apple, the world's leading technology company, announced a $23.8 billion quarterly stock buyback, the largest by a stock in the s&p 500. In fact, apple has been buying back a lot of its own stock for nearly a decade, and as of the third quarter of 2019, it had nine of the top 10 stock buybacks.




In fact, it's not just star companies like apple that do share buybacks. Since the subprime crisis in 2008, the stock repurchase scale of major listed companies in the United States has increased significantly. According to S&P DJI, U.S. stock buybacks in the past decade have reached $5.160.9 billion, with information technology, finance and consumer goods among the top three sectors, while energy, raw materials and health care topped $100 billion.



Many people have asked me what I think of the Taiwan dollar's buyback destruction model. A leaf to know the spring and autumn, a tea floating. From this decade in the u. s. stock buyback tide can understand a thing or two: the u. s. stock buyback is an important driver of the bull market in the u. s. a decade; But while buybacks have driven up asset prices, they have also created many pitfalls, the most serious of which is corporate finance.


In March 2020, the dow Jones industrial average plunged 6,000 points to the market level of a year ago, after a year of hard work and a night before liberation. If investors in coinage don't see the words "S&P 500", they think it's a waterfall caused by a copycat running away.


At the same time, under the impact of the two "black swans" -- the epidemic and the oil price -- the grey rhinoceros, whose corporate debt problems are caused by the repo model, has begun to move. With little room for fiscal and monetary policy, if corporate debt is not dealt with properly, the us could slip into a new recession.


After a decade of yangzhou dream, the 10-year bull market dream of American stocks woke up, and the decade only confirmed a sentence: "buyback is the cheapest, the most lazy, and the most fragile business model in this era of restlessness."


1. & have spent


Around 2018, I got to know A domestic fund manager, who once joked in his circle of friends: "the us stock market was slow in ten years, and the s&p 500 index rose nearly three times; on the other hand, the a-share market did nothing for ten years, with 3,000 points ten years ago, and 3,000 points ten years later. & have spent




The past decade has been a spectacular one for U.S. stocks, with the s&p 500's cumulative return of 290% and annualized return of 14.6% from the start of 2009 to the end of 2019, not counting dividends. So why did stocks rise for a decade? One of the most important reasons lies in the share repurchase behavior of listed companies.


Like the Taiwan dollar's buyback destruction model, share repurchases have at least three benefits: first, they directly reduce the number of shares outstanding in the market and raise the price; Secondly, after the buyback and write-off of the company's shares, the company's price/earnings ratio (EPS) will be increased, the financial indicators will be improved, and the stock price will continue to rise. Finally, American listed companies often adopt the equity incentive mechanism, and the management of many listed companies hold shares, and they will benefit from the rise of the stock price, and the management has the incentive to promote this.


In practice, among the top 1500 companies in the S&P DJI index, the amount of money used by listed companies to buy back shares has risen rapidly since 2010, reaching $800 billion by the end of 2018. More importantly, since 2010, the combined value of share buybacks and mergers and acquisitions has exceeded capital expenditures, meaning that companies have spent most of their money buying shares in listed companies, rather than making additional investments to expand reproduction and raise research and development costs. This is actually quite a dangerous signal, because we know that the growth and value of enterprises come from the physical operation of the business itself, rather than in the financial market capital game, when not goldThe crisis was already brewing when the financial sector devoted too much of its resources to capital market buy-backs or mergers and acquisitions. Many may ask why, if it is so simple, managers do not spend more on capital and research and development, but on share buybacks or mergers and acquisitions to boost share prices. This leads to deeper economic problems.

& have spent



Zhou jintao, the late chief economist of citic construction investment, famously said: "prosperity in life depends on kangbo. The basis of compo cycle is the dominant industrial innovation proposed by American economist rostow. The so-called leading industries are those that play a leading and guiding role in the process of economic growth and play an important role in the whole industrial chain with a strong diffusion effect. According to Jacob van duyneWe are currently in the fifth cycle brought about by information technology.




If you think about it, what started the it industry? Yes, it was thirty or forty years ago. So, in the last decade, have we had a significant innovation-led cluster? No, perhaps you are more familiar with the more commercial transformation of the mobile Internet, and the next round of dominant industrial clusters, mainly 5G, Internet of things and artificial intelligence, is still on the eve of the outbreak. Even the blockchain technology we love to talk about is actually based on the original technology, through a combination of coincidence and birth.


Over the past decade, the global economy has been in the awkward position where such major technological innovations have been slow to break through and a new generation of dominant industrial clusters has failed to form. Listed companies need to consider the input-output ratio of r&d and investment, and major innovation is far from hopeless. Under the professional manager system, the performance of the company's management is often linked to the stock price, EPS and other core financial indicators, so it is natural that the stock buyback becomes the best choice for the management.


It is worth mentioning that zhou jintao predicted that 2019 would be the "year of no return" for kangbo due to his research on the kangbo cycle, and serious liquidity crisis would occur. Of course, we can also see that king zhou's prediction is still a little bit inaccurate. The ongoing global systemic liquidity crisis is three months later than king zhou's prediction.


So how much of an impact does the stock buyback behavior of listed companies have on the bull market? S&P DJI published the S&P 500 repo index in 2012 (S& P 500 Buyback Index, which covers the 100 stocks in the s&p 500 with the highest Buyback ratios in the last year. We can use the "current index/initial index" to compare the market differences caused by share buybacks. Comparing the performance of the two indices, we can see the power of "share buybacks". Since 2013, S& P 500 Buyback Index outperformed S& P 500 is 10% to 30% higher.




Share buybacks are a happy strategy, with large shareholders happy, small investors happy, and management benefiting. But is everything so good? No, because the decade-long share buyback is like a castle on a beach, shaken by its collapse. And it all started with the fed's monetary policy this decade.


2. & have spent & have spent


"It doesn't make sense to lend at 1.4 per cent. It's a very unusual situation where we allow people to borrow at very low rates. Berkshire couldn't borrow 10 years ago." & have spent-- warren buffett, 2020/2


The fed began cutting interest rates in response to the crisis in early 2008, and then flooded the market with liquidity through quantitative easing. It did not announce the end of the third round of QE until late 2016. Stimulated by the loose monetary policy, the broad monetary aggregate in the United States has grown rapidly from $7.4 trillion at the beginning of 2008 to $15.4 trillion today, and the federal funds rate has been near zero for a long time.


With near-zero interest rates and a steady "printing of money" through QE, there is, as Mr Buffett says at the beginning, so much money if it is so cheap. Then why not borrow some money? So American companies borrowed.


The fed's massive release of water is precisely aimed at pumping liquidity into the real economy and boosting the us economy. So what's the effect? The following figure is the data released by the bureau of economic analysis of the United States. Since the financial crisis in 2008, the operating conditions of enterprises in the real economy of the United States have not improved, but further deteriorated. Their net assets have been negative, which means that enterprises are insolvent. And in this decade, the expansion of enterprise assets, all by the increase in debt.


Some friends may ask, since the enterprise is insolvent and on the verge of bankruptcy, it is difficult to obtain credit loans from the bank, so how does it borrow money? Your hunch is right, since you can't borrow from a bank, of course you can issue debt, and you can't issue highly rated bonds, you should issue low-rated subprime bonds. So we've seen the U.S. non-financial corporate sector's lending grow slowly over the last decade, but the size of debt securities has grown rapidly.



What do companies usually borrow to do? Either to maintain production operations, or to invest to expand reproduction. So us non-financial sector companies got a lot of cheap money, and how did they use it? Since 2009, according to data released by the federal reserve, non-financial companies have bought back $3.3 trillion worth of stock through share buybacks, residents and institutions have sold $672 billion and $1.2 trillion of stock, respectively, and mutual funds and etfs have bought $1.6 trillion of stock.Companies have become the biggest receivers of American stocks.From the perspective of the net change in the debt and stock market value of non-financial sector enterprises, they show a significant negative correlation, which means thatMuch of the money companies borrow cheaply is spent on share buybacks.This is consistent with our previous analysis that companies are more likely to invest in share buybacks and mergers and acquisitions than in additional investments as the dominant industry stagnates.& have spent & have spent




3.


Whether a rapid increase in debt is a good thing or a bad thing depends on the outcome of the debt and its repayment. Since credit creates both purchasing power and debt, whether increased credit is good or bad depends on whether borrowing can be used for productive purposes, thereby generating enough income to service principal and interest. -- Ray Dalio, founder of bridgewater fund

As Mr Dalio points out, if debt is used for productive purposes, and debt service is guaranteed, then such debt will surely boost the economy, allocating resources better and benefiting both the debtor and the bond. Yet American public companies borrow not to invest in production, but mainly for share buybacks or mergers in the capital markets. Share repurchase has brought two effects in the financial market: one is to whitewashing the performance of listed companies, whose price/earnings ratio (EPS) has been greatly improved; the other is to cause the separation of volume and price. In the normal market, share price rise is often accompanied by huge trading volume, while share repurchase has successfully broken this market rule. According to Wind, since the economic crisis almost ended in 2010, the p/e ratio of the s&p 500 has risen from 14 times to about 22 times, and the s&p 500 has nearly tripled, while daily trading volume has fallen nearly 30%.


Therefore, the growth of us corporate debt in this decade has not contributed much to the real economy of the us. It merely whitewashed the company's earnings (EPS), raised the stock price, and turned the us stock market into a financial market with high valuation, high debt and low growth.




In normal economic times, these games work perfectly. Companies, however, are unlikely to add leverage forever buybacks, investors also can never bear losses, once interest rates began to rise for the market, or the economic downturn worsened significantly cause company fundamentals, so the company's debt would considerably increase the cost of financing, stock repurchase is unable to continue, this game is also the final ending: the stock market crash.


In March 2020, affected by the global epidemic and the drop in oil prices, both commodity futures and stocks plunged, while the dow Jones industrial average plunged 8000 points and the s&p 500 index fell 26.97%, leading to a global liquidity crisis. Even the release of $500 billion of liquidity by the New York fed in the early hours of March 13th did not stop the market from tumbling.


If the liquidity crisis intensifies, it will deal a major blow to highly indebted companies. According to the minsheng securities research team, the debt repayment pressure of us companies will peak in the third quarter of 2020. The only solution is to inject liquidity into the market again. At present, the us federal funds rate has been cut nearly 50 basis points, and the target rate remains at 1.25%. On the other hand, while the us economy was still growing normally when Mr Trump came to power, he rushed to implement tax cuts worth $4.4 trillion, the biggest tax reform since the Reagan era. Having run out of ammunition in peacetime, there is little room for fiscal policy in difficult times. So in the future, the fed is likely to resume quantitative easing.


The current panic in the global financial market caused by the outbreak of disease and the collapse of oil prices is still a "black swan". The corporate debt problem of the us non-financial sector is the real "grey rhino". If the us government does not properly handle this risk, then the us stock market will plunge again and the us economy will have a minsky moment.


4.


As we have said before, share buybacks can only improve the share price of listed companies and whitewash their p/e ratio, but they do nothing to help the company's value and growth. Not only that, but also easy to cause financial crisis. The buyback destruction mode of Taiwan dollar is the same. The value of Taiwan dollar is based on the digital currency trading platform. In the long run, Taiwan dollar price is linked to the strength and performance growth of the digital currency trading platform, and is directly related to the ecological construction around Taiwan dollar. Even if more of the currency is destroyed and the trading platform collapses or goes out of business, the value of the currency will go back to zero. In fact, the lightning storm of the Fcoin trading platform is a true reflection of this problem. The one-time destruction of 700 million FT held by the Fcoin team directly triggered a deeper crisis within the exchange, which eventually led to the demise of the Fcoin exchange.


I believe there are a number of second-tier trading platforms that are under market pressure to follow the buyback destruction strategy, but are under severe financial pressure. Even the head exchange, quanan, announced the preferred buyback team's airbnb last year, raising questions about lending shares to the buyback team to ease its cash crunch.


On the face of it, the repo destruction model is a strategy that investors and trading platforms are happy with. But on the other hand, why are we playing a game of money with no real value? To OKEx, fire COINS and coin AnSanDa head trading platform as an example, each quarter will spend millions or tens of millions of dollars buy flat t, if we take the money out, each quarterly report on time: how many money to Taiwan's ecological construction, how much money for trading platform research and development and technical upgrading, how much money for the development of chain and DApp. Will this be more beneficial to the value of Taiwan dollar and long-term development?


For now, OKEx is the first platform to recognize this. While other trading platforms have said they will include more revenue in the buyback destruction fund, many have asked when OKEx will announce it will include contract revenue in the buyback fund, and the company's official line has always been to "consider future inclusion." From the author's point of view, it is wise to do so. First, the platform could have more money to spend on product development and technology upgrades. Second, and more importantly, it leaves plenty of ammunition for the Taiwan dollar's future, just in case it needs to be -- and you'll remember that trump's massive tax cuts and interest rate cuts in normal times have left him in trouble.


Many people ask: "didn't OKEx destroy 700 million okbs in one go and trigger other trading platforms to follow?" But in my opinion, these following digital currency trading platforms have only scratched the surface of OKEx's destruction strategy, not the surface. This is actually an exchange with the market, in exchange for 700 million OKB platform and public chain in the future better development. Anyone with economic knowledge knows that when the money supply does not grow as fast as the economy, it tends to cause a depression. Trading platform public chain is mostly based on the future financial infrastructure as the positioning, the construction of DeFi ecology. Use were destroyed repurchase, the decreasing number of flat t as the underlying Token, finally will only lead to ecological chain of depression, because with the enlargement of the public ecological chain, the community demand for Token will increase, due to the lack of Token community developers can only choose to leave, that is why the etheric lane in the design of the ETH used when issuing the cause of the inflation mechanism. OKEx actually exchanged 700 million okbs for the distribution right of Token -- OKT -- at the bottom of the common chain of OKChain. From this point of view, we have to admire OKEx's precise strategic vision and sophisticated market means.


It is time to abandon the idea that the Taiwan dollar needs to be repurchased and destroyed. Instead of pursuing the short-term benefits brought by the repurchase and destruction, let the Taiwan dollar return to its original investment value -- focusing on the performance growth of the trading platform and ecological construction of the Taiwan dollar.


The original address: https://finance.sina.cn/blockchain/2020-03-16/detail-iimxyqwa0854506.d.html? The from = wap




Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit