header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
한국어
日本語
ภาษาไทย
Türkçe
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

The crypto industry is rekindling the debate on “Who Should Hold the Private Key” following the $13 million theft from the Coldcard wallet.

BlockBeats News, August 10th, a wallet security incident involving around $130 million worth of Bitcoin loss is reigniting the cryptocurrency industry's debate on asset custody models: whether Bitcoin holders should rely on individual self-custody or turn to institutional custody.


Hardware wallet manufacturer Coldcard had a firmware vulnerability in 2021 that led to a random number generation flaw, causing the devices to generate mnemonic phrases with predictable risks. This vulnerability was discovered years later, and currently, around 5,200 addresses holding approximately 2,000 BTC were stolen, resulting in a loss of about $130 million.


Following the incident, some investors started turning to Wall Street custody products. Data shows that the US Bitcoin spot ETF saw a net inflow of around $626 million in the days after the event. Bloomberg ETF analyst Eric Balchunas stated that such security incidents may further drive funds into ETFs.


However, the Bitcoin core community still advocates for self-custody. Casa co-founder Jameson Lopp stated that the recent event should not weaken users' confidence in self-custody and pointed out that third-party custody also carries risks. Bitcoin Core early developer Peter Todd also believes that self-custody has a better long-term security track record than centralized institutions.


Bitcoin custody platform Onramp co-founder Michael Tanguma, on the other hand, believes that both solutions have drawbacks. He mentioned that consolidating a significant amount of assets in a single institution creates a "honey pot," while hardware wallets face risks such as the supply chain, firmware, and random number generation.


Tanguma proposed a "multi-institutional custody" solution, where multiple regulated institutions hold keys through a multi-signature mechanism, requiring multiple institutions to jointly sign off on any transaction to reduce the risk of a single point of failure.


However, this model has also sparked controversy. Critics argue that although multi-institutional custody enhances security, it also introduces permissioned management, conflicting with Bitcoin's original pursuit of decentralization.


As Bitcoin gradually enters the pension, trust, and institutional asset allocation fields, the industry is seeking new custody solutions suitable for long-term wealth management. The Coldcard vulnerability incident once again highlights that balancing security, decentralization, and usability remains a core challenge facing the Bitcoin ecosystem.

Correction/Report
Submit
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish